Which Lady Gaga lead single is better? 

vs.

 

Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease
Disease

Stupid Love's intro annoys me more than anything. 

Disease is coming from Bloody Mary's land and feels more creative. 

 

However stupid love's hook freak out freak out freak out look at me part is so Gaga so camp and her vocals so fun.

 

Its almost a tie but Disease wins because of that annoying Stupid Love intro. 

Disease for all 3 by quite a large margin (and I say this as someone who enjoys Stupid Love)

I swear I feel we had this thread 2 days ago. 
 

but Disease for sure

Stupid Love for the song

Disease for the rest

Song - Stupid Love, Artistry - Disease.

 

But the video...

Stupid Love mv is campy AF and reminds me of how cool the concept of Chromatica was with the tribes and all... I actually really like rewatching it for the choreography and fun factor  In hindsight, it's also bittersweet how that video was pretty much the last hoorah of the pre-COVID pop music world.

But the Disease mv has some of Gaga's best looks and sickest visuals to date that are on another level. I LOVE Gaga in black hair + the themes are quite dark 

 

Tough choice. It just depends on what I want from my music video!

Edited October 30, 20241 yr by psychodiva336

Disease 

So It performing worse than SL commercially, as the 'shallow' of 2024 continues to blow up Spotify, shows PopGa could indeed be the issue 

Phew, I am still in disbelief that Stupid Love exists. I don't think any of the girls has ever fumbled a comeback THIS bad. Lots of them have released bad songs or bad videos or both, but this was a time when it was perfectly feasible for Gaga to actually smash. Like Ray of Light / Emancipation / Private Dancer type of return-to-form, not just one or two cute hits and back to Cyndiville. And she gave this

 

But anyway, yeah, Disease is better, although the verses are some of the worst pop writing ever. Ever. A torment of a melody to get through

7 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

Disease 

So It performing worse than SL commercially, as the 'shallow' of 2024 continues to blow up Spotify, shows PopGa could indeed be the issue 

She is promo sensitive. She needs to perform disease at 2-3 tv shows and watch the song take off 

The fact that there are people who actually voted for SL in any category...

I enjoy Stupid Love, but Disease is taking it 

1 minute ago, Démodé said:

The fact that there are people who actually voted for SL in any category...

I did. Disease is grating, grating on the ears. It hadn't grown on me at all. It wins the other two categories though.

1 minute ago, Capris Groove said:

I did. Disease is grating, grating on the ears. It hadn't grown on me at all. It wins the other two categories though.

I admire your bravery. SL is indeed very stupid, her worst lead and an atrocious song overall.

Edited October 30, 20241 yr by Démodé

Stupid Love is my fav. Only weakness of that song is the repetitive chorus. Disease is good too, but you have to be in a certain mood for it.

SL for all. it made me a fan during pandemic. need time for disease. it reminds me of judas

Disease for all.

Stupid Love is the better song, Disease got the better video (both a boring and cheap mess tho)

 

And there's not artistry found in both tracks.