what's the better album in your opinion on the first listen...

Plastic Hearts is the correct answer.

Plastic Hearts sweetie 

I haven't finished ESV yet lol

Plastic Hearts

Plastic Hearts

PH is so superior it's not even funny

No comparison whatsoever.. Plastic Hearts FTW! 

I haven't listened yet but I can't imagine ESV winning this one; Plastic Hearts is really an all-time fave of mine 

I’ve listened ESV once this morning but Plastic Hearts definitely wins without hesitation. Midnight Sky alone >>>>> 70% of this album. 
 

On first listen I liked Flowers, Handstand, River and Muddy Feet but they’re not like instant for me. Still unsure about Violet Chemistry. 
 

 

PH, and especially Midnight Sky. I really don't get Flowers and why it became so big. 

Oh first listen? ESV wins.  However I thin PH will end up being better overall.

PH is a once in a lifetime album 

ESV on the other hand... 

Plastic Hearts by FAR 

Those who voted esv are either lying or tasteless  💀

I’m the minority here, but ESV is more my vibe. Jaded, Rose Colored Lenses, You, Handstand and Violet Chemistry are excellence.

I mean, nothing tops Midnight Sky, but as an album, I think I prefer ESV.

Edited March 10, 20233 yr by starsailor

Plastic Hearts tbh 

Plastic Hearts and it's not even close

45 minutes ago, Insanity said:

I haven't finished ESV yet lol

Oh wow, you really didn't like it.

Esv is really alternative but PH’s rock sound is much better

Endless Summer Vacation, her best album to date for me. 

PH but ESV is good and solid too

plastic hearts and it’s not even close

PH by far

Plastic Hearts is a cult classic. ESV wishes