1 minute ago, hausofbryan said:

Being a stan since early 2009 on GagaDaily, it's funny to see what's beloved by fans today that was hated or at least polarizing at the time.

Ikr

The way y'all switched on songs like MTN, Judas or Applause. I was there since the beginning and I know y'all were not cute about these three back then

Just now, hausofbryan said:

Being a stan since early 2009 on GagaDaily, it's funny to see what's beloved by fans today that was hated or at least polarizing at the time.

Newer fans would never know it, but the daily meltdowns during the BTW era were something else

Just now, Teneo said:

Ikr

The way y'all switched on songs like MTN, Judas or Applause. I was there since the beginning and I know y'all were not cute about these three back then

The redemption arc for Judas is really something.

I even think of the performances that had a shift in perception — Like the DITD BRITs performance was trashed since it replaced a really large spectacle that was planned until McQueen passed. Now people really like that performance.

Time is the ultimate truth teller I suppose

Anyone else old enough to remember the tumblr and GGD meltdowns when she revealed the BTW album cover?

BTW (album) was hated HATED by the fanbase when it dropped and ARTPOP was considered to be a masterpiece with daily think pieces on how every song deserved to be a single

Atleast the hate for Dope never changed

Glamorous Life moodboard

1 minute ago, Entalan said:

Newer fans would never know it, but the daily meltdowns during the BTW era were something else

From the minute the Madonna comparisons started during the single straight through Marry The Night only being in the iTunes Top 10 for a few seconds before being knocked out again We had no rest

Just now, Bhabylon said:

Anyone else old enough to remember the tumblr and GGD meltdowns when she revealed the BTW album cover?

It was just one of the betrayals, the real cover is coming soon

1 minute ago, Teneo said:

BTW (album) was hated HATED by the fanbase when it dropped and ARTPOP was considered to be a masterpiece with daily think pieces on how every song deserved to be a single

I still stand by that Sexxx Dreams should've been the first or second single.

Shadow of a man is only 20,000 streams away from Vanish into you (daily)…

Need it go viral now with all this MJ buzz

Gaga (or Jo) slipping off the piano or whatever during the VMAs. Oh, that was not a good night for this Base

Just now, Bhabylon said:

Anyone else old enough to remember the tumblr and GGD meltdowns when she revealed the BTW album cover?

I'm old enough to remember the conspiracy that the BTW cover reveal was a joke and the first of "three betrayals" as a Judas promo and ATRL users making gifs of Katy's head in a tricycle, P!nk's on a truck, etc.

I also remember a meme of a cell phone image taken during the Monster Ball of the BTW cover reveal on the arena screen and the text "I don't speak German but I can be a bike"

Edited April 25Apr 25 by Entalan

1 minute ago, hausofbryan said:

I still stand by that Sexxx Dreams should've been the first or second single.

She should have dropped it as a single right after the Swinefest with the Rihanna verse but nooo she had to play "I'm too cool to collab with other female peers" only to go back running to Xtina 2 months later to farm some PR points

3 minutes ago, Teneo said:

BTW (album) was hated HATED by the fanbase when it dropped and ARTPOP was considered to be a masterpiece with daily think pieces on how every song deserved to be a single

I still remember little monsters writing essays about how ARTPOP was experimental music and that Gaga was shifting into becoming an indie artist

1 minute ago, opbranden said:

I still remember little monsters writing essays about how ARTPOP was experimental music and that Gaga was shifting into becoming an indie artist

the concept of an indie artist collaborating with TI, Twista, and R Kelly

You and I era had people in here, FANS, calling her the r word like it was nothing

imo her trinity of missed opportunities (singles) are

1. replay

2. monster

3. garden of eden

Watching So you think you can dance only for the TEOG MV to be a diabolical emergency stairs advertisement

I remember sharing replay to my straight guy friends and they were GAGGED! They thought it was an instant classic! REPLAY R-R-REPLAY AY AY

Just now, hausofbryan said:

the concept of an indie artist collaborating with TI, Twista, and R Kelly

"Yeah yeah, but see? She's hugging rocks in the woods with Marina Abramovich!!"

Just now, denim said:

imo her trinity of missed opportunities (singles) are

1. replay

2. monster

3. garden of eden

that hit in your head ain't real

10/10 MAYHEM song just came on

9 minutes ago, Teneo said:

BTW (album) was hated HATED by the fanbase when it dropped and ARTPOP was considered to be a masterpiece with daily think pieces on how every song deserved to be a single

yup yup yup

I remember thinking ARTPOP was a groundbreaking masterpiece. BTW took me like a year or two to fully love (during the wait for AP)

I also remember hearing Judas' bridge for the first time and thinking it was Gaga's best and going to be her biggest hit Little did I know…

Well in a way I was sorta right, just had to wait 14 years I still can't fully process that it outstreams bad romance, paparazzi, telephone, etc… on the regular