November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850511 8 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said: PI didn’t lack personality though, it was just not lead single worthy. its a bland kinda generic song.. literally could have been released by anyone Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850511 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850521 Just now, flower moon said: its a bland kinda generic song.. literally could have been released by anyone I don’t agree at all. I just think both PI and Houdini sound like third singles, rather than being on par with Bad Romance or DSN. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850521 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850579 6 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said: I don’t agree at all. I just think both PI and Houdini sound like third singles, rather than being on par with Bad Romance or DSN. well i guess i could agree with that. but to you, what vibe do you think she/they were going for with PI? it always gave me a half baked idea/very much demo vibes. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850579 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850598 1 minute ago, flower moon said: well i guess i could agree with that. but to you, what vibe do you think she/they were going for with PI? it always gave me a half baked idea/very much demo vibes. Unfortunately I got the same vibes. I think it was chosen because it was more poppy, but the fact that it was Gaga’s shortest lead single also added to the demo vibe. Diamond Heart would’ve been a better introduction to the era IMO. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850598 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850600 Kevin Parker did his job. The last part of PI is pure Tame Impala magic, too bad Fad ruined it with her shrieking. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850600 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850604 Perfect Illusion still sounds better than Houdini Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850604 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850620 At least Houdini is way better than PI. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850620 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850628 It’s almost 2024, you guys can stop pretending to hate Perfect Illusion Direct that hate to real trash like Sinner’s Prolapse Edited November 10, 20232 yr by Bhabylon Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850628 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850633 Just now, Bhabylon said: It’s almost 2024, you guys can stop pretending to hate Perfect Illusion Direct that hate to real trash like Sinner’s Prolapse Sinner’s Classic is one of her most underrated deep cuts. Let’s fight the real enemy A-NAL. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850633 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr ATRL Moderator comment_24850665 perfect illusion and sinners prayers slander is childish lol Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850665 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850696 Perfect Illusion is in Gar's top three best lead singles and Houdini is Dua's best lead period. I think Kevin is the missing piece that the pop girls need to serve. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850696 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850706 I remember the PIss thread before being released and everyone was so hyppped and getting posts every second. They way monsters VANISHED after the drop tho. Houdini, indeed Edited November 10, 20232 yr by FailSafe Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850706 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850720 5 minutes ago, Bandito said: Perfect Illusion is in Gar's top three best lead singles and Houdini is Dua's best lead period. I think Kevin is the missing piece that the pop girls need to serve. Houdini is nowhere near as good as DSN, don't let recency bias fool you. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850720 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850763 Jesus was hated in his time. Perfect Illusion will get her flowers come 2365. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850763 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850774 ATRL needs to stop acting like Joanne is the worst album ever. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850774 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850781 Perfect Illusion isn't a perfect song but this fanbase wouldn't feel the same way if it smashed, at all. Edited November 10, 20232 yr by EnigmaticAndroid Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850781 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850791 2 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Perfect Illusion isn't a perfect song but this fanbase wouldn't feel the same way if it smashed, at all. That was never going to happen though girl. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850791 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850792 Perfect Illusion was literally years ahead of its time musically and somebody does a similar sound almost a full DECADE later and y'all are gagging and calling PI bad. Gaga is a genius musically and this cycle of reducing her continues to prove it. Never change liddos. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850792 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850806 i always forget how much this base loves old crusty demos, so not surprised with the piss love Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850806 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850837 10 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said: That was never going to happen though girl. Oh I know, just saying Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850837 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850847 Perfect Illusion is a pretty divisive song, but calling it bland and generic is just wild Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850847 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850852 12 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: Perfect Illusion was literally years ahead of its time musically and somebody does a similar sound almost a full DECADE later and y'all are gagging and calling PI bad. Gaga is a genius musically and this cycle of reducing her continues to prove it. Never change liddos. Yup, love to see a liddo who is strong enough to know the truth Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850852 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850854 Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850854 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850863 The only thing that PIsses me off about PI is the fact that it did not sound like the album at all I was ready for an album of GrungeGa, instead we got DepressedGa singing about daddy issues and appealing to middle American soccer moms Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850863 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
November 10, 20232 yr comment_24850869 2 minutes ago, Almodusa said: Let me switch like a ****** Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/395666-lady-gaga/page/4261/#findComment-24850869 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
