We all know chart = fart

 

quality discussion only 

 

better debut album?

Aquarius.

Aquarius

don't rly like early Bey albums

 

while Tinashe's debut is one of the best debuts quality-wise

Aquarius 

 

Not sure there are many (if any) debut album from ATRL faves that could compare with Aquarius tbh.

Dangerously in Love

Aquarius sweetie.

Dangerously In Love had one of the best debut eras ever, had superb single choices, performances, videos and chart success. But better debut album? Aquarius, my dear.

 

Now that I think of it, Aquarius can battle it out with the best of the MPG's debut records. Who's next?

Aquarius is just another level really. Insane that was her debut album too.

Any Tinashe album is better 

Bey debut is really bad outside the singles. My mouth was to the floor listening for the first time with the poor quality & vocals.

 

She really stepped it up with Bday. 
 

Tinashe wins 

DiL

I love the DIL singles but as an album overall I'll stand with Aquarius, it's one of the best albums released in the past 10 years easily. 

Aquarius is the best album of all time so that one

Aquarious, sweetie...

 

not this AGAIN

DIL easily 

1 hour ago, magazine said:

Any Tinashe album is better 

says hi 

2 minutes ago, smoore95GAGA said:

says hi 

Stomps on DIL still

Aquarius! 

The title track alone is better than majority of Beyonce's mixtape.

Aquarius.

24 minutes ago, smoore95GAGA said:

says hi 

Joyride was a mixtapes sis, nightride is the album. Tinashe told me herself. 

Edited April 5, 20233 yr by nuclear

As someone else said, DIL is pretty weak outside of the singles.

 

2 hours ago, Klein said:

Not sure there are many (if any) debut album from ATRL faves that could compare with Aquarius tbh.

This, it's kinda thee debut album when you think about it 

Tinashe, honestly all her albums slay over all bey's album (except IASF imo) 

25 minutes ago, nuclear said:

Joyride was a mixtapes sis, nightride is the album. Tinashe told me herself. 

Pretty sure the opposite is true but ok hun 

I was actually just listening to DiL this morning and thinking about this randomly . I voted for Bey which may have been too hasty but the singles + Yes and the title track are some of my favorites. They're both too good and I probably will go back to T's side again soon anyway.

 

I feel like Tinashe is the only pop-ish artist who comes close to Beyoncé on any metric so more comparisons need to happen