Better song and video- Telephone. It was an iconic collab of two of the biggest stars in music, the video is supercharged camp, it was a moment in pop culture when it was released. It's a hard comparison because Rain on Me is an amazing song, however it isn't as magical as Telephone and what it did at the time. 

I think Rain on Me is the better song but love both! 

Telephone is so much better both song and a video. artwork - rom wins this one.

ROM for song & single cover.

 

Telephone is a great bop but one of my least fave singles from her. Now that music video was a major EVENT.

Rain On Me for Song/Cover, the song is dance-pop perfection and the cover is wonderfully tacky. The Telephone music video is a stomp tho

Telephone for all, although I love everything about ROM, but Telephone si just on another level.

Rain on Me dragged me down the street by my scalp the first time I heard it, it's everything I could have wanted from them. Telephone remains great, though.

 

Telephone is easily the better video. Camp, Tarantino-esque masterpiece.

Telephone is wayy better

Telephone is an iconic artful and timeless masterpiece, so that one. 

telephone is so iconic. 

like its one of the biggest pop culture moments in history.

Rain On Me

Telephone

Telephone is the superior song and has the better music video. I was over ROM after week 1 tbh.

Telephone for all, talk about iconic!

telephone is just iconic

but i do think roms cover is a bit better cause telephones is a bit outdated

Rain On Me but Telephone has the better video obviously.

Telephone’s video it’s obviously the better one

ROM’s cover is better,  Telephone’s one is so ugly

Both songs are great but I’d give the edge to Telephone  

I remember Twitter being a frenzy when the Telephone video dropped. 

Telephone is a masterpiece. ROM is so basic and boring next to it

Rain On Me better song and cover

 

Obviously Telephone has the better video

telephone sweetie...

both songs are incredible but Telephone still wins by a bit! 

Telephone better video of course

Rain on Me has a cooler single artwork  though

Teléfono >>>> Méame Encima for all except cover art (both equally horrible)

I think telephone is annoying and mediocre. The worst single to come out of Gaga in her prime. Bey doesn’t really add anything to it for me either. Though, the video is great. 
 

I think everyone hypes Telephone up wayyyy too much. I never listen to her. I think the melody is meh and I hate the vocal effects on it. It’s just barely better than video phone for me, and I am pretty sure everyone unanimously agrees that that one’s awful. I’ve never understood why everyone loves telephone, but I’m aware I’m the minority. 
 

On the other side, I love ROM and think she and Ari sound great together.