Both are MPGs that have longevity but are sometimes overlooked.

Both were edgy bad girls and had a rock/country edge.

Both have big lesbian fanbases and are popular in Australia.

Both are good vocalists, not the best, but very respectable and have a unique tone.

Both are considered good performers.

 

Who is better?

 

Edited July 9, 20242 yr by toxicgenie

Miley is easily taking every category

miley has a few good songs

p!nk has none

 

p!nk is bigger outside the US though thanks to her successful tours and radio spam

Two legends that the f*ggos like to piss on.

P!NK in all three categories. No competition for me.

I'm an OG P!nk girlie but she started losing me at TTAL 

 

I don't think Miley could tour in the same way P!nk does. 

 

Try This is better than any of Miley's albums, don't @ me. 

But Miley does have Dead Petz which is a pretty f**king good vanity project 

Thanks for voting for P!nk. And FU for voting for Miley.

Pink had the best global longevity out of her peers  she was still bagging hits and great album sales in the 10s while her peers could barely scrap gold sans Beyonce. 
 

and lol at Miley having the bigger peak. when Missundazstood, I'm Not Dead, Funhouse, Greatest Hits, and TTAL were much bigger than Bangers (her only successful album outside the Hannah Montana soundtracks and the time of our lives)

Destiny Hope for all

Miley. 

 

Pink peaked after like 8 six years with funhouse. She declined so much in quality and success but Miley still get better 

 

 

1 hour ago, Breakdown said:

p!nk has none

This fawking lie???

 

Miley clears. Imagine having a song like Dance Again in your discography.

 

Edited July 9, 20242 yr by Miley Cyrus

Breakout > Funhouse

Miley for all but P!nk is underestimated a lot in pop culture conversations, she's had a very long and successful career (the fact that she's still doing stadiums 24 years in is amazing)

Pink is a non factor in latinamerica so, Miley won this

No way you guys genuinely think Miley had a bigger peak than P!nk atrl stays out of touch. P!nk for everything. 

P!nk for everything. 

 

The fact that ATRL thinks Miley has bigger peak when P!nk can sell out stadiums and outsell Miley   

The most absurd thing here is "P!nk is a good vocalist, not the best..."

 

Just because she doesn't oversing, people don't see her as the EXCELENT vocalist she is. Her technique is among the greatest in history, her breath control is out of this world (no one else is singing upside flown flying around the stadium), and the versatility in her voice is stunning. 

As a P!nk stan, I think Miley had the bigger overall peak, especially if you include celebrity status and controversy.

 

Both have great music and success, but P!nk takes it for quality for I'm Not Dead alone.

This photo 

 

5 hours ago, Gabriel Guedes said:

The most absurd thing here is "P!nk is a good vocalist, not the best..."

 

Just because she doesn't oversing, people don't see her as the EXCELENT vocalist she is. Her technique is among the greatest in history, her breath control is out of this world (no one else is singing upside flown flying around the stadium), and the versatility in her voice is stunning. 

Exactly. People always forgetting how great she is as a vocalist too, not only as a performer.