https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/olivia-rodrigo-guts/

 

We blame logical for this

Edited September 11, 20232 yr by enchanted0

Higher than Midnights!

 

Congrats to Ms Rodrigo for this amazing score!

Edited September 11, 20232 yr by Slayn

we blame lacy

1 minute ago, Slayn said:

Higher than Midnights AND fearless!

 

Congrats to Ms Rodrigo for this amazing score!

The album just got an amazing score yet Atrlers still make this about Taylor.  

 

Love the album but pretty sure it would've easily got BNM without two ballads

I thought 8 and above is Best New Album? But this score is amazing congrats Olivia!!

Just now, Ruby said:

I thought 8 and above is Best New Album? But this score is amazing congrats Olivia!!

Scores of 8.2 and above are awarded BNM

Critical acclaim 

And yes we can blame logical:

 

Quote

Counterbalancing the album’s ruthless zingers are the platitudes of treacly ballads like “logical,” on which Rodrigo tries to show her romantic irrationality with a grade-school mathematics demonstration.

 

Great score  logical is the best written song on the album tho, but some aren’t ready for that discussion 

Gimmicks get you far 

7 minutes ago, Slayn said:

Higher than Midnights!

I guess something of hers this era finally had to be!

 

OT: good score!  

3 minutes ago, AndThenTheCocaine said:

Critical acclaim 

And yes we can blame logical:

 

 

I checked the credits and apparently, Julia Michaels worked on the song too ? No wonder it's the worst on the album.

5 minutes ago, enchanted0 said:

The album just got an amazing score yet Atrlers still make this about Taylor.  

 

Love the album but pretty sure it would've easily got BNM without two ballads

Why don't you tell that to all the swifties swarming Olivia's streaming thread saying "yikes" to an album that is in the top 10 biggest female debuts of all time on spotify.

deserved. 

Oh wow  she really won with critics huh? 

logical and the grudge PANNED, iktr

An amazing score for a new artist so early in their career. Hopefully the praise will continue as Olivia grows as an artist

 

Spoiler

I bet the album would’ve gotten BNM if she had replaced Logical with Obsessed 

 

6 minutes ago, Slayn said:

Why don't you tell that to all the swifties swarming Olivia's streaming thread saying "yikes" to an album that is in the top 10 biggest female debuts of all time on spotify.

"all the swifties" 

 

there were like 2-3 max, the rest were giving Olivia her flowers. Meanwhile only one person in this thread so far has brought up Taylor - what can we conclude about that, I wonder? 

10 minutes ago, Zaynsus said:

I checked the credits and apparently, Julia Michaels worked on the song too ? No wonder it's the worst on the album.

Julia's songwriting is awful hope she stays far from Olivia from no on

Truly the Melodrama of the 2020's

maybe halsey made some points
 

Leave logical alone, blame licy or teenage skip!

1 minute ago, Michael196 said:

Leave logical alone, blame licy or teenage skip!

Lacy is one of the best songs on the album 

logical is not the best written song from GUTS ijbol. Maybe if you were a teenager just getting into songwriting

Regardless, it's still cute and there are no skips on the album 

Yes Olivia Yes high scores 

the fact that she'll definitely get only better