Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive

This is part 1 of the K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive discussion.

Featured Replies

4 minutes ago, Mel. said:

What about her?

 

it’s cemented sweetie, they’re million sellers CONFIRMED by officials. Cry about it. I love that how counted them out, keep doing so 

 

 

Where are the other million copies? NMIXX have a rival with the fraudulent sales. 

  • Replies 131.8k
  • Views 10.9m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • aespa #1!    MYs can have arts AND charts now No chart updates on Spicy from you then?   I think not. Nope. They're at #1 now. Consider your points deb

  • Also @Mel. now that thread banning is back your two week ban starts now. 

  • Antisocialites
    Antisocialites

    some of the new members not giving new at all 

3 minutes ago, Mel. said:

What about her?

 

it’s cemented sweetie, they’re million sellers CONFIRMED by officials. Cry about it. I love that how counted them out, keep doing so 

not you accusing basically all non-yg acts of fraud weekly and then choosing to avoid this blatant fraud :bibliahh:

 

1 million copies are about to be shipped back bc as expected no one moved for their comeback:lmao:

 

2 hours ago, Odette Violet said:

Itzy girls has 3 more years :eli:

More like 1 year…

And idk but Ryan must’ve deleted the post, but I wanna let it be known cause I’m a petty *****, I put all 25 of you that thought it was funny that I got banned on ignore, you’re all BLOCKED and you’ll stay there

5 minutes ago, Mel. said:

What vision? I saw your post shading them sis…what’s the truth?

This post was me replying to your post about a TREASURE teaser:

 

On 7/16/2023 at 6:34 PM, Pluto2022 said:

I smell at least 1M sales with this one :clap3:

When I saw TREASURE's first day sales I was scared ngl and thought that my vision and smell had failed me for the first time, but looks like I'm always right in the end 

Melisandre.gif

6 minutes ago, DelRey said:

 

 

Where are the other million copies? NMIXX have a rival with the fraudulent sales. 

 

4 minutes ago, armink said:

not you accusing basically all non-yg acts of fraud weekly and then choosing to avoid this blatant fraud :bibliahh:

 

1 million copies are about to be shipped back bc as expected no one moved for their comeback:lmao:

 

I came prepared because I already knew you would pull that card, but it’s only ORGANIC over here. Just because your favs are frauds don’t mean mine are

 

 

Nq3yAro.png

 

But KTRL constantly told us there's an album sales leader?

 

xjaa6Of.gif

It’s quite funny how the narrative has suddenly changed :fan: TREASURE were flops for not keeping up with some of the other groups according to you girls and now they’re frauds…like pick a stuggle loll

 

you can’t have it both ways

Edited by Mel.

Not an NCT stan coming for fraudulent sales in general, when NCT DREAM latest album has over 600+ photocards :redface: The fact that they sold over 4M and yet TREASURE are literally out streaming them right now :redface:

 

Bona Bona = 9,7M streams 

ISTJ = 9,6M streams

 

Bona Bona was released 11 days after ISTJ btw, and they already managed to surpass them. 

 

Edited by Pluto2022

By the way, I guess we can also put to rest the talks of TREASURE being below ENHYPEN and ATEEZ as “REBOOT” has outsold both their latest releases

 

:fan:

Edited by Mel.

Need the SM building bulldozed. We were promised a fresh sporty new bg and they give us yet another NCT unit?? 

4 minutes ago, Mel. said:

It’s quite funny how the narrative has suddenly changed :fan: TREASURE were flops for not keeping up with some of the other groups according to you girls and now they’re frauds…like pick a stuggle loll

 

you can’t have it both ways

They are flops, you're just delusional. 

 

Just now, Pluto2022 said:

Not an NCT stan coming for fraudulent sales in general, when NCT DREAM latest album has over 600+ photocards :redface: The fact that they sold over 4M and yet TREASURE are literally out streaming them right now :redface:

 

Bona Bona = 9,7M streams 

ISTJ = 9,6M streams

 

Bona Bona was released 11 days after ISTJ and they already managed to surpass them. 

NCT DREAM is charting in Korea with multiple songs, that is their main market. They have been selling millions since Hot Sauce and touring around the world, I just saw them last month in Mexico with 20k more people so...

 

Treasure chart nowhere.

 

Skz have a lot of PCs too dont act like they have 50 :coffee2:

10 minutes ago, Mel. said:

 

I came prepared because I already knew you would pull that card, but it’s only ORGANIC over here. Just because your favs are frauds don’t mean mine are

 

 

 

hmm I guess faking sales is one way to appease your fanbase while "helping the environment" :clap3:

:giraffe:

 

Seventeen dating rumor ...

I wonder how knetz find non celebrities like these???

 

I remember jongdae's non-celeb girlfriend was also found in 2017 similarly by knetz... I wonder if he married the same girl.

1 minute ago, hallucinate said:

spacer.png

Roller Coaster's impact :clap3:

 

7Tm5KCx.gif

 

Damn I’m so disappointed on the Riize song :deadbanana4:! I really thought that SM would have gone for a boys next doors vibes with songs like Replay or Call me baby!
 

Really hope this is not their main sound :toofunny3:

1 hour ago, Flomik said:

They're still touring right now so I doubt it

Although I would love a cozy anniversary vlive filmed on an iphone like in the old days :heart2:

 

 

The fact that last year they did 2 separate lives bc they couldn’t do a group vlive :deadbanana4:

Your oppa made serval points here though @DelRey 

 It seems like none of the NCTzens had his back when he released this masterpiece including you, while I was the only person in the world who stood behind him and singlehandedly made sure that the song didn't flop and go under the radar  :ghostface:

I remember even including in it my 2022 year end rate while you didn't :oh: Which means I'm more of a loyal fan of Jaehyun papi than you are apparently? :giraffe:

 

Edited by Pluto2022

1 hour ago, DelRey said:

You truly love everything that EXO put outs even If its trash.

 

Like that Cream song or Dont fight the feeling, both are uninspired and mid songs but you liked them because is exo :coffee2:

 

Shinee is the best SM BG y ni modo

DFTF I can agree but Cream soda is far from mid :coffee2:

 

You truly love everything that EXO put outs even If its trash.

 

There is something about them that just makes everything better. :giraffe:

 

 

OT: when NCT debuted I actually was not 100% on board with the 7th sense at first because it sounded very empty-ish, chill instrumentals compared to what exo and SHINee for doing atm . HOWEVER I could immediately feel that it was something unique that no one else was doing. Plus SM was producing rap heavy music for the first time. So they actually debuted with a unique flavor that got them an audience. And later on it helped them develop their (noise) music identity. So actually I think NCT too had a good debut. 

 

Well.. Who knows maybe with their debut song rizze should also be able to showcase their unique sound. I don't want to hate on some 18 year old kids trying to do their best. But with SM's current management I am just not so sure about things anymore. NCT debuted at a time when SM was at their peak.

 

 

 

 

9 hours ago, Britney Jean said:

 

The live vocals omg. Eunchae also covering lots of Chaewon's lines there. She's the 3rd best vocalist confirmed :jonny4:

She always was, although she's not a great vocalist, she's alwayss been much more in tune and clear than Sakura, Kazuha and Garam when singing live (even if it doesn't seem much of a difference in the studio versions)

 

 

All this NCT slander made me think that while some bonafide stars in NCT like Jaehyun, Mark, etc deserve a better group better company better music and all that….I also can’t deny that Taeyong shines BECAUSE he’s in NCT. I feel like his style and vibe on stage matches with whatever sm gives NCT musically. I mean look at how much of his personality shines on this horrible ass song lol, i can’t imagine anybody else looking half as comfortable and not ridiculous as him while dancing to this :dies:

 

Happy monthsary to myself. Celebrating my 1 month here in KTRL with the Main Event of the Last Decade. 12 years later and still haven't been top in terms of total domination  :1stplace:

 

 

 

The first and only #1 female peaking album in Gaon Year End Chart, over 3M digital downloads, Digital Daesang/Artists of the Year winner, Hailed as Cultural Ambassadresses of Koria etc. etc. :gaycat1:

 

Edited by Odette Violet

46 minutes ago, Born to Run said:

Nq3yAro.png

 

But KTRL constantly told us there's an album sales leader?

 

xjaa6Of.gif

xjaa6Of.gif

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.