Both are very polarizing figures within the GP and stans. But how did Tate manage to be bigger? I would think Addison's music is better.

They are friends...

Edited February 10Feb 10 by RoseBud

Tate is the Paula Abdul to Addison's Madonna (Although Paula is an Emmy-winning choreographer)

All you have to do is watch one performance of each and it will show you why.

Also Tate has young fans. Addisons fan group is mostly comprised of older gay men.

Girl idk. Maybe she had a better diet during puberty or something.

Tate is less experimental and more generic, it's like asking why Britney was bigger than Kylie

Solo top 10 hits:

• Tate: 1

• Adisson: 0

Boatmates...

One has hits, the other has a good pr team

2 minutes ago, YourFavoriteWeapon said:

Tate is less experimental and more generic, it's like asking why Britney was bigger than Kylie

How so ? Addison literally works with max's team

Tate is more experimental and less generic, it's like asking why Madonna was bigger than Cyndi

bigger but not better

Tate's been around since 2017, has 3 albums out and has grown her fanbase with each release

2 minutes ago, Opium said:

Solo top 10 hits:

• Tate: 1

• Adisson: 0

Boatmates...

Tate has two solo #3 hits actually (Greedy and *** For Tat)

Bonus:

Top 50 hits:

• Tate: 15 (13 solo)

• Adisson: 0

Sabrina Carpenter is bigger than Björk. Why?

Outside of stan twitter and atrl, nobody takes Addison seriously.. Tate has legit pop diva credibility

14 minutes ago, Opium said:

hits

5 minutes ago, NewStanner said:

*** For Tat

This song was not a hit.

Top 50? The bar in literal hell...

1 minute ago, Opium said:

This song was not a hit.

Top 50? The bar in literal hell...

19 weeks and it's still charting in the top 40, how is that not a hit.

And yes, top 50 is a bar in hell indeed, that's why it's so shocking when one girl doesn't even have one.

more mainstream appeal

25 minutes ago, Beamon said:

bigger but not better

I thought bigger is always better though ?

Just now, Mocha said:

Outside of stan twitter and atrl, nobody takes Addison seriously.. Tate has legit pop diva credibility

Both (+ Gracie) are Meme Pop Girls, nobody takes them seriously...

mcdonalds bigger than good food, why?

Tate has picked up the straight girls over the years.

Addison's niche is still very much in the FKA Twigs/Arca audience.

H&M is more "popular" than Maison Margiela.

Sales are not a sign of quality, so what's your point?

1 hour ago, YourFavoriteWeapon said:

Tate is less experimental and more generic, it's like asking why Britney was bigger than Kylie

comparing Addison to Kylie is an insult to Kylie.

Just now, Pop said:

H&M is more "popular" than Maison Margiela.

Sales are not a sign of quality, so what's your point?

as if addition is not forever 21 or zara