Lover but 911 is the best song here. 

Edited May 4, 20233 yr by unino

Yes Lover has some lows but the highs on that album are excellent 

 

Lover (s) and Cruel Summer alone puts it above Chromatica 

Replay alone stomps on the other one 

Lover for the Lover song alone (and its little sister The Archer) 

 

I didn’t really enjoy Chromatica at all unfortunately just Rain on me

 

(I like Gaga’s first album and Artpop, Swine live it’s simply a masterpiece)

only one of these is a good album and it's not loser 

Cornelia Street alone clears the other one 

Obviously chromatica but Me! is one of her best songs 

Well, both are my fave but Lover is indeed a better album, despite the lower lows. Chromatica is just average for 80% of it, while Lover is bad for 30% of it but average for only 20%, so the other 50% of the album is pretty amazing. 

the one with Cruel Summer, Miss Americana, Cornelia Street and Afterglow 

Afterglow alone >>

Both below their talents but only one has 911 so I'll go with that

 

Loser's lows are a crime against humanity, even she knew that and had to burry it with 2 magnum opuses the following year.

Chromatica but Lover has good songs too

Chromatica is better than any Taylor album, really

Chromatica clears easily  I'm surprised at the poll results but at the same I'm not knowing how many OGHs we have here

lover is better than gag's entire discography and that says a lot

Lover has some really strong songs. but some cringe ones and also felt reductiv elike a 1989 copy with faux political element to copy what Gaga did with BTW to try to increase her impact The inital performance and hate for lovler rattled Taylor massively, which is why we got folklore. Chromatica simarly felt reductive in certain ways but had really strong elements too. Likewise i hope Gaga's folklore is coming.

So i voted Chroma i prefer it on the speakers

I'm assuming the lows and absolute cringe-songs that y'all speak of on Lover are "I Forgot That You Existed" & "ME!", no? Cause they are the worst offenders for me.

Lover sweetie

Lover has The Archer and Cornelia Street  

Lover overall but Chromatica has the better highlights (911 and its interlude, Alice, ROM).

23 minutes ago, Avariko said:

I'm assuming the lows and absolute cringe-songs that y'all speak of on Lover are "I Forgot That You Existed" & "ME!", no? Cause they are the worst offenders for me.

London Boy too. And Soon You'll get better. 

Lover is excellence! Sorry Chromatica you're good but....

I agree with the critics that ranked Lover higher on year-end lists

Of the two, I only stream Lover on a daily basis