Has there ever been a Ariana Grande rate? If not I think she might be a good candidate for one next.

4 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Has there ever been a Ariana Grande rate? If not I think she might be a good candidate for one next.

Unless there's been another one since that I just can't find, there was one before Sweetener

 

https://classic.atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=999403

Just now, conatus said:

Unless there's been another one since that I just can't find, there was one before Sweetener

 

https://classic.atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=999403

Damn, that was long ago

4 hours ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Has there ever been a Ariana Grande rate? If not I think she might be a good candidate for one next.

I believe @Treacherous has one coming on the near horizon but idk the exact timeline 

And the winner of Ladies of Jazz is...

 

Spoiler

"Strange Fruit" by Billie Holiday!

Why hasn't there been a Motown rate yet?

5 hours ago, Wicked said:

Why hasn't there been a Motown rate yet?

this would be great, "this old heart of mine" ftw (tho ofc it's men so it's hobbling in at #42 or something behind a million supremes hits)

International Madonnas Part One is live!

12 hours ago, Wicked said:

Why hasn't there been a Motown rate yet?

Oh yeah we need that  

I would love a rate of 2023/2024 indie/indie rock albums

 

some of the options for the lineups:

Yeule - Softscars

Nilufer Yanya - My Method Actor

Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

Beabadoobee - This is How Tomorrow Moves

Wednesday - Rat Saw God

Feeble Little Horse - Girl With Fish

Indigo De Souza - All of This Will End

 

I wonder if people would be interested in this? I feel like these are noteworthy enough but it would be a niche rate of like prob 15 participants

1 hour ago, honights said:

I would love a rate of 2023/2024 indie/indie rock albums

 

some of the options for the lineups:

Yeule - Softscars

Nilufer Yanya - My Method Actor

Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

Beabadoobee - This is How Tomorrow Moves

Wednesday - Rat Saw God

Feeble Little Horse - Girl With Fish

Indigo De Souza - All of This Will End

 

I wonder if people would be interested in this? I feel like these are noteworthy enough but it would be a niche rate of like prob 15 participants

Was about to say at the very least @Eeveelution would eat up whatever line-up you settled on but saw he'd already liked it because of course he had

 

I feel like a long time ago I did a rate that had like beabadoobee, Clairo, soccer mommy(?), and others??

 

but im so weathered and haven't used atrl in ages that I don't even remember hosting

 

 

I may be extremely rusty 

23 minutes ago, conatus said:

Was about to say at the very least @Eeveelution would eat up whatever line-up you settled on but saw he'd already liked it because of course he had

 

To offer an outsider perspective, I would try a rate like that (me not knowing any of the music) if there were... 4 or 5 albums maybe?

 

Yeule - Softscars

Nilufer Yanya - My Method Actor

Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

Beabadoobee - This is How Tomorrow Moves

Wednesday - Rat Saw God

 

I feel like this would be the best lineup in that case since it offers a bit of variety for everyone:  shoegaze/dreampop, classic indie rock, americana, pop rock, country rock

 

I do love FLH so if I could sneak them in...  it's only like 26 mins! But I agree 5 is prob the best

The indie pop girl threads here seem to do pretty well so I'm sure it could be a semi-hit rate with the right lineup. 

 

I almost want to say bring back the This WAS rates but I saw how y'all did Japanese Breakfast in the 2021 rate so maybe not.

 

This is also a more (sane) approach to this theme since I initially was like MJ Lenderman and Alex G

The concept of me finally listening to beabadoobee for the rate after refusing to for years because of that stupid ******* name

 

Just now, conatus said:

The concept of me finally listening to beabadoobee for the rate after refusing to for years because of that stupid ******* name

 

The way this is like her weakest album too

 

Beatopia >

 

but I can't stretch to make a 2022 album fit

Just now, honights said:

The way this is like her weakest album too

 

Beatopia >

 

but I can't stretch to make a 2022 album fit

A good friend of mine is a fan and is constantly trying to get me to look past the name so either way they'd be pleased

 

2 minutes ago, conatus said:

The concept of me finally listening to beabadoobee for the rate after refusing to for years because of that stupid ******* name

 

She was on my stan list for a minute but yeah Tomorrow is... not the best starting point I fear.

 

Beatopia the influential STAR you are, can we do a rate that is just random albums I like

10 minutes ago, honights said:

Yeule - Softscars

Nilufer Yanya - My Method Actor

Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

Beabadoobee - This is How Tomorrow Moves

Wednesday - Rat Saw God

 

I feel like this would be the best lineup in that case since it offers a bit of variety for everyone:  shoegaze/dreampop, classic indie rock, americana, pop rock, country rock

 

I do love FLH so if I could sneak them in...  it's only like 26 mins! But I agree 5 is prob the best

add All Born Screaming and I'm in

 

4 hours ago, honights said:

I would love a rate of 2023/2024 indie/indie rock albums

 

some of the options for the lineups:

Yeule - Softscars

Nilufer Yanya - My Method Actor

Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

Beabadoobee - This is How Tomorrow Moves

Wednesday - Rat Saw God

Feeble Little Horse - Girl With Fish

Indigo De Souza - All of This Will End

 

I wonder if people would be interested in this? I feel like these are noteworthy enough but it would be a niche rate of like prob 15 participants

Babe...

 

We still haven't had a rate of the BIG indie rock albums of 2023 (Lana, Caroline, Sufjan, Kelela) and 2024 (Clairo, mk.gee, MJ Lenderman) yet. I would do one of those FIRST tbh.

8 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Babe...

 

We still haven't had a rate of the BIG indie rock albums of 2023 (Lana, Caroline, Sufjan, Kelela) 

This lineup  oh Lana queen of rock