4 minutes ago, Zack said:

Giselle is for the intellectuals.

If you don't get her, it's your problem. She's just 2HOT4U.

 

are we biased towards western coded members too?

 

Just now, Asscatchem said:

are we biased towards western coded members too?

 

Are you counting KARINA, WINTER and NINGNING as western too?

 

Maybe someone needs a map.

 

Just now, Zack said:

Are you counting KARINA, WINTER and NINGNING as western too?

 

Maybe someone needs a map.

 

spin it however you like…

 

Do you think it’s a priority these days to have an English speaking member when putting together a group?

 

other than Twice, what other groups have zero members capable of communicating in English?

 

i’m overall a fan of aespa, their vocals are great across the board but their choreos beginning with girls era have felt so uncoordinated/ lethargic (?)

 

even watching them perform illusion at festivals it just feels like they give…. nothing 

 

Just now, Asscatchem said:

spin it however you like…

 

There's nothing to spin. I'm not going to be jumping on the Giselle hate train, no matter how en vogue it might be in this thread.

 

I'm in the privileged position of liking all of the aespa members and that isn't likely to change.

 

7 minutes ago, Save-Me-Oprah said:

how dare they let Yunjin go and replace her with Gizz

 

I actually think this was for the better

I literally can't imagine Yunjin pull off concepts like Kwangya and singing songs like Black Mamba, Savage, Next Level and Girls

 

The only title tracks where I can imagine her serving is Spicy and perhaps DCT

 

Le Sserafim on the other hand... you can just tell this is HER thing 

 

 

 

1 minute ago, Flomik said:

I actually think this was for the better

I literally can't imagine Yunjin pull off concepts like Kwangya and singing songs like Black Mamba, Savage, Next Level and Girls

 

The only title tracks where I can imagine her serving is Spicy and perhaps DCT

 

Le Sserafim on the other hand... you can just tell this is HER thing 

 

 

 

Yunjin would probably think the whole virtual member thing is so stupid

 

14 minutes ago, Asscatchem said:

shes lowkey a glorified english translator  its hard for me to sense any passion from her when she performs. it feels like she doesnt care most of the time

Imagine being added just bc you speak English, and ruining everything saying the N word in front of a camera . 

There's a reason why Winter went viral so many times for her fancam. Not everyone needs to be a bad ***** on stage. Kpop fans' obsession with glorified dancer needs to be studied. Maybe that's why these new girlies can't sing for **** anymore

Also Gizelle is not only one, bc how Lia was the one who made it in Itzy when Lily was literally there ??? And Lily  is even fluent in English ?

Like no one would have dare to drag them since she’s the best vocalist of the 4th gen 

Edited May 21, 20233 yr by Adama

Just now, Save-Me-Oprah said:

Yunjin would probably think the whole virtual member thing is so stupid

 

Do you think aespa members themselves secretly don't think it's stupid either?

 

Just now, Flomik said:

Do you think aespa members themselves secretly don't think it's stupid either?

 

Everybody does

 

Visuelle is for cunty people. you have to exude cuntiness to get her.

 

1 minute ago, Flomik said:

Do you think aespa members themselves secretly don't think it's stupid either?

 

They all dislike it I think. (In fact I think many SM idols have directly or indirectly expressed dislike for KWANGYA )

 

Giselle looks like she was dying inside when she was forced to talk about ae-KARINA's vacation to Croatia etc. She deserved a medal for making it to the end

 

 

Taking a stance again talentless nepo babies stealing places in top ggs from more deserving girls who are now doomed to rot away in nugudom feels like being on the right side of history  
 

There are far worse, tone-deaf idols to choose from in the industry than picking on Giselle. Especially when she’s out-singing most of the GGs today.

Edited May 21, 20233 yr by Rhythm

The kfans are crazy 

 

They are creating a buzz because of the part where they are dancing with women as pairs... the dance is one thing but people are questioning what the heck is up with the female back dancers' outfits

 

1 minute ago, Magdalene said:

also itzy are my girls but adding lia was such a choice

 

they’re a dance focused group so it just doesn’t make sense but even then for vocals we got chaeryeong and yeji killing their ariana and dua covers… and then there’s lia straining to taylor…

And Like I said Lily was literally right there for the Main vocal position + the English speak role 

10 minutes ago, Flomik said:

I actually think this was for the better

I literally can't imagine Yunjin pull off concepts like Kwangya and singing songs like Black Mamba, Savage, Next Level and Girls

 

The only title tracks where I can imagine her serving is Spicy and perhaps DCT

 

Le Sserafim on the other hand... you can just tell this is HER thing 

 

 

 

and we thank her for that! She embodies Lesserafim for me 

visuelle is the most talented member tho, she even produces 

16 minutes ago, Save-Me-Oprah said:

Do you think it’s a priority these days to have an English speaking member when putting together a group?

 

other than Twice, what other groups have zero members capable of communicating in English?

 

I was gonna say IVE but then realized miss Strawberry actually speaks good English 

but having said that, I don’t think they had thought of putting a translator in the group when finalizing the lineup

Edited May 21, 20233 yr by Witnessed ET

2 minutes ago, Magdalene said:

also itzy are my girls but adding lia was such a choice

 

they’re a dance focused group so it just doesn’t make sense but even then for vocals we got chaeryeong and yeji killing their ariana and dua covers… and then there’s lia straining to taylor…

Yeah can the Itchy stans stop pretending Lia is a good dancer? Nobody has ever made blatant mistakes like she did (not once but several times, no need to reinsert the evidences). And that has nothing to do with the other 4 being good dancers

SM should've just debuted aeapa as 3. They would've been perfect. Giselle stands out in a bad way although she's still a better singer than most idols nowadays. 

The way I bought 2 more red velvet birthday albums (green digi and yellow sm mini) in hopes to be blessed by queen joy and seulgi and I got Yeri (no problem with her just that I already pulled a lot of yeris)

Love them so much