Which album is better? Madonna's best album in 2 decades? Or Tinashe's acclaimed album that Pitchfork calls "the best pop album of the year"?

Discuss.

Edited 8 hours ago8 hr by Maxxxine

Totally different albums! But LES Girl (featuring Tinashe) (POPSTAR Afterhours Mix) when?

Just now, Taylor fanboy said:

Totally different albums! But LES Girl (featuring Tinashe) (POPSTAR Afterhours Mix) when?

The only correct answer

kinda incomparable. Two great albums released this year.

Odd comparison

13 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said:

LES Girl (featuring Tinashe)

Hold on.

I liked Confessions more but Popstar is very solid.

12 minutes ago, Appletree said:

Odd comparison

Are they both not pop albums?

Popstar. Madonna can only do so much with her mediocre vocals

Popstar and it's not even close

Confessions II and it's not even close.

Confessions II by far.

The one that was scored 9.0 BNM

The one that debuted at #1.

I REFUSE VOTING

the one with School

both incredible works that display the artists' mastery of their craft

The one that doesn't sound AI generated

AOTY on AOTY war

School Nashe mix to settle the score

For CII takes it and it's not even close BUT Popstar is an interesting concept record in a sense

1 hour ago, Taylor fanboy said:

Totally different albums! But LES Girl (featuring Tinashe) (POPSTAR Afterhours Mix) when?

Okaaay

C2

CII but i love both

Popstar is an amazing album but the tracklist goes everywhere

we need an anonymous poll. I refuse to participate in the banning of myself.