ericcartman

Not surprised. Gaga has her hits but also has a lot of misses. Ari has been consistently successful for a while now. But both are successful so not a drag on either of them

Sales alone are not enough. You need longevity or impact. This is probably about Taylor and even though her impact doesn't compare to someone like Madonna or Beyonce, her longevity and sustained success alone will have her regarded as a legend.

Mariah and Janet have to stay Whitney does have the weakest albums but her hits make up for it. Also, even the weak the filler is good for a some listens for that voice alone. So good bye Mary.

Madonna would be both 80s and 90s Beyonce obviously for 00s Taylor or Gaga or Rihanna or Beyonce for 10s Taylor or Billie for 20s

Which of these women made the better song? Adela for "Nicole Kidman" or Sza for "Drew Barrymore"

You can't use a Bruno Mars song to discredit Taylor

This is objectively gross and cringe but we are in the middle of Taylor's hate train so we have no choice to stan. Get it Olivia! Use that armpit sweat

What happened with Kelly?

Teenage dream was the bigger musical era. Britney had a bigger peak as her peak included multiple albums/era plus she had the bigger celebrity profile and pop culture moment.

Even with the Litmus push, obviously not. Beyonce surpassed Brit in like 2003 and the gap just kept getting bigger. It's an insult to Bey to compare the two.

I was expecting to see Olivia here as I figured she was the intended target of this thread. But I didn't realize Billie only has the one week as she's always been successful

You know, she's like the same old. You know, her videos are very bowling pin formation, dancers behind, you know, it's nothing that you haven't seen yet. I was like, "Oh, you know, she's dope, you know... Im always hoping for something a little more exciting. You know but, you know, it was what it was and she's a tiktok star and that's that.

It's bad but It doesn't really count either. It's not really considered part of her discography. Something like ME and Stupid Love are far worse in that they were made to be lead singles of a full studio album

Meh... Should have worn transparent underwear

Meh it's typical FYC as, no desperation Did showgirl really get 5 stars from RS? How did I miss that thread

It's obviously Beyonce and some of these names why even bother including them (eg Selena Gomez)

This is surprising honestly. Who is buying that.

Not sure why acting is included for pop star's. If the bar is low enough to give credit to Gaga as a dancer, then a lot of others need to be changed as well no shade. Also no shade, it's worth noting that being capable and great are different things. Some artists can do a lot of things and will have a check mark across the board while someone like Bey is actually great at many categories.

Why is Madonna not in this gif

These are some of Gaga's best singles while some of Taylor's worst singles

Record breaking #1 album

Nobody watches the VMA

It was cute the first week

Mariah was mostly taking a jab and Madonna's decline in popularity in the 90s, not really her age. Either way she was defending herself.

#thankyougracieabrams