Y’all are trippin the world shifted with the savage remix!!!!!! 
 

“hips TikTok when I dance..”

Edited September 21, 20232 yr by sillycilla

Ugh this is all Yvette is here for

 

https://x.com/narcissegroove/status/1704901612483838314?s=46&t=DBEzweI3pkN0q0I7VG8vbQ

 

Edit: I thought this was real lol

 

Edited September 21, 20232 yr by sillycilla

30 minutes ago, kimberly said:

is anyone paying her $24M for a 60-minute show?

Isnt she getting paid by Saudi Arabia to perform one song for $3M? Let’s say the performance takes 5min, then Shakira is getting $48M per hour  

 

edit: bringing up Dubai is crazy. Kimmy, you’re grasping at straws  

Edited September 21, 20232 yr by Blue Rose

Another day of the same tired complaints. The 8 months until act ii are gonna be awful.

17 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

I think you don’t understand what gaslighting is. You are using specific examples to undermine what we are actually seeing in the numbers isn’t real. 
 

And the data I was referring to wasn’t just about Shakira only.   
 

But let’s go down this list, yes she has toured stadiums, she just announced an actual world tour. She’s still incredibly favored by her main demographic and is a still able to garner massive numbers despite being older. Beyoncé is struggling in her main demographic, US, and can’t get people to listen to her old music. Shakira’s popularity is rising while Beyoncé is not even top 40 most streamed artist. 
 

How long will Beyoncé be able to tour stadiums if no one is listening to her music, new and old?

ARE people listening to Shakira's old music or are bulk of her streams coming from Karol G and Bizarrap collaborations?

 

let's examine:

 

Daily streams for Shakira's singles from 2017's El Dorado:

 

Chantaje (with Maluma) - 270k

Me Enamore - 79k

Perro Fiel - (with Nicky Jam) - 110k

Trap (with Maluma again) - 10k 

Nada - 7k

 

WHO IS GASLIGHTING WHO MAMA?

was this REALLY that hard to do ? give the people what they want you mad woman

 

 

 

compare those to Lemonade singles (sabotaged Spotify release):

 

Formation - 156k

Hold Up - 68k

Sorry - 70k

All Night - 46k

Freedom 32k

 

nothing to GLOAT, but even Lemonade album tracks like Daddy Lessons are out streaming her Maluma featuring hit single by threefold.

Next month, Bey will be the second female artist to have two songs released before 2010 over 1 billion streams. The other one is not Shakira, just saying. 

 

 

It's cute people still think act ii is happening. This convo will be going on for a while because it's relevant. 

 

I did see a tweet that said Houston gets Megan and Travis and New Orleans will most likely get Big Freeda, what does that mean for KC? Hopefully the visuals.

Just now, carameldelight said:

I did see a tweet that said Houston gets Megan and Travis and New Orleans will most likely get Big Freeda, what does that mean for KC?

perfume samplers and a recycled outfit or two, maybe a new ugly IVY PARK outfit 

8 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

was this REALLY that hard to do ? give the people what they want you mad woman

 

 

 

She hates giving the people what they want. 

I don't care to argue anymore about WHY Beyoncé should or should not be doing anything, but why do the SAME complaints need to be said over and over and over? At what point will we just accept that this is how Beyoncé is, and is going to be? Has any of the many complaints ever changed things? Do you feel better after complaining? And if so, why does it continue?

 

It's been the same talking points it since 2013. Why spend a decade being mad at Beyoncé for not promoting or whatever...at some point you're going to have to let it go and focus on enjoying the music, the era, the tour, the remixes...(and the parfum).

 

 

Edited September 21, 20232 yr by swissman

why the hell are yall talking about shakira 

3 minutes ago, PrettyHurts said:

why the hell are yall talking about shakira 

 

 

2 minutes ago, swissman said:

I don't care to argue anymore about WHY Beyoncé should or should not be doing anything, but why do the SAME complaints need to be said over and over and over? At what point will we just accept that this is how Beyoncé is, and is going to be? Has any of the many complaints ever changed things? Do you feel better after complaining? And if so, why does it continue?

 

It's been the same talking points it since 2013. Why spend a decade being mad at Beyoncé for not promoting or whatever...at some point you're going to have to let it go and focus on enjoying the music, the era, the tour, the remixes...(and the parfum).

 

 

Its actually quite easy to explain why: because there is nothing else to talk about.

Do you want to talk about a perfume? Wait, no one has smelled it yet, sry.

Do you want to talk about the tour? But there are no changes, so also same old since 5 months.

Do you want to talk about her albums and do rating things? Also same old.

Do you want to talk about some fan theories that have nothing to them aside from being cute dreams? 

 

Like, we might as well close the thread then till sth happens cause there is nothing to talk about and there wont be anything to talk about cause she makes sure no one talks about her, the recording etc.

haha was just watching this video essay/commentary video that came out today and this British YouTuber used "Pretty Hurts" as the title credit song.

 

seems like people remember it! and daily Spotify streams are a trivial metric.

 

 

11 minutes ago, PrettyHurts said:

why the hell are yall talking about shakira 

Chiiiile, that’s what happens when you get gaslit into a side conversation that was never the main point.  
 

Had to let it go. 

ST: Music videos for every song upon release, docu series about the concept and making of, speech at art univeristy in new york, grammy performance, brits performance, hbo x10 tour performances series, platinum edition, 15 minute VMA medley, HBO concert special for a SECOND tour in support of the album, BET performance

 

Lemonade: Superbowl, movie upon release, BET performance, CMA performance, ANOTHER 15 minute VMA medley, 10 minute Grammy performance, tidal special concert, her first full stadium solo tour, 

 

Renai:ssance 

 

I'm sorry but the complaining, hostility and lashings are well deserved and nowhere as bad as they should be. 

The sabotaged singles releases/commercial strategies are one thing, whatever, but when you don't even bother to give some content to the legions of fans who have taken you to the 'can do whatever tf I want' position you are in nowadays is extremely distasteful. Like, this **** stopped being funny LAST september. 

 

I hope the complaining and lashing will transform into REAL backlash soon. I know frm me it's gonna be Youtube mp3 converter with miss Knwoles from now. That is if she ever bothers to puts out something again after this. 

7 minutes ago, kimberly said:

haha was just watching this video essay/commentary video that came out today and this British YouTuber used "Pretty Hurts" as the title credit song.

 

seems like people remember it! and daily Spotify streams are a trivial metric.

 

 

Isn't this the definition of anecdotal evidence??? 

5 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

when you get gaslit

open a dictionary  repeating I gaslit you won't make it true.

 

6 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

Had to let it go. 

conveniently after I showed you the receipts of your made up perception

Y'all constantly complain how there's nothing to talk about yet somehow manage to produce a few pages everyday  More than any other Base that I follow

It's absurd but I'm gon' say those three words

Yes, I do,

I think it's true,

I just know

I love you

 

the fact we don’t know what “three words” she meant. Her mind 

Just now, carameldelight said:

Isn't this the definition of anecdotal evidence??? 

yes, I said I just came across it.

 

there's no science to defining someone's status as a legend and how "well remembered" they are. it's all qualitative mama.

 

* unless some serious organization randomly decides to run an actual research study about this question only ATRL thinks about.

2 minutes ago, kimberly said:

open a dictionary  repeating I gaslit you won't make it true.

 

conveniently after I showed you the receipts of your made up perception

You lack comprehension it’s ok.

 

And you think you won an argument because I ignored and didn’t reply? Lmao, girl ok. 
 

Everything you posted is easily refutable, I just didn’t care to engage anymore on that. 

Anyway, new show tonight and no more than three days between shows until the end of the tour.