Respectfully, why would a Gangsta Boo album be any more likely to draw in participants than, say, Outkast?

6 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Respectfully, why would a Gangsta Boo album be any more likely to draw in participants than, say, Outkast?

Oh, I wasn't saying she's the draw. Feel like I didn't phrase what I meant right because it was 8am here and my ass was still half-asleep gajglkflkf

 

It was more so me saying the average ATRLer might be more inclined to take part with an all-female line-up but looking at the line-ups now I'm like "no girl, nobody's sitting through some of those"

Though Stankonia might be a better idea re: OutKast considering it's not, you know, a double album

20 minutes ago, conatus said:

Though Stankonia might be a better idea re: OutKast considering it's not, you know, a double album

Stankonia vs. Miss E….So Addictive

 

Oh, I’m seeing the vision

2 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Stankonia vs. Miss E….So Addictive

 

Oh, I'm seeing the vision

Now we're cooking. Walk with me.

 

Are we thinking acclaimed or are we thinking popular? Because these could be 2 very different rates... (One might have The Notorious KIM in, one might not, you know?)

Edited August 7, 2025Aug 7 by conatus

Throw in The Blueprint. I’m not exactly sure how you sell that theme, but why not?

The rap blockblusters of the new millennium: The Marshall Mathers LP vs. Nellyville vs. Get Rich or Die Tryin’

3 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

The rap blockblusters of the new millennium: The Marshall Mathers LP vs. Nellyville vs. Get Rich or Die Tryin'

As someone who looked at the unfinished TW2000 rate thread recently, let's just say... people weren't happy about having to listen to one of these albums then. I imagine they'd even less happy now. Ratings poison tbh.

 

1 minute ago, conatus said:

As someone who looked at the unfinished TW2000 rate thread recently, let's just say... people weren't happy about having to listen to one of these albums then. I imagine they'd even less happy now. Ratings poison tbh.

 

So we’re going to continue to let ATRLers being losers deter us from doing anything fun?

1 minute ago, supaspaz said:

So we're going to continue to let ATRLers being losers deter us from doing anything fun?

No. But since when was listening to M&M fun

 

 

Wouldn't you rather do Miss E..., Stankonia, The Blueprint, and The Notorious KIM?

 

1 hour ago, conatus said:

No. But since when was listening to M&M fun

 

 

Wouldn't you rather do Miss E..., Stankonia, The Blueprint, and The Notorious KIM?

 

Well, you’ll notice I put him in the blockbusters rate rather the critically acclaimed rate (even though the critics loved him…)

2 hours ago, conatus said:

Wouldn't you rather do Miss E..., Stankonia, The Blueprint, and The Notorious KIM?

 

I'd do this one.

 

1 hour ago, Graves said:

I'd do this one.

 

Oh I'm sure

 

4 hours ago, conatus said:

Wouldn't you rather do Miss E..., Stankonia, The Blueprint, and The Notorious KIM?

 

Could just call it something simple like the New Millennium Rap rate idk. Titles are hard.

 

5 hours ago, supaspaz said:

Respectfully, why would a Gangsta Boo album be any more likely to draw in participants than, say, Outkast?

Because then we'd be including Three 6 Mafia with/through her who would be coming to sweep with a perfect 10 average

1 minute ago, Reverie said:

Because then we'd be including Three 6 Mafia with/through her who would be coming to sweep with a perfect 10 average

You see the vision

 

1 minute ago, conatus said:

You see the vision

 

 

Hip Hop and Hoes of Horror: Mystic Stylez vs Juju vs Hellbilly Deluxe vs Thriller vs Dr. Ev4l vs whatever that Kim Petras one is 

 

Vision???!?

 

5 minutes ago, Reverie said:

 

Hip Hop and Hoes of Horror: Mystic Stylez vs Juju vs Hellbilly Deluxe vs Thriller vs Dr. Ev4l vs whatever that Kim Petras one is 

 

Probably a better turnout than the Feminem and Smelly rate

 

Edited August 7, 2025Aug 7 by conatus

5 minutes ago, Graves said:

Vision???!?

 

A top 5 (ATRL) smash hit  

5 minutes ago, Reverie said:

A top 5 (ATRL) smash hit  

Thank you Ace Reject!

2 minutes ago, Graves said:

Thank you Ace Reject!

Thank you Ace Reject for saving my life! 

7 hours ago, conatus said:

Though Stankonia might be a better idea re: OutKast considering it's not, you know, a double album

it was the cd era, they all go on a bit tbh (aquemini ftw really)

Hi @Ace Reject! The Lady Gaga's Discography ATRL Megarate has officially concluded, with Brooklyn Nights as the Unreleased Discography's winner with an overall average score of 8.594 and with Abracadabra as the Official Discography's winner with an overall average score of 9.797!

 

 

 

Thank you once again for approving it and allowing me to host it!

Quote

Sorry!

You do not have permission to view this topic.