500+ characters & months later still playing victim. 

Idk how to say this without sounding shady but Renaissance feels like Chromatica fully realized and elevated to its highest potential 

y'all really need bey to throw a mic on you

 

3 hours ago, Zaram said:

This is like the third time you quoted me like this
I'm cackling a bit tho nnn

Because you’re in every Beyoncé thread  so it’s kinda easy to clock ya 

Lol no. Ren is miles above Chroma. 

The lashings on the first page alone

6 hours ago, Pheromosa said:

Same producers, the difference is that Beyonce is the better artist with a strong vision than gaga. 

Ding ding ding! Beyoncé can make cohesive projects while the other is a scattered mess. 
 

Now where is that thread the monsters made about them both using the same “rooster” of producers?

 

9 hours ago, Blue Rose said:

Chromatica is cute while Renaissance is gorgeous 

 

 

this thread  

 

No, Renaissance is good

The first page is a masterpiece 

 

22 hours ago, Jaded. said:

Idk how to say this without sounding shady but Renaissance feels like Chromatica fully realized and elevated to its highest potential 

Exactly this. Love both these girlies down but the reality is, Renaissance sounds like the work of an artist who felt passionate making the record. While Chromatica on the other hand sounds like someone was forced by their producer to get off their porch to stop smoking and record a song… multiple times…

Edited August 8, 20233 yr by BlondGuts

No. Only one of these albums is listenable and it’s not the one with a song carried by a kpop girl group.

Renaissance is a masterpiece in every aspect 

I love Chromatica more than Renaissance but Renaissance is above. That album is really experimental. Chromatica feels generic at times 

Ren is the better album, but Chromatica has visuals. I think both tours are their best too. So they both win imo.

22 hours ago, 45seconds said:

Because you’re in every Beyoncé thread  so it’s kinda easy to clock ya 

If "kpop stan" is supposed to be a clock

Definetly not as regards quality

1 hour ago, Zaram said:

If "kpop stan" is supposed to be a clock

it's a derogatory term actually

Rennie is a work of art. It’s a universe of visual and sonic storytelling. 

 

Chromatica is an okay pop album 

Why do they keep insisting on this. You all keep getting Gaga dragged when you compare to Bey. Renaissance is coming to pass Chromatica streams and it didn’t need 3.5 years to catch up. 
 

Chromatica tour - 20 dates 112 million 

Renaissance tour - 12 US dates 141 million 

 

Gaga did fine. 

 

 

4 hours ago, Zaram said:

If "kpop stan" is supposed to be a clock

Absolutely, umma

16 hours ago, BlondGuts said:

Exactly this. Love both these girlies down but the reality is, Renaissance sounds like the work of an artist who felt passionate making the record. While Chromatica on the other hand sounds like someone was forced by their producer to get off their porch to stop smoking and record a song… multiple times…

Oh but don't forget Ren has 5x more writers producers as Chromatica! Ren is the writing camp'd album of the two, which, when you find that out, undermines the authenticity of the album...

15 hours ago, crf13 said:

No. Only one of these albums is listenable and it’s not the one with a song carried by a kpop girl group.

Well every song on Ren is carried by samples from more talented, authentic artists...

Edited August 9, 20233 yr by Sylpher

14 minutes ago, Sylpher said:

Oh but don't forget Ren has 5x more writers producers as Chromatica! Ren is the writing camp'd album of the two, which, when you find that out, undermines the authenticity of the album...

And yet Renaissance is the album that is the most cohesive, musically and thematically. It's also by far the more authentic album. Further proving that the artist in charge has a strong vision and is able to shape and craft a high-quality album. Chromatica cannot relate. Hence your fumes.

2 hours ago, Sylpher said:

Oh but don't forget Ren has 5x more writers producers as Chromatica! Ren is the writing camp'd album of the two, which, when you find that out, undermines the authenticity of the album...

Maybe Gaga should hire more then, if it helps her make a quality album.