Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (โ‹ฎ) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Communion

ATRL Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  1. (Surely you can now understand why progressives were frustrated that these were the types of people liberal politicians and thinktankers were actually referencing when talking about making room in the Democratic Party for Never Trump Republicans? ddd Not to accuse or assume you were ever an O'Leary fan, to be clear. But just that there are many people who seem supportive in the abstract of moderation or incremental liberalism but then forget in practice in the US it looks like billionaire Canadian conservatives being like "I need Democrats to understand the real fascistsโ€ฆ.are the teachers unions!!!" like girl I'm sick of living in the real life nation version of Monoply dddddd)
  2. Didn't the last 10 years of politics just show you that your view on this is not shared by most Americans?
  3. Like the "how do you pay for it????" discourse from evil people like Mark Cuban is actually annoying and in bad faith because the 2020 primary's discourse was just so robust and detailed. Even just looking back and notes stored away from trying to understand better myself or discuss on here. November 2019 - When Warren tried to attack the Sanders plan's pay-fors (remember when people pretended to even discuss those!?): February 2020 - Medicare For All vs Pete Buttigieg's public option: This little listicle from October 2019... oh Bernie, we really did fail you.
  4. Again, I appreciate healthy skepticism, but I do think my post addresses most of this concern. 98% of providers participate in Medicare already. Congress can further leverage already-existing legislation and regulations on how physicians and providers need to accept Medicare rates and the fee schedule as-is to bill Medicare, and if you rightfully ban duplicative coverage, physicians either have to pick only offering services considered cosmetic or going cash-only vs working within Medicare. (This also isn't your argument but there is a contradiction in people citing the cost of M4A as too high but then also fear-mongering over Medicare rates as too low.) You'd also have to be more specific about issues regarding your grandma, as most issues with Medicare (as-is) are due to there being a multi-payer system. Medicare (as-is) doesn't include dental and vision coverage because private insurers lobbied against such, for example. By comparison, the only people I have known to have no issues with costs anymore for healthcare are when both my parents became dual-eligible beneficiaries aka people who are on Medicare and Medicaid as a secondary insurance. (The issue with the status quo is that many dual eligibles are people who have worsened health outcomes due to avoiding healthcare for long periods of time. Many dual eligibles are not just low-income geriatrics but those with health issues that qualify them as disabled. It was great when my dad no longer had to worry about healthcare costs.. but he was then dead from stomach cancer 2 years later. My mom has no healthcare costs, but it would have been nice for that to be before stage 4 liver disease rendered her quality of life super low!) The end result of Medicare For All (coverage with no cost-sharing) looks more like what being a Medicare dual eligible beneficiary is like (12.5M~ Americans are currently in this pool). The proposal of expanding this no cost-sharing coverage through Medicare is because Medicaid is administered through states, and we saw how individual states were able to stall the Medicaid expansion. So Medicare For All as a plan is already strategically built to avoid these kinds of legal challenges, ie: expanding through federally administered Medicare and not state-administered Medicaid, as one example.
  5. ddd thank you. I do think @Rian is just trying to be skeptical for the purpose of knowing, but also I don't.. think most of these things matter to the average voter. Again, I appreciate that the 2020 primary wasn't followed by everyone for this specific discussion, but the policy discussion was had back then and it was so specific and detailed to a degree only bad-faith pundits would care about. To me, the system just so...... self-evidently doesn't work! You just have to experience it to know it! I know not everyone grows up poor, but the current system makes seeking care so difficult that I don't think you have to have been poor in order to see that it doesn't work. I don't think my view of it is uniquely informed by my situation growing up! I moved a few years back and fell on the stairs while moving in, slicing open the bottom of my foot. I didn't want to go to the ER but eventually went hours later because it was a cut deep enough that it was into a layer of muscle of my foot. The hospital was in-network but the physician who I saw to get stitches wasn't so I ended up with a $2k bill. There... was no element of choice there in that scenario! My job's insurance provider has changed 3 (!) times in seven years. Even this last year, looking at marketplace alternatives showed there's no meaningful alternatives. UHC, Aetna, OSCAR, AmeriHealth, OMNIA, etc. None of these were good! No matter employer-based or marketplace-based, they're all insurance products meant to de-incentivize you from utilizing care. My premiums actually went down this year.... but because the new plan the company brokered has a higher deductible and much higher out-of-pocket maximum. Like with the ER bill, I know it sounds silly, but there is a point of financial distress that would make me just.... pick dying. And that's the contradiction with healthcare. When I have a sickly parent I have to help take care of, or a sibling who is a drug addict and so my personal finances are often volatile cause of the chaos they bring, there is a level of financial distress that means, yes, healthcare will just.. not be sought. Any pains or discomforts just... have to be lived with! My past primary physician switched to concierge services too so I basically haven't seen a doctor in 2 years due to the costs of finding a new in-network physician. Like, no, I don't want you to run a bunch of tests and treat me! I don't want to know if these recent anxiety-induced stomach pains mean something I can't afford! I basically at this point pay $4k a year in premiums to have my own version of catastrophic care in case, god forbid, I ever develop some kind of cancer. Of course some employer-based insurance is amazing! But it's also tied to your employment! Wawa is.. a gas station and yet a friend I have who has worked there for a decade has great health insurance! The problem? She wants to quit after being promoted and moved to a new location and finds herself in a toxic environment that's making her miserable to go to work... but that work is tied to your healthcare! Another friend (who didn't vote in 2024 due to being angry at how expensive everything got ddd) was navigating her self-employed parents' marketplace insurance and how she has no clue how they'd afford it being $1600 more a month due to the ACA subsidies cut. This is all just...... intentionally dysfunctional and not how any of this is meant to work!
  6. There's two parts to this: 1) The initial questioning worries about a problem that can't actually happen as Medicare already exists. Like Social Security already exist. Entitlement programs are objectively more incredibly difficult to try and break apart without immense blowback. Trying to find a policy that an opposition party won't attack is... not a realistic ask. There's no policy anyone can ever point to and go "Republicans won't attack this". It's not true for America or any country that does have universal healthcare. Conservatives in Canada or across Europe all try to make continuous cuts to their healthcare systems. But it's much more difficult when you force the opposition to call to strip an entitlement from EVERYONE as opposed to just those deemed as leaching (ex: Medicaid cuts). It's also not a realistic ask because the current system Dems installed is already failing because of its weakness to Republican sabotage. The ACA has enabled premiums to skyrocket because Republicans could so easily gut mechanisms like the individual mandate or tax subsidies. "Something is a failure if it's not Republican-proof," would make, for example, the ACA an objective failure. 2) If you're talking about actual healthcare policy, again, Medicare already exists. Meaning, Medicare already has rules and regulations that establish coverage determinations via CMS. The point of the government is to govern. The White House has immense rules-making privileges via its various agencies. If the idea is that these institutions should never be used in case a Republican wins would mean upending most of American civil society. Like what's next, getting rid of the Department of Education and public schools?
  7. There's three roles in each chamber: the head of the chamber, the head of the majority party, the head of the minority party. There's no vote on the head of the Senate because the VP acts as the de-facto 'president of the senate body' aka why they cast tie-breaking votes. The whole chamber of the House votes for Speaker of the House, and I believe only a simple majority of the party itself needs to vote for the head of both the majority and minority party in each chamber.
  8. Ana's not my favorite and I hate how reactionary she is but it is funny how people push framing where only Israelis and Jewish Americans can be honest in their generational trauma of the Holocaust and everyone else is secretly an antisemite or paid for when Ana's views are largely informed by the Armenian genocide and Palestinians being some of the first to take in Armenian refugees fleeing death.
  9. I think though too the issue is so many provisionals end up being a product of voter rolls having discrepancies and issues. Like I know in NJ, if you have any issue or there's confusion with verifying exact address, they just hand you a provisional to do to be verified later. I think most NJ voters never think much of it because no races are really seen as tight, but election systems probably need to be improved to limit how often a provisional ballot is needed for tight races.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions โ†’ Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.