All the threads and fighting today  

 

you can tell people were waiting to call out Gaga for meh chart performance (but you can say that about most pop stars on this forum, people love a tear down!)

 

but again… anyone expecting anything from this to succeed commercially was just setting themselves up. 
 

can't wait for the lg7 lead… I hope we know the date by the 11th at the latest 

34 minutes ago, Miracle said:

The way Gaga's gonna have to add at least DWAS and HM (and prolly The Joker tbh) to the (likely) 2025 stadium tour + an entire album...I do hope she finally gets rid of old songs

 

 

 

As long as applause is back on the setlist she can do whatever tf she wants 

15 minutes ago, hausofbryan said:

And then you woke up 

 

Noooo 

 

I think its because he doesn't care about pop music. He doesn't even know who Olivia, Sabrina, Billie, Chappel are. But he really liked Harlequin. 

Gaga doesn't have any fillers on any of her main studio albums, maybe Money Honey (still a bop).

 

BTW bonus tracks, Jewels and Drugs, Donatella, Come to Mama, Fun Tonight, and 1000 Doves are all well justified thematically in the context of their albums. They tend to be disliked because they're too abrasive, too left-field or perhaps sonically redundant, but they don't really bloat the album because they keep adding something to it.

2 hours ago, Spicy Pisces said:

 

Tagging my vinyl sis @Daglazzo

Omg so excited thank you!

1 minute ago, Nando_05 said:

Noooo 

 

I think its because he doesn't care about pop music. He doesn't even know who Olivia, Sabrina, Billie, Chappel are. But he really liked Harlequin. 

Please tell us he at least knows who Ava Max is!

1 minute ago, Nando_05 said:

Noooo 

 

I think its because he doesn't care about pop music. He doesn't even know who Olivia, Sabrina, Billie, Chappel are. But he really liked Harlequin. 

I'm just teasing, love!  

 

I'm glad he enjoyed. 

43 minutes ago, AbeHicks said:

This is the last pop album we will get for the next 8-10 years because she will leave to become a mother, so I'd be happy with at least 15

  Reveal hidden contents

or 25

 

 

43 minutes ago, Miracle said:

Anyone wanting a shorter album always confuses me...I got it when CDs were physical so you bought the whole thing but as of right now...even if there's filler,  you can just choose which songs you prefer. Some people will find the "fillers" essential. Only thing is that critics still have a boner for albums with less tracks...so best solution is to just release a standard version and then a deluxe with 3 more tracks two weeks later lol

 

Call me old fashioned but I think it's better to have fewer songs that are great then some great and some good ones. Makes the album a more cohesive and logical experience, rather then sounding like a mixtape.

If there are more songs there can always be on a delux 

6 minutes ago, Denim said:

All the threads and fighting today  

 

you can tell people were waiting to call out Gaga for meh chart performance (but you can say that about most pop stars on this forum, people love a tear down!)

 

but again… anyone expecting anything from this to succeed commercially was just setting themselves up. 
 

can't wait for the lg7 lead… I hope we know the date by the 11th at the latest 

Fortunately, given it's basically a covers album, none of the Gaga stans actually care enough to meltdown.  Just perchedT for her next single (and to surpass 100M listeners.)

 

Just now, Thin White Duke said:

 

Call me old fashioned but I think it's better to have fewer songs that are great then some great and some good ones. Makes the album a more cohesive and logical experience, rather then sounding like a mixtape.

If there are more songs there can always be on a delux 

I feel like she did a good job with that with BTW and BTW Bonus version tbh.

 

The additions are ok, but would've weighed down the standard as a cohesive piece. 

27 minutes ago, hausofbryan said:

If Gaga made an album with a mixture of Just Another Day, Look What I Found, and World On A String, it'd be 5x platinum in the US.

 

Just sharing FAX.

 

Lmao

28 minutes ago, hausofbryan said:

If Gaga made an album with a mixture of Just Another Day, Look What I Found, and World On A String, it'd be 5x platinum in the US.

 

Just sharing FAX.

 

The absolute taste displayed here (and the absolute lack of it in the reactions) 

 

I'm waiting for stores to get the standard vinyl. Where is ittt

Gar needs to take LoveGame out of the setlist of her next tour, nothing against it but there are better songs in her discography 

 

 

Just Another Day is the best song on Joanne. 

3 minutes ago, Thin White Duke said:

The absolute taste displayed here (and the absolute lack of it in the reactions) 

She dabbles and dances around that sound over and over, but if she fully dove in, whew. The acclaim and sales she'd see. She's one of the ONLY (if not the only) pop girl that can pull that vocal style off over those instrumentals. 

 

and the numbers are exactly the same.  Can't wait for Day 2 when they fall below 143's 2nd day.

A Katy fan comment on the Spotify thread. These people never learn 

 

base really serving 'this is fine' today

 

3 minutes ago, Janet said:

I'm waiting for stores to get the standard vinyl. Where is ittt

We're really missing the top 10 bc of that surely…

8 minutes ago, Thin White Duke said:

 

Call me old fashioned but I think it's better to have fewer songs that are great then some great and some good ones. Makes the album a more cohesive and logical experience, rather then sounding like a mixtape.

If there are more songs there can always be on a delux 

People say this but this is not actually true. Less songs does not mean all those songs will be of stellar quality. Like look at Adele's 30 or 143. Both short albums. Are they all excellent?

 

And it doesn't work like that. The song you loathe will be someone else's favorite and vice versa.

3 minutes ago, Smarticle said:

base really serving 'this is fine' today

 

If she holds at #1 on Spotify tomorrow, we have the:

 

"Gaga has the biggest song of 2024. Surprised?" 

 

ready to go

 

13 minutes ago, AbeHicks said:

Please tell us he at least knows who Ava Max is!

Not even I know who Baba Max is 

 

Spoiler

Gaga queen

 

5 minutes ago, Album Leak said:

Just Another Day is the best song on Joanne. 

And guess which producer didn't put his hands on that one