There's so many similarities but which one is better? 

 

 

 

Edited November 10, 20232 yr by Cloröx

1 minute ago, Cloröx said:

There's so many similarities but which one is better? 

 

 

 

Perfect Illusion MV is gone from the OP, Houdini.

PIss is bottom of the barrel pop, so not that.

1 minute ago, GraceRandolph said:

Perfect Illusion MV is gone from the OP, Houdini.

Fixed it 

Perfect Illusion Tame Impala version > Houdini > Perfuct Illusion OG

Houdini sweetie

 

We all know that BloodSport ruined PI when he touched it... 

 

Houdini 

Never thought I'd vote for PI vs anything, but here we are 

Houdini is kinda like what GaGa failed at and Dua made happen. Switch to the new Queen monsters. 

 

Is shocking a10/10 song is this low on the ratimg but seriously. DUA NAILED THIS. 

 

Is rare a pop girl delivers this Material on third album and this is way better then applause. 

Edited November 10, 20232 yr by Shaner69

Dua sweetie, I am so sorry

 

PI easily

PIss is like one of the most hated songs in ATRL, so Houdini wins by default

 

Houdini wins for most users here cuz it's an easy to listen catchy pop song, it's good cuz it's not doing too much, it has very groovy light production. PI gets a bad reputation because it was doing way too much, like the screams and jagged instrumental (I love it tho personally)

Houdini obviously. Perfect Illusion is garbage trash and is what started the demise of Gaga’s music career. 

Perfect Illusion is the perfect song to play for when you want your guests to leave, works better than any other repellent

Houdini >>>

The delusion in these votes  

 

Houdini’s competition in Gaga’s discography are songs like Bad Romance, Poker Face, Edge of Glory etc. NOT Perfect Delusion.

That Dua video was hard to watch. Gaga actually delivered in Perfect Illusion imo

22 minutes ago, ThousandMiles said:

Houdini obviously. Perfect Illusion is garbage trash and is what started the demise of Gaga’s music career. 

Didn't it start with Born This Way selling for 99 cents?

Love both, but Houdini is better. Perfect Illusion is a bit too intense. I need a reprieve from Gaga's vocal and energy and it just never happens. 

47 minutes ago, Relampago. said:

The delusion in these votes  

 

Houdini’s competition in Gaga’s discography are songs like Bad Romance, Poker Face, Edge of Glory etc. NOT Perfect Delusion.

 

I love Dua but Houdini is literally an attempt to have her own "As It Was". Inoffensive, boring pop song that goes nowhere. Except As It Was is much catchier. Not really comparable to Bad Romance, Poker Face, or even Edge of Glory.

Edited November 10, 20232 yr by awong918

Houdini mopped the floor with E. Lou Shawn

Perfect Illusion is grating- Gaga could have toned it WAY down on the vocals. Love the instrumental though, especially the intro. 

 

The only good part of Houdini is the last 45 seconds. I love Dua but the song is so boring and it's a disappointment compared to Don't Start Now.

 

Overall, I'd say Houdini is slightly better. That last 45 seconds is a bop. 

 

Both music videos are a big step down in quality but I'm going to go for Perfect Illusion since I like the editing and the part where she's swinging the microphone.

 

 

Edited November 10, 20232 yr by CoolNebraskaGuy

love them both!!