1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Rep wins

1. …Ready for It? vs I Forgot That You Existed

2. End Game vs Cruel Summer

3. I Did Something Bad vs Lover

4. Don’t Blame Me vs The Man

5. Delicate vs The Archer (the only difficult choice) 

6. Look What You Made Me Do vs I Think He Knows

7. So It Goes… vs Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince

8. Gorgeous vs Paper Rings

9. Getaway Car vs Cornelia Street

10. King of My Heart vs Death By a Thousand Cuts

11. Dancing With Our Hands Tied vs London Boy

12. Dress vs Soon You’ll Get Better

13. This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things vs False God

14. Call It What You Want vs You Need to Calm Down

15. New Year’s Day vs Afterglow

 

Lover wins this one easily. 

New Year’s Day alone is much more mature, and creative than the entirety of that demo mixtape playlist, all written in the glitter gen pel Taylor says, diary-needing to sell, and rehash of her stolen past work.