8 hours ago, lgaga1fan said:

This narrative is extremely tired. NJZ girls actually sang live a LOT,

What's there to sing in their songs lol, they were mediocre vocalists like, below Jihyo, Rose, Jisoo, or Nayeon level, whatever dancers, their music was appealing but there was nothing outstanding about them sans the music and their distinctive choreo.

1 minute ago, Odette Violet said:

so are you ignoring all the other western pop girls I listed besides Mariah?  I didn't even mentioned Ariana and I stan her  

Just count yourself lucky Wendy already left SM or this would have been a case for KWANGYA 119

 

 

The way I know H2H are doing well, in general (singing, dancing, song quality), is because I know about half their names now. I use myself as a barometer for success because I actually don't know anything. 

KATSEYE about to eat. I fear.

I don't get this narrative that we should wait for more material when the strongest vocalists of SM's previous ggs had already the portfolio why they got their positions right at the bat. 

 

if SM is truly confident with this girls vocals. We would've some cute acapella by now and them sitting down with MICS ON but all you get here is they're all better dancers than aespa / RV okay so does 90% of Kpop  

6 hours ago, Ubermensch said:

Anyway every single sone is better than every single non-sone. Users who spend so much time policing other's behavior in this thread should really reflect on the escalation from sheep bickering with each other over a rookie year comeback to calling somebody a loser and telling them to leave the website. Let's keep it cute and shady.

Not this on the same timeline that you just told me to leave the site and I'm not welcomed Last but not least monitored my posts 

55 minutes ago, Ubermensch said:

H2H have already done more live singing than aespa

Have they?

You want vocals and dance and personality?

 

 

Stan KATSEYE 

 

1 hour ago, Windy Day said:

this makes zero sense i fear

 

they're supposed to be pop singers

 

they record music and promote it first and foremost. beyonce is an amazing dancer but she's an even better singer because that's her job

 

hearts2hearts' job is to sing on stage, while dancing yeah, but that comes AFTER singing

 

do you listen to their choreography? 

why are you dragging them? I thought you like them

 

22 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

What's there to sing in their songs lol, they were mediocre vocalists like, below Jihyo, Rose, Jisoo, or Nayeon level, whatever dancers, their music was appealing but there was nothing outstanding about them sans the music and their distinctive choreo.

so outstanding music and choreo isn't enough damn, really show how the music itself isn't a priority for a lot of kpop fans

 

reminds me of some Katseye thread where someone said they're obsessed with them but just need them to finally drop a good song so they can stan

2 hours ago, OrbitNumber1 said:

 

HOLY **** 

Why are the vocalfags in the thread quiet about this performance. I thought you guys were into k-pop for the vocals 

2 minutes ago, OrbitNumber1 said:

Why are the vocalfags in the thread quiet about this performance. I thought you guys were into k-pop for the vocals 

the music is not giving. You gotta have BOTH the vocals and good music 

This whole ep was so cute  

Sana is truly one of the most beautiful women in the world. Hobi is so strong, I wouldn't know how to act if she looked at me like that and I'm a straight woman  

 

 

9 minutes ago, K$Ellie said:

so outstanding music and choreo isn't enough damn, really show how the music itself isn't a priority for a lot of kpop fans

 

reminds me of some Katseye thread where someone said they're obsessed with them but just need them to finally drop a good song so they can stan

Music is subjective, people are dragging Flop2Flop because of their lack of vocal talent while down voting my posts just because I claimed NJ are just as talentless as other groups that have been dragged in the past. 

K-pop is really dead huh

 

 

anyway I'm not a vocal nazi. I can excuse the lack of singing talent if they actually have something to compensate it for eh good music and serving cvnt for days 

 

Happy 13 Year to this PAK thot anthem 

 

 

10 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

the music is not giving. You gotta have BOTH the vocals and good music 

Or maybe you guys didn't even press play on the stage of QWER's top 30 hit song and chose to spend more time discussing the vocal skills of a dance-focused group.

1 hour ago, Pluto6 said:

@DelRey What's withe the "" emoji? Did I lie? Do you seriously believe a group where Haechan is the main vocalist isn't one of the weakest SM groups vocally?

Riize and Dream don't belong in the same sentence tho

 

Haechan, Chenle and Renjun are good vocalists, Riize only have Sohee.

 

 

Are TWICE really going to drop the album all at once? No pre-release singles?

I'll just check back in 4 years to see whether H2H has anything for a hagologist like me.

H2H is very boring but these teenybopper children are not targeted towards me so that's fine

 

15 minutes ago, smates said:

This whole ep was so cute  

Sana is truly one of the most beautiful women in the world. Hobi is so strong, I wouldn't know how to act if she looked at me like that and I'm a straight woman  

 

 

people better not start the delusional shipping because Sana is way out of his league

 

H2H doesn't feel like a SM group. They're so cheap and nugu'd  

somiana comeback this july  give us another bop like fast forward please

imo

good music > vocals > dancing

 

all three are important ofc to an extent but i just can't see myself stanning a group just because they are great vocalists or dancers, music needs to click for me first. i'll appreciate them for their talent but that's it

Edited June 19, 20251 yr by hallucinate