State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would (tie, idk)

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "****!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

Red, sweetie, don't worry, she didn't mean it!

1 minute ago, Cruel Summer said:

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would (tie, idk)

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "****!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

Red, sweetie, don't worry, she didn't mean it!

SSS over WD?! 

 

1989 is short, simple and sweet.

 

Perfect cohesive album!

 

OverRatED cannot relate!

Just now, Forever Winter said:

SSS over WD?! 

 

I never liked Lanaest Dreams and I won't start now 

 

I almost thought the one I'd get called out over is AYHTDWS over All Too Well, though!

4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

SSS over WD?! 

i'd say that, taylor's silly songs are underrated

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

 

it is not even close never was and never will be

50 minutes ago, makeawish said:

i'd say that, taylor's silly songs are underrated

She definitely has a knack for a CAMPy style, I hope she does a full album full of humorous folk/campfire songs

not familiar enough to do the vault tracks (tho tbf the 1989 ones aren't that good, IION aside), but:

 

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

 

1989 shades it, tho as a 13 track album it's solidly more consistent than the 16 track red imo

I hate these track vs track ratings. It feels discriminatory tbh

 

Realistically it should go like

 

All too well=state of grace>clean>stay>etc. With the first song having 1 point, the 2nd 2 and the next 3 and so on. The album with the lower score will then win the rating

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

Red: 10
1989: 12

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

Red is better and more timeless, for me.

Although 1989 makes me more nostalgic for that time when it was current release.

 

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off 

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

Edited August 2, 20241 yr by Gladiator

22 hours ago, Forever Winter said:

 

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Red is too bloated IMO. 1989 is Taylor's best album, only rivaled by Reputation.

I'm on mobile so I hope the formatting isn't too bad:

 

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

1989 wins for me. 

State of Grace vs Welcome to New York

Red vs Blank Space

Treacherous vs Style

I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of the Woods

All Too Well vs All You Had to Do Was Stay

22 vs Shake It Off

I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood

Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams

The Last Time vs How You Get the Girl

Holy Ground vs This Love

Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places

The Lucky One vs Clean

Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland

Starlight vs You Are in Love

Begin Again vs New Romantics

The Moment I Knew vs "Sl*t!"

Come Back...Be Here vs Say Don't Go

Girl at Home vs Now That We Don't Talk

Better Man vs Suburban Legends

Nothing New vs Is It Over Now?

Babe vs Sweeter Than Fiction

 

1989 clears with ease. Style and I Know Places are both amazing as well and clear the majority of Red, they just happened to be up against Red's best songs. 

1989 is amazing but Red is also really good. 1989 >>>