Why couldn't it be a hit?

 

Was the subject matter too complex?

 

Was it not a bop?

 

Discuss.

 

 

It ended up peaking at #86 on the Hot 100.

idk but it should've been, it's so good

Because it's mid

It was too ahead of it’s time. 

Cause it is a retread of Zedd’s earlier production (Stay, The Middle, Good Thing). 

The video is too weird and Zedd looks ugly in this one 

Edited February 24, 20242 yr by AvadaKedavra

ive never heard this before

Wdym? It was a hit in my car 

i didn't know this was a FLOP. it went platinum at my local supermarket that's for damn sure 

The GP knew this HYMN was too good for them and didn't stream because of it.

The weird tryhard music video is the main reason I feel, to the point where no video would have been better

Edited February 24, 20242 yr by concubine

deserved to be a radio earworm, a durable top 10. the sad thing about a career in the mainstream is that once the flops start coming, its very very hard to come back. had this been a collab in 2012 is would have been 6-7 million downloads deep already.

No long black hair no hit

 

I was honestly shocked. I thought it would be a big hit

it should have been but no one has taste

Typical flop not bop from Kathryn. 

I honesty don’t know why it has everything to be a huge hit. I thought for sure this song would launch her into the top 10 again. 
 

Such a shame 

despite the charts, it's one of her best, imo.  Video is great too, especially that red part. 

Katy Perry was simply over at that point. The GP saw her name and kept scrolling

 

Idk it was a really good song  

It was kind of meh tbh. Its missing something to it to make it really hit.

She’s making room for Charli XCX’s 365

 

 

 

Needs a five year anniversary TikTok revival

I LOVE this song and When I’m Gone! Katy should do more DJ collabs.

It should have been. The video was also interesting it had a plot and everything.  Maybe the video was too sad.