Swiftienator13
ATRL Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
-
the question implies the first to have a big fall off and its definitely ariana. that isn't to say taylor wont flop but shes guaranteed another decade of success at the very least, ariana is relatively shakier (RELATIVELY is the key word here they wont flop for at least another 5 years shes on her way to legend status) ariana has a set image, taylor has transitioned then de trans'ed plenty of times in terms of image and era visuals and sound, ariana just plays around that trap-r&b-synthpop max martin sound since 2018, a sonic jump thats still pop friendly would be absolutely welcomed.
-
more tacky nonsense and more 'fans' excusing bad music with 'if this was a white popgirl' this 'had a white girl released' that lord pls shes proven that shes mediocre time and time again. the closest spark shes had was her debut.
-
critical acclaim, gp adored smash HITS, 4 global top 10s with a #1 smash, huge career album first week repeak, oh godlivia the #GRAMMYSWEEP is coming!
-
-
-
-
smashhouseeeeee
-
Contextually the best part about this all was thst this was her first official shot at a pop record and she smashed it with ease I can only think of like 3 other modern popgirl albums that can stand toe to toe with it in terms of quality and consistency its just that good! She ate so badddd If only she could find that level of inspiration again for TS13
-
It's good but a little underrated, she hopped on the pop train late and added everything groundbreaking to it. She was cosplaying what the girls had already been doing since never. Style is a rich man's Teenage Dream, Bad Blood was her trashy Kidz Bop entry, Shake It Off is an all timer megasmash, Blank Space her signature hit, New Romantics the critics choice, she had it all. Truly the best pop era of all time when you take into singles, rollout and celebrity status and the narrative of the celebrity as it happened, so much **** was happening around her all the time
-
-
The stars who last the longest I think always know when to push push push and when to hold everything back, Beyonce did this by the 2010s, Madonna by the mid 1990s and the 2010s, Taylor I think needs a big break too bc the quality of the recent work is not it but I think she gives herself ample amount of rest in between major career moves. being incapable of separating the persona and the real person underneath is what killed these megastars. From the popgirls, the ones who lasted knew this. Especially Madonna.
-
yall mock her but shes making sense. madonna i always felt had a sense of groundedness to her (in a way similar to taylor), her ego was ginormous like the legends alongside her but i think above all else she had a good sense of when to push forward and when to hold back and it showed throughout her entire career. her ego too i think is truly only when it comes to her career, her personal life i think is pretty normal and i think that absolutely helps too.
-
2026 is the year of TATE. I think shes gonna continue with this minimalistic lingerie hotgirl aesthetic and honestly im not mad its making waves in Europe. Housewife global SMASH HIT'
-
Tate actually has lyrical depth compared to yer ancestors of the hot dance pop route. Housewife tackles the concept of being a girlboss and being ok with being on your own while still knowing you lust after and can still want to have a man beside you. Most songs either go for one or the other but Tate has nuance, love that. Popgirls have entered their manifestation era songs
