Which legend has the superior most recent album?

I like madame X

This title track alone clears discographies - that's tea

The way I forgot about this Mariah era, as if it didn't even happen...

Stream Dangerous Type

I will defend Madame X in other threads, it is undeniably her best album since Hard Candy. Arguably, her best album since Ray of Light, but I personally prefer Confessions

Edited March 7Mar 7 by Reginald

Madame X may have lower lows but it is much more interesting.

10 minutes ago, Reginald said:

Arguably, her best album since Ray of Light

You're correct by saying "arguably". I would definitely argue against this

both are kinda horrible

here for it all is slightly worse cause mariah sounds awful, you can hear her voice straining in most of the songs

My opinion:

7,005 streams - 2018 - Caution
5,789 streams - 2014 - Me. I am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse
5,690 streams - 2025 - Here for it All
2,429 streams - 2015 - Rebel Heart
1,942 streams - 2019 - Madame X

Caution and Madame X are of the same era. HFIA and Madame X are not.

Here for It All (song) and Giving Me Life are the 2 best recordings ever made in human history.

Edited March 7Mar 7 by stevyy

Mariah's voice is completely shot on this album. Here for it all song is so overrated by lambs.

Sugar sweet was cute.

Metacritic:

82 - 2018 - Caution
73 - 2025 - Here for It All
74 - 2020 - The Rarities
67 - 2014 - Me. I am Mariah
60 - 2010 - Merry Christmas II
70 - 2009 - Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel
64 - 2008 - E=MC²
64 - 2005 - The Emancipation of Mimi
43 - 2002 - Charmbracelet
59 - 2001 - Glitter

4 positively rated albums in a row. <3

6 minutes ago, stevyy said:

Metacritic:

82 - 2018 - Caution
73 - 2025 - Here for It All
74 - 2020 - The Rarities
67 - 2014 - Me. I am Mariah
60 - 2010 - Merry Christmas II
70 - 2009 - Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel
64 - 2008 - E=MC²
64 - 2005 - The Emancipation of Mimi
43 - 2002 - Charmbracelet
59 - 2001 - Glitter

4 positively rated albums in a row. <3

Can you please post daily, weekly and total streams from each of the albums? And then from each song of each of the albums?

1 minute ago, Yes, AND said:

Mariah's voice is completely shot on this album. Here for it all song is so overrated by lambs.

Sugar sweet was cute.

So, you're not here for it all. In fact you've never been there. But you can repent, and listen to this masterpiece now.

I'm kinda obsessed with Sugar Sweet so Mi takes it this time

Just now, stevyy said:

So, you're not here for it all. In fact you've never been there. But you can repent, and listen to this masterpiece now.

We both know she wasn't singing.

Just now, Yes, AND said:

We both know she wasn't singing.

oh spill.. who was? Katy?

3 minutes ago, Toxic Love said:

Can you please post daily, weekly and total streams from each of the albums? And then from each song of each of the albums?

it's too toxic. too little love.

Rehearsal, test flight, you just gotta, praise the most high.

7 minutes ago, stevyy said:

Metacritic:

82 - 2018 - Caution
73 - 2025 - Here for It All
74 - 2020 - The Rarities
67 - 2014 - Me. I am Mariah
60 - 2010 - Merry Christmas II
70 - 2009 - Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel
64 - 2008 - E=MC²
64 - 2005 - The Emancipation of Mimi
43 - 2002 - Charmbracelet
59 - 2001 - Glitter

4 positively rated albums in a row. <3

Anything below 80 is mixed, not positive.

And Caution only had 8 reviews submitted.

3 minutes ago, stevyy said:

oh spill.. who was? Katy?

She lipped to a rough track before final processing.

MADAME XCELLENCE of course

The Mirwais tracks are like some of the best music ever. The production

everyone is too scared to make a political song like God Control and Batuka. Futue (Tour Version) is 10/10

My HFIA streams in detail:

944 - Here for It All
656 - Confetti & Champagne
605 - Mi
589 - Nothing is Impossible
535 - Play This Song
499 - My Love
497 - In Your Feelings
487 - I won't Allow It
306 - Type Dangerous (+1,241 from the single)
288 - Jesus I Do
283 - Sugar Sweet (+296 from the single)

This is just a rehearsal.

Medellin vs Mi

Dark Ballet vs Play This Song

God Control vs Type Dangerous

Future vs Sugar Sweet

Bataka vs In Your Feelings

Killers Who Are Partying vs Nothing Is Impossible

Crave vs Confetti & Champagne

Crazy vs I Won't Allow It

Come Alive vs My Love

Faz Gostoso vs Jesus I Do

B*tch I'm Loca vs Here for It All

3 vs 8

Mariah takes it

Just say u hate her. Don't invent a narrative to sound edgy. There's nothing edgy about trashing Miss Carey in 2026. It's kinda sad.

2 minutes ago, Yes, AND said:

She lipped to a rough track before final processing.

The beauté is cooking.

2 minutes ago, stevyy said:

Just say u hate her. Don't invent a narrative to sound edgy. There's nothing edgy about trashing Miss Carey in 2026. It's kinda sad.

You're a stan.

You know she never sings live anymore. Be fr.