vs

 

 

Dirrty was basically Christina Aguilera copying what Britney was doing. Anyway, Gimme More > Legend X's entire discography.

I'm sure this thread will be very thoughtful and calm without attracting the usuals.

Gimme More x 3 

The Gimme More MV is ATROCIOUS, it is the better song but that's it. everything else about Dirrty is better

Gimme More

Both are great bops.

 

Song - Gimme More

 

Video - Dirrty

 

Character - Stripper (because I stan ha and her minidress on the funeral version )

Dirrty has the better MV, other than that its Gimme More. 

I was obsessed with both songs and eras as they were released but 'Gimme More' is the better song. 

Dirrty intro is more remembered than Brits discography 

people voting GM for video

23 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

people voting GM for video

Literally worms 

Dirrty was the last great thing Christina released.

 

Gimme More for all, though. The "idgaf" nature of GM and Blackout as a whole just does something for me  

Song: GM

MV: Dirrty

GM video is a choice, infamous at best, and yet it has double the views of Dirrty on YouTube, not shocking at all though.

Having said that. Gimme More is one of Britney's classics, and obviously, the better song

 

Gimme More is kinda the best song ever recorded

 

1 hour ago, sunbathinganimal said:

people voting GM for video

obviously it's not better than the dirrrty video, but something in that video it's iconic lmao. I love it idk why, it's basic but good. 

Britney's record label greenlighting that video in that phase of her life will never cease to baffle me.

I mean... it does fit the song perfectly, but it was a (entertaining) low-effort disaster after all the top-tier music videos she's given prior.

Song is kinda a tie, maybe I like Gimme More a bit more, video goes to Dirrty 100%

GM is the better song but no way that it's the better video unless you're blind.

Dirrty for all!

I remember that wasn't the original idea for the GM MV and it changed. Was suppose to be darker or something.

better song: gimme / better mv: dirrty

44 minutes ago, Magic_boXX said:

I remember that wasn't the original idea for the GM MV and it changed. Was suppose to be darker or something.

This is so good 🫶🏻

59 minutes ago, Death & Decay said:

Dirrty for all!

Both iconic but yes