vs

 

Fifth Harmony had several global hits 

 

I couldn't name a KATSEYE song with a gun to my head.
 

They seem like one of those "popular on the internet" types. 

The OGs pussycat dolls 

 

4 minutes ago, CallumDavies said:

Fifth Harmony had several global hits & ppl know who they are… 

 

I couldn't name a KATSEYE song with a gun to my head.
 

They seem like one of those "popular on the internet" types. 

That Jean commercial is making them brave. 

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Appletree

2 minutes ago, CallumDavies said:

Fifth Harmony had several global hits 

 

I couldn't name a KATSEYE song with a gun to my head.
 

They seem like one of those "popular on the internet" types. 

Fifth harmony took 3 years to get a hit, give katseye some time.

Destiny's Child, Pussycat Dolls, and Danity Kane are the true trinity of ggs iktr. 

5 minutes ago, JO1s said:

Fifth harmony took 3 years to get a hit, give katseye some time.

It's KATSEYE vs 5H now… not some future hypothetical scenario 

1 minute ago, CallumDavies said:

It's KATSEYE vs 5H now… not some future hypothetical scenario 

I mean no poll in the op said who has a bigger career overall. It's not always a math game 

the Reflection era is iconic to me, that's why i'm gonna go with 5H overall. 

I'm sorry but you have to be crazy if you genuinely think Normani is a better dancer than than Daniela 

Weird how we are flexing who's the better dancer now. Shouldn't this be about vocals first? they  are recording artists before they are dancers 

The Old Navy jeans commercial dancers will never be the ICONS 5H were

11 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

Weird how we are flexing who's the better dancer now. Shouldn't this be about vocals first? they  are recording artists before they are dancers 

ok, well Lara is a better singer than all of 5H, now what?

Just now, 50thStateofMind said:

ok, well Lara is a better singer than all of 5H, now what?

I doubt that  

 

not fan of 5H at all but Ally and Dina have better range 

Vocally the 5H girls are clearing whether it's tone or vocal strength. Katseye just works better as a group because they are actually in sync.

Prefer 5H. 

Katseye seem to have better chemistry.

 

 

 

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Cole

Prefer 5H songs and their vocals are more distinct. Love Katseye too but more for dancing

54 minutes ago, taemin said:

I'm sorry but you have to be crazy if you genuinely think Normani is a better dancer than than Daniela 

Well, no. They're both extremely talented, so it's not like either answer is a slam dunk.

Katseye (and I hardly even know one song of theirs) >>>>> 5H

 

Firth Harmony was a mistake from it's inception. Just a motley group of randos forced to tolerate each other with no vision and no goal but to use the opportunity to launch mediocre solo careers. It was a disastrous project and a waste of funds imo. 

Lara raj from katseye has such a pretty voice and they are great performers but SO FAR I prefer 5H simply because I liked all of their voices (even Camila's). Also I loved their first 2 albums. Katseye has to release a full album for me to reconsider especially since they were originally marketed as a k pop group which I don't really listen to. Also I can only imagine what people will do when one of the katseye girls says something "problematic" and the Internet spends the next 7 years focusing on that and trying to cancel them.

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Onyxmage

4 minutes ago, Onyxmage said:

Lara raj from katseye has such a pretty voice and they are great performers but SO FAR I prefer 5H simply because I liked all of their voices (even Camila's). Also I loved their first 2 albums. Katseye has to release a full album for me to reconsider especially since they were originally marketed as a k pop group which I don't really listen to.

they arent kpop theyre a global girl group managed by a kpop company

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Josh

1 minute ago, Josh said:

they arent kpop theyre a global girl group managed by a kpop company

Quote

a global girl group that incorporates K-pop training and methodologies into its music and performance style, a strategy designed to globalize the K-pop production system. 

They are basically a k pop group.

I feel it's unfair to compare them since Katseye is a new group,while 5H has like a decade in the industry 

Virality + synchronicity vs. vocals and actual hits

Having seen both groups live, I'd have to go with 5H. Their songs are better and all of them are great vocalists even if they are messy performers. One of the girls in Katseye was horribly off key when I saw them live