Since I’ve seen many people discussing this in the Midnights thread, let’s put this to rest.

 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

And maybe just for fun 

 

16. I Don’t Wanna Live Forever vs ME!

 

Discuss 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot This Song Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

16. I Don’t Wanna Live Forever vs ME!th

 

Rep: 9

Lover: 7

 

Kinda shocked that it was that close, Rep does have some of her worst songs tho, but also some of her best. Lover meanwhile is just a mid album through and through.

Edited September 24, 20223 yr by smoore95GAGA

7 minutes ago, smoore95GAGA said:

Since I’ve seen many people discussing this in the Midnights thread, let’s put this to rest.

 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

Rep- 8

Lover - 7

 

both are bottom tier Taylor albums

1 minute ago, JoJo said:

Rep- 8

Lover - 7

 

both are bottom tier Taylor albums

Loser is indeed her worst album. For awhile I put it above just her debut, but over time I’ve come to realize that even that is better than it 

 

Rep will always hold a special place in my heart. Even tho I totally understand why it’s not seem as one of her stronger albums, it will likely always be my personal favorite of hers 

This has been going on since forever

 

We know that Reputation is better

Lover was only used against it by ppl that hate on it and Taylor at the time, but even they left it for folklore/evermore now

Just now, Rev8 said:

This has been going on since forever

 

We know that Reputation is better

Lover was only used against it by ppl that hate on it and Taylor at the time, but even they left it for folklore/evermore now

I completely agree that Rep is clearly better, although it is interesting that when I went track by track it was actually much closer than I thought it would be.

 

Am I secretly a Loser Lover 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed 

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

8-7 to Rep with both track 1s being tragic and Delicate/The Archer being a tie

6 minutes ago, smoore95GAGA said:

I completely agree that Rep is clearly better, although it is interesting that when I went track by track it was actually much closer than I thought it would be.

 

Am I secretly a Loser Lover 

Imo u should rank them instead of comparing them by their number of song

or even judge by the overall feel of the album

 

 

but Lover has some cute songs tho
the title track is one of Taylor's ALLtime best   (the video is pretty amazing too)

 

Just now, Rev8 said:

Imo u should rank them instead of comparing them by their number of song

or even judge by the overall feel of the album

 

 

but Lover has some cute songs tho
the title track is one of Taylor's ALLtime best   (the video is pretty amazing too)

 

That’s what I’m saying! Like overall it’s kind of a snoozefest, but then it has some of her best songs, somehow. Tbh it would’ve been better as an EP. 
 

1. Cruel Summer

2. Lover

3. The Archer

4. Miss Americana

5. DBATC

6. False God

7. Afterglow

 

Imagine how much better it would’ve been received!

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings neither

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better neither

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Rep: 8

Lover: 5

 

I guess I like Reputation better, but it's pretty close  

Taylor’s best album REPUTATION by far.

 

Lover is top 3 along with 1989.

 

K bye for now, Sunshine. <3

A couple of ties and a couple of wins for puta, but the answer is clear and by a landslide...

Reputation is better than that trash Loser. 

Rep For all

 

The only good song that Lover has is Cruel Summer, ironically is better than almost all Reputation tracks.

Lover by far.  It's not going to change. 

7 minutes ago, Rei said:

Lover is top 3 along with 1989.

 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down - that's a mid off really

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Reputa - 4

Lover - 11

That one album has nothing on Lover, I fear 

reputation and it’s not even close. 

I always struggled to choose between these two. Lover has a greater amount of songs I dislike, but it's overall a more entertaining listen than reputation, which has only one high peak for me (Call It What You Want). The two albums are bottom of the barrel of her discography either way.

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Rep: 5

Lover: 10

 

Lover wins.

Reputation

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Reputation: 6

Lover: 10

 

Checks out 

 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

reputation:  10 / lover: 5 

This is an insult to the iconic legendary game shaking MOMENT that is Reputation. 
 

L0#1sER sadly can’t relate. 

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Rep: 6

Lover: 8