4 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

The concept of Fergie beating Neko Case and Joanna to the finish in the 2006 rate 

 

Fergalicious vs. Monkey & Bear vs. Thank You (Dedication to Fans...)... This photo finish

 

3 hours ago, Graves said:

I was thinking something less album based, honestly.

 

Mothers and Daughters or something idk

 

4 hours ago, Graves said:

 

...

 

 

 

  Hide contents

C'mon - Caution and Sweetener in the same rate, and you're not salivating? You're not gagging!??!!?

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

C'mon - Caution and Sweetener in the same rate, and you're not salivating? You're not gagging!??!!?

I'm just keeping up the bit at this point.

15 hours ago, conatus said:

See, I was thinking 2006 and 2007 are also rife for the MTW treatment (along with those years you mentioned)

 

2006: Some variation of Back to Black, Loose, B'Day, Back to Basics, The Dutchess, Alright, Still, Corinne Bailey Rae, Fox Confessor Brings the Flood (for you...), could open it up to The Chicks too... I guess we won't be making @Graves suffer through Ys... Unless we throw in (miss)understood for him as a compromise or something idfk

 

2007: Kala, As I Am, Blackout, Good Girl Gone Bad, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, X, The Reminder, White Chalk, The Best Damn Thing, Little Voice

 

Whole lot of variety there idk

 

I can see a three-parter for 2006!

 

1) B'day v. I'm Not Dead v. Loose v. The Duchess v. The Sweet Escape

 

2) Alright Still v. Back to Black v. Corinne Bailey Rae v. Fox Confessor Brings The Flood versus either The Greatest or Ys

 

3) A Public Affair v. Back to Basics v. Oral Fixation Vol 2 v. Taylor Swift v. The Evolution

 

Yeah, that feels right and just!

3 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

I can see a three-parter for 2006!

 

1) B'day v. I'm Not Dead v. Loose v. The Duchess v. The Sweet Escape

 

2) Alright Still v. Back to Black v. Corinne Bailey Rae v. Fox Confessor Brings The Flood versus either The Greatest or Ys

 

3) A Public Affair v. Back to Basics v. Oral Fixation Vol 2 v. Taylor Swift v. The Evolution

 

Yeah, that feels right and just!

This makes sense 

 

part 1 - success 

part 2 - acclaim 

part 3- 

8 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

This makes sense 

 

part 1 - success 

part 2 - acclaim 

part 3- 

You get it. You get it!

 

2007 MTW could be split similarly...

 

1) Blackout v. GGGB v. Dignity v. X v. Terry Murphy 

2) Crazy Ex-Girlfriend v. The Reminder v. Kala v. White Chalk v. Volta

3) My December v. The Best Damn Thing v. Growing Pains v. Just Like You v. Because I Love It

 

 

9 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

 

1) Blackout v. GGGB v. Dignity v. X v. Terry Murphy 

 

Roisin:

 

Xtine getting lumped into the ? category for '06

 

Part 1 and 3 looking lit as ****.

 

17 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

Roisin:

 

Be happy I didn't say Kathy Diamond! Now that's a REAL UOG.

No shade but do we really need Roisin here? Great albums yes but I fear her inclusion might be a turn off for a lot of people given her…..opinions 

1 hour ago, Ace Reject said:

1) B'day v. I'm Not Dead v. Loose v. The Duchess v. The Sweet Escape

I wouldn't mind putting my name in the ring for this one, you know... after I finish up the J-Divas and other things.

22 minutes ago, Ghibli said:

No shade but do we really need Roisin here? Great albums yes but I fear her inclusion might be a turn off for a lot of people given her…..opinions 

And yeah, I'm one of the people who would be turned off by her inclusion. Would rather not give her any attention at all.

28 minutes ago, Ghibli said:

No shade but do we really need Roisin here? Great albums yes but I fear her inclusion might be a turn off for a lot of people given her…..opinions 

 

5 minutes ago, Graves said:

And yeah, I'm one of the people who would be turned off by her inclusion. Would rather not give her any attention at all.

Understood! She's out; Sophie EB can take her place! (and If You Go can be top five, as it was meant.)

9 minutes ago, Graves said:

I wouldn't mind putting my name in the ring for this one, you know... after I finish up the J-Divas and other things.

The concept of you hosting a rate with P!nk in it

 

1 hour ago, Ace Reject said:

2) Alright Still v. Back to Black v. Corinne Bailey Rae v. Fox Confessor Brings The Flood versus either The Greatest or Ys

Not the threat of more Cat Power...

12 minutes ago, Graves said:

I wouldn't mind putting my name in the ring for this one, you know... after I finish up the J-Divas and other things.

You should host part 2 as well

 

Just now, conatus said:

Not the threat of more Cat Power...

I COULD be genius and suggest Bat For Lashes's debut... but why when suffering is fun! (And you'd COME AROUND TO CHAN MARSHALL HER GENIUS.)

Maybe I'm alone in this but something about wildly different albums together seems like more fun to me. Like, yes, I want to see Get Me Bodied, Alfie, and Sawdust & Diamonds battle it out.

 

 

Happy to go along with the consensus though of course.

 

7 minutes ago, conatus said:

The concept of you hosting a rate with P!nk in it

 

 

4 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

You should host part 2 as well

 

You think I won't?

 

2006 Part 2: The first rate with graphics drawn in MS Paint.

 

 

When I only allow a scoring range of 0 - 4.

1 minute ago, Graves said:

2006 Part 2: The first rate with graphics drawn in MS Paint.

 

 

When I only allow a scoring range of 0 - 4.

What did Corinne do to you?

 

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

What did Corinne do to you?

 

Only being the fifth best Rae in pop music is a crime not worth forgiving.

 

17 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

 

Understood! She's out; Sophie EB can take her place! (and If You Go can be top five, as it was meant.)

Oh Me and My Imagination the rate winner you are...