The Taylor Swift Discography Rate || Winner Revealed!

[1989]

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 

 

Hello and welcome to the Taylor Swift Discography Rate! With Taylor recently releasing her tenth studio album, I thought this would be a good time to celebrate her discography. Given how large Taylor’s discography is, only official releases are included. Also, any Taylor’s Version that has been released will replace the original version (Fearless, Red, Wildest Dreams, etc.), but for the sake of typing (lol) will just be referred to by their titles without all of the parentheses. Hopefully you all have fun and enjoy this rate!

 

Rules:

1. Rate only the songs on the list. 
2. Rate each song 1-10. Decimals are allowed, but only one decimal place (7.6 is fine, 7.65748 is not). 
3. You can give THREE songs an 11 and THREE songs a 0. 
4. Comments are optional, but encouraged!
5. Send your ballot to me via PM. Please do not post it in this thread. 

 

 

Due Date: February 19th

 

Song List:

Spoiler

Studio Albums:

 Taylor Swift 
Tim McGraw 
Picture To Burn 
Teardrops On My Guitar 
A Place In This World 
Cold As You 
The Outside 
Tied Together With A Smile 
Stay Beautiful
Should’ve Said No 
Mary’s Song (Oh My My My) 
Our Song 
I’m Only Me When I’m With You 
Invisible 
A Perfectly Good Heart 

 
Fearless (Taylor’s Version)
Fearless
Fifteen 
Love Story 
Hey Stephen 
White Horse 
You Belong With Me 
Breathe (feat. Colbie Caillat) 
Tell Me Why 
You’re Not Sorry 
The Way I Loved You 
Forever & Always 
The Best Day 
Change 
Jump Then Fall 
Untouchable 
Forever & Always (Piano Version) 
Come In With The Rain 
Superstar 
The Other Side Of The Door 
Today Was A Fairytale 
You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) 
Mr. Perfectly Fine 
We Were Happy 
That’s When (feat. Keith Urban)
Don’t You 
Bye Bye Baby 

 
Speak Now
Mine 
Sparks Fly 
Back To December 
Speak Now
Dear John 
Mean 
The Story Of Us 
Never Grow Up 
Enchanted 
Better Than Revenge 
Innocent 
Haunted 
Last Kiss
Long Live 
Ours 
If This Was A Movie 
Superman 

 
Red (Taylor’s Version)
State Of Grace 
Red
Treacherous 
I Knew You Were Trouble 
All Too Well 
22
I Almost Do 
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 
Stay Stay Stay 
The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody of Snow Patrol) 
Holy Ground 
Sad Beautiful Tragic 
The Lucky One 
Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran) 
Starlight 
Begin Again 
The Moment I Knew 
Come Back…Be Here 
Girl At Home 
State Of Grace (Acoustic Version) 
Ronan 
Better Man 
Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) 
Babe 
Message In A Bottle 
I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton)
Forever Winter 
Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) 
The Very First Night 
All Too Well (10 Minute Version) 

 
1989
Welcome To New York 
Blank Space 
Style 
Out Of The Woods 
All You Had To Do Was Stay
Shake It Off 
I Wish You Would 
Bad Blood 
Wildest Dreams 
How You Get The Girl 
This Love 
I Know Places
Clean 
Wonderland 
You Are In Love 
New Romantics 

 
Reputation 
…Ready For It? 
End Game (feat. Ed Sheeran and Future) 
I Did Something Bad 
Don’t Blame Me 
Delicate 
Look What You Made Me Do 
So It Goes…
Gorgeous 
Getaway Car 
King Of My Heart 
Dancing With Our Hands Tied 
Dress
This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things 
Call It What You Want 
New Year’s Day 

 
Lover 
I Forgot That You Existed 
Cruel Summer 
Lover 
The Man 
The Archer 
I Think He Knows 
Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince 
Paper Rings 
Cornelia Street 
Death By A Thousand Cuts 
London Boy 
Soon You’ll Get Better (feat. The Chicks) 
False God 
You Need To Calm Down 
Afterglow 
Me! (feat. Brendon Urie of Panic! At The Disco)
It’s Nice To Have A Friend 
Daylight 

 
folklore 
the 1 
cardigan 
the last great american dynasty 
exile (feat. Bon Iver) 
my tears ricochet 
mirrorball 
seven 
august 
this is me trying 
illicit affairs 
invisible string 
mad woman 
epiphany 
betty 
peace
hoax
the lakes 

 
evermore 
willow 
champagne problems 
gold rush 
‘tis the damn season 
tolerate it 
no body, no crime (feat. Haim) 
happiness 
dorothea
coney island (feat. The National) 
ivy
cowboy like me 
long story short 
marjorie 
closure 
evermore (feat. Bon Iver) 
right where you left me 
it’s time to go 

 
Midnights 
Lavender Haze 
Maroon 
Anti-Hero 
Snow On The Beach (feat. Lana Del Rey) 
You’re On Your Own, Kid
Midnight Rain 
Question…?
Vigilante Sh*t
Bejeweled 
Labyrinth 
Karma 
Sweet Nothing 
Mastermind 
The Great War 
Bigger Than The Whole Sky 
Paris 
High Infidelity 
Glitch 
Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve 
Dear Reader 
Hits Different 

 
Other Albums: 

 
The Taylor Swift Holiday Collection
Last Christmas 
Christmases When You Were Mine 
Santa Baby 
Silent Night 
Christmas Must Be Something More 
White Christmas 

 
Other Songs:
Beautiful Eyes 
I Heart ? 
Crazier 
Two Is Better Than One (with Boys Like Girls)
Half Of My Heart (with John Mayer) 
Both Of Us (with B.o.B.) 
Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) 
Eyes Open 
Highway Don’t Care (with Tim McGraw and Keith Urban) 
Sweeter Than Fiction 
Bad Blood (feat. Kendrick Lamar) 
I Don’t Wanna Live Forever (with Zayn) 
Lover (Remix) (feat. Shawn Mendes) 
Christmas Tree Farm 
Macavity
Beautiful Ghosts 
Only The Young 
Gasoline (with Haim) 
Renegade (with Big Red Machine) 
Birch (with Big Red Machine) 
The Joker And The Queen (with Ed Sheeran) 
Carolina 

 

Edited February 28, 2023 by 1989

[1989]

Participants:

(already submitted) 

Spoiler

1. @1989

2. @KillingYourCareer

3. @Velvet Night

4. @Klein

5. @SleepingTigers

6. @greento

7. @Taylor fanboy

8. @By the Water

9. @byzantium

10. @pinkbowvintage

11. @RihannaLoverrr

12. @creativity.

13. @Tusk

14. @AbeHicks

15. @freakum.

16. @TMRA

17. @4Real

18. @beagle

19. @FancyStars

20. @Prison

21. @NordicGuy

22. @Holy Ground

23. @Tedwards

24. @PrismaticOwen

25. @ithinkheknowsoutsold

26. @Aiya

27. @roso

28. @Fama

29. @Brando

30. @Sanguine

31. @Isaiah

32. @Allday

33. @Mr. Duff

34. @Icarus

35. @yeezytaughtme

36. @Fifteen

37. @TaylenaStan

38. @luckythisway

39. @Bussea

40. @modern thing

41. @Supernatural

42. @jacobhalkohit

43. @Wolf Alice

44. @Hunter_13

45. @The Music Industry

46. @Pink Whitney

47. @Taeyong

48. @Ayanaa

49. @Quicksand

50. @Achilles.

51. @sparrowblue

52. @Ken Lee

53. @NMIXX

54. @jacklovesyou1

55. @=NEX=
56. @Navy4Life

57. @EtherealCat

58. @sanzo

59. @eli's_rhythm

60. @wastedpotential

61. @Terylee

62. @Michael196

63. @Cruel Summer

64. @State of Grace.

65. @Kyungsoowift

66. @inshadesofcool

67. @JoanneActII

68. @Lorenzo22

69. @feelslikeadream

70. @PopA911

71. @Bindi

72. @MardinBeksloy

73. @Shendelzare

74. @TheArgonaut

75. @Peroxide

76. @Rev8

77. @chaeyonce

78. @Miles.

79. @a_d_22

 

Edited February 19, 2023 by 1989

[1989]

Results:

Spoiler

219. Lover (Remix) (feat. Shawn Mendes) - 2.798

218. Me! (feat. Brendon Urie of Panic! At The Disco) - 3.017

217. Macavity - 3.499

216. Silent Night - 3.653

215. The Joker And The Queen (with Ed Sheeran) - 3.835

214. Santa Baby - 3.852

213. White Christmas - 3.853

212. Christmas Must Be Something More - 3.858

211. I Forgot That You Existed - 4.229

210. Half Of My Heart (with John Mayer) - 4.261

209. A Perfectly Good Heart - 4.371

208. Only The Young - 4.646

207. You Need To Calm Down - 4.674

206. Christmases When You Were Mine - 4.721
205. Bad Blood - 4.790

204. Both Of Us (with B.o.B.) - 4.875

203. Vigilante Sh*t - 4.906

202. Beautiful Eyes - 4.998 

201. Last Christmas - 5.510

200. I Heart ? - 5.646

199. The Man - 5.680

198. Two Is Better Than One (with Boys Like Girls) - 5.682

197. Stay Stay Stay - 5.685

196. Stay Beautiful - 5.734

195. London Boy - 5.745

194. Birch (with Big Red Machine) - 5.821

193. Bad Blood (feat. Kendrick Lamar) - 5.850

192. Tied Together With A Smile - 5.897

191. Superstar - 5.907

190. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things - 5.987

189. The Outside - 5.989

188. Highway Don’t Care (with Tim McGraw & Keith Urban) - 5.993

187. Girl At Home - 5.994

186. Invisible - 5.995

185. A Place In This World - 5.997

184. Superman - 5.999

183. Beautiful Ghosts - 6.007

182. Gasoline (with HAIM) - 6.011

181. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 6.019

180. Gorgeous - 6.032

179. Change - 6.078

178. It’s Nice To Have A Friend - 6.116

177. I’m Only Me When I’m With You - 6.118

176. We Were Happy - 6.122

175. You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) - 6.138

174. Welcome To New York - 6.145

173. Innocent - 6.154

172. Sweeter Than Fiction - 6.156

171. I Don’t Wanna Live Forever (with Zayn) - 6.167

170. Today Was A Fairytale - 6.172

169. Come In With The Rain - 6.177

168. Never Grow Up - 6.178

167. How You Get The Girl - 6.195

166. End Game (feat. Future & Ed Sheeran) - 6.207

165. Soon You’ll Get Better (feat. The Chicks) - 6.210

164. Shake It Off - 6.217

163. The Moment I Knew - 6.221

162. Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 6.243

161. Bye Bye Baby - 6.263

160. Question…? - 6.266

159. Crazier - 6.302

158. Jump Then Fall - 6.373

157. The Best Day - 6.382

156. Carolina - 6.405

155. We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together - 6.434

154. Paris - 6.473

153. That’s When (feat. Keith Urban) - 6.475

152. Glitch - 6.486

151. Cold As You - 6.492

150. Sweet Nothing - 6.498

149. Christmas Tree Farm - 6.513

148. Hey Stephen - 6.527

147. Mary’s Song (Oh My My My) - 6.532

146. Starlight - 6.556

145. Message In A Bottle - 6.592

144. Dorothea - 6.598

143. Closure - 6.614

142. Eyes Open - 6.650

141. State Of Grace (Acoustic Version) - 6.653

140. No Body, No Crime (feat. HAIM) - 6.656

139. The Lucky One - 6.673

138. Forever & Always (Piano Version) - 6.684

137. Ronan - 6.717

136. I Did Something Bad - 6.721

135. The Other Side Of The Door - 6.744

134. Babe - 6.750

133. So It Goes… - 6.753

132. 22 - 6.784

131. The Archer - 6.817

130. Tell Me Why - 6.827

129. Epiphany - 6.844

128. It’s Time To Go - 6.855

127. New Year’s Day - 6.863

126. Bejeweled - 6.915

125. Picture To Burn - 6.931

124. Mastermind - 6.932

123. Labyrinth - 6.959

122. If This Was A Movie - 6.960

121. Speak Now - 6.972

120. Better Than Revenge - 6.976

119. I Wish You Would - 6.992

118. Don’t You - 6.995

117. Snow On The Beach (feat. Lana Del Rey) - 6.998

116. Breathe (feat. Colbie Caillat) - 7.010

115. Dress - 7.018

114. Mean - 7.020

113. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.037

112. Daylight - 7.063

111. King Of My Heart - 7.082

110. Long Story Short - 7.084

109. Untouchable - 7.098

108. Dear Reader - 7.101

107. High Infidelity - 7.105

106. Fifteen - 7.115

105. Tim McGraw - 7.142

104. Renegade (with Big Red Machine) - 7.143

103. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince - 7.159

102. Mad Woman - 7.162

101. Betty - 7.188

100. Look What You Made Me Do - 7.195

99. I Think He Knows - 7.215

98. The Very First Night - 7.259

97. Come Back…Be Here - 7.315

96. Hits Different - 7.320

95. Mr. Perfectly Fine - 7.364

94. You Are In Love - 7.379

93. Paper Rings - 7.417

92. You’re Not Sorry - 7.423

91. All You Had To Do Was Stay - 7.463

90. I Know Places - 7.469

89. The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody of Snow Patrol) - 7.482

88. Wonderland - 7.485

87. I Almost Do - 7.497

86. I Knew You Were Trouble - 7.511

85. Happiness - 7.514

84. Forever Winter - 7.521

83. Ours - 7.528

82. …Ready For It? - 7.571

81. Coney Island (feat. The National) - 7.582

80. Bigger Than The Whole Sky - 7.584

79. The Story Of Us - 7.604
78. Invisible String - 7.620

77. Hoax - 7.643

76. Afterglow - 7.651

75. False God - 7.661

74. Gold Rush - 7.667

73. Sad Beautiful Tragic - 7.685

72. The Lakes - 7.698

71. Should’ve Said No - 7.709

70. Peace - 7.721

69. Last Kiss - 7.762

68. Lover - 7.794

67. Forever & Always - 7.815

66. Karma - 7.826

65. This Love - 7.837

64. White Horse - 7.855

63. Lavender Haze - 7.873

62. The Last Great American Dynasty - 7.897

61. Teardrops On My Guitar - 7.907

60. Marjorie - 7.947

59. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) - 7.950

58. Champagne Problems - 7.968

57. Willow - 7.970 

56. Tolerate It - 7.978

55. Our Song - 7.984

54. Long Live - 7.997

53. New Romantics - 8.003

52. The Great War - 8.009

51. Dancing With Our Hands Tied - 8.015

50. Midnight Rain - 8.025

49. The Way I Loved You - 8.079

48. You Belong With Me - 8.110

47. Don’t Blame Me - 8.117

46. Better Man - 8.124

45. Out Of The Woods - 8.140

44. Illicit Affairs - 8.142

43. Seven - 8.163

42. The 1 - 8.182

41. Evermore (feat. Bon Iver) - 8.183

40. Fearless - 8.186

39. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.201

38. Death By A Thousand Cuts - 8.221

37. Haunted - 8.240

36. Mirrorball - 8.260

35. Mine - 8.265

34. My Tears Ricochet - 8.276

33. Dear John - 8.281

32. ‘Tis The Damn Season - 8.317

31. Cruel Summer - 8.331

30. Ivy - 8.349

29. Getaway Car - 8.359

28. Holy Ground - 8.369

27. Maroon - 8.413

26. You’re On Your Own, Kid - 8.433

25. Call It What You Want - 8.447

24. Anti-Hero - 8.453

23. Exile (feat. Bon Iver) - 8.472

22. Back To December - 8.488

21. Right Where You Left Me - 8.494

20. Cowboy Like Me - 8.501

19. Cornelia Street - 8.502

18. Red - 8.513

17. Delicate - 8.521

16. Blank Space - 8.598

15. Sparks Fly - 8.618

14. All Too Well (10 Min Version) - 8.689

13. Treacherous - 8.705

12. Style - 8.715

11. Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve - 8.721

10. This Is Me Trying - 8.727

9. Clean - 8.744

8. State Of Grace - 8.805

7. Wildest Dreams - 8.830

6. August - 8.861

5. Begin Again - 8.884

4. Love Story - 8.914

3. All Too Well - 9.017

2. Enchanted - 9.023

1. Cardigan - 9.034

 

Edited February 28, 2023 by 1989

[Fastlane]

I'm done:

 

1. Taylor Swift – 2.8 out 5.

2. Fearless – 3.6 out 5.

3. Speak Now – 3.9 out 5.

4. Red – 4.0 out 5.

5. 1989 – 3.8 out 5.

6. Reputation – 3.7 out 5.

7. Lover – 4.2 out 5.

8. Folklore – 3.6 out 5.

9. Evermore – 3.4 out 5.

10. Midnights – 3.0 out 5.

[Starchild]

This is dope, I love rates!

 

This better not be like most times where that overrated SN song and other overrated songs get top 10 again tho 

[Jaay]

I hate the be this person but the TV shouldn’t replace the originals but I digress I will rate as the originals 

Edited January 5, 2023 by Jaay

[Starchild]

1 minute ago, Jaay said:

I hate the be this person but the TV shouldn’t replace the originals 

Nobody wants to hear her screech through her old albums and some of the vault tracks are better than some album tracks 

[Jaay]

1 minute ago, Starchild said:

Nobody wants to hear her screech through her old albums and some of the vault tracks are better than some album tracks 

So when people lauded Red as a great album no one wanted to hear it? Hm, that’s interesting logic. Yikes.

[Fifteen]

Let me try 

[Starchild]

8 minutes ago, Jaay said:

So when people lauded Red as a great album no one wanted to hear it? Hm, that’s interesting logic. Yikes.

Who the hell said the album was bad? The re recorded albums are just better, her voice is smoother. The only complaints were the max tracks but everything else is an improvement

[Jaay]

19 minutes ago, Starchild said:

Who the hell said the album was bad? The re recorded albums are just better, her voice is smoother. The only complaints were the max tracks but everything else is an improvement

The only complaints from fans weren’t just the Max tracks. A lot of us fans prefer the original vocals on the original songs because they weren’t as smooth and evoked the emotion of the album. That being said, the vault tracks were such an overwhelmingly welcome addition to her discography.

[Shendelzare]

whew that's a lot of songs

[Shendelzare]

1 hour ago, Starchild said:

This is dope, I love rates!

 

This better not be like most times where that overrated SN song and other overrated songs get top 10 again tho 

Enchanted will stay on top

[KillingYourCareer]

I'm in! Ready to give justice for the Sounds of the Season: The Taylor Swift Holiday Collection

[RihannaLoverrr]

I’m in!

 

Wish Taylor’s version of her debut was out though, cause fearless (TV) vocals were such a massive improvement from the original.
I was waiting for the Taylor’s version of her debut before listening to it all the way through for the first time  

[Klein]

I'm in! It's going to be a hard time going through her entire discography. I might just rank all the songs and then give them a score depending on their position. 

[Dear Reader]

Im in. This is going to be so hard 

[TaylenaStan]

 the long list
But this is a great way to revisit all her past albums ahead of the eras tour 
Gonna try to listen to a full album front to back every few days and complete the list in 2-3 weeks, maybe sooner if i feel like it lets see

Also this time i'll try to be a bit harsher with my scores and not give everything a 7 or higher.. and also sabotage some legit good songs that i just know will get overrated.. a certain Midnights song comes to mind 

Edited January 5, 2023 by TaylenaStan

[Mr. Duff]

Will do this, and sabotage some of the songs

 

Evermore (the whole album) better get a lot of love!

[doonerr]

1 hour ago, RihannaLoverrr said:

 

I’m in!

 

Wish Taylor’s version of her debut was out though, cause fearless (TV) vocals were such a massive improvement from the original.
I was waiting for the Taylor’s version of her debut before listening to it all the way through for the first time  

Smoothers vocals or not the new version of Fifteen and You Belong With Me just sound wrong

[P!NK2LOVE]

I’m in! 

[luckythisway]

I want in! The Lakes is coming for top 5 

 

[Tusk]

 

Drop everything now!  I'm ready

[KillingYourCareer]

My ballot is IN!

 

Overall average: 5.75

 

Album averages:

7.06

6.43

6.41

6

5.98

5.75 (others section)

5.74

5.74

5.53

5.18

4.83

Edited January 5, 2023 by KillingYourCareer

[xfreshkidxx]

I'll join