Yes, and add Smile, Melodrama and folklore to this list

I wouldn’t put money on it

Of course not

17 minutes ago, 80x100 said:

Yes, all those albums/artists flopped, and so did Joanne.

Edited June 21, 20224 yr by Nightglitch

The what... the flopping effect?

Of course. Her top 3 album did that  

Gaga has been leading the girls since The Fame, nothing new on that

The Sinner’s Prayer chanteuse did that!

 

Her best album. 

2 minutes ago, ontherocks said:

The what... the flopping effect?

it's true

Yes. Lady Gaga invented country and hats and anyone saying otherwise is an OGH 

No. It was a perfect delusion illusion. 

Whether people want to admit it or not, what Gaga does always trickles down to others. Whether or not she's the one who directly inspires these people, she's at least the one to put the ideas in their heads. The thing is, a lot of these artists don't actually come up with the themes and looks of their albums, rather their teams do, and we know for a fact that the teams of other popstars have always paid attention to what Gaga does.

 

the fact that “Joanne effect” wasn’t even coined by stans but the actual media  

 

of course the girlies here are pressed 

 

and it’s definitely real

 

(OP you also forgot Kylie’s Golden)

It was influential but the projects she influenced were BOMBS

Yes, as the Chromatica effect is also real (Beyonce, Rina, Drake, etc…)

More delusion.

Not saying Madonna did it first but she certainly did it long before that woman ever did...

 

 

 

14 minutes ago, Bang Up said:

Whether people want to admit it or not, what Gaga does always trickles down to others. Whether or not she's the one who directly inspires these people, she's at least the one to put the ideas in their heads. The thing is, a lot of these artists don't actually come up with the themes and looks of their albums, rather their teams do, and we know for a fact that the teams of other popstars have always paid attention to what Gaga does.

Exactly. 

 

OT: Yes

 

 

 

Kesha said she started working on Rainbow in 2014, before Joanne was released. 

 

Man Of The Woods has R&B, funk and pop elements while Joanne is pop-rock with some country elements. 

 

But more importantly, have these artists said anything about Joanne let alone cite it as an influence?  

22 minutes ago, GlamSlam said:

More delusion.

Not saying Madonna did it first but she certainly did it long before that woman ever did...

 

 

 

girl no one ever said gaga did it first, wyd?

you give your fave too much credit 

46 minutes ago, ontherocks said:

The what... the flopping effect?

yes 

44 minutes ago, Bang Up said:

Whether people want to admit it or not, what Gaga does always trickles down to others. Whether or not she's the one who directly inspires these people, she's at least the one to put the ideas in their heads. The thing is, a lot of these artists don't actually come up with the themes and looks of their albums, rather their teams do, and we know for a fact that the teams of other popstars have always paid attention to what Gaga does.