The same as the second decade thread, but make it their third decades!

00s Madonna

 

10s Mariah

Edited January 3, 20242 yr by UseYourIllusion2002

You are SICK for this set up 

i will decide after stevyy posts their Spotify numbers

I pick Madonna, but I'll be perched for them Mariah stans and their spreadsheets.

Music album alone >>> Mariah's third decade.

Well Stevvy told me Mariah is the 38th most succesful female touring artist born in 1969 who debuted in 1990 so it must be her!

 

Poor Mariah

 

The answer is obviously Madonna.

Madonna of course

Well Erotica tanked so obviously Mariah!!!!!!

you're missing Remixed and Revisited and Celebration.

 

answer is Madonna, of course.  Confessions alone >>>

Next poll: Bigger childhood, Madonna (60s) or Mariah (70s)?

46 minutes ago, tost1 said:

i will decide after stevyy posts their Spotify numbers

 

44 minutes ago, Kyoto said:

I pick Madonna, but I'll be perched for them Mariah stans and their spreadsheets.

 

44 minutes ago, Love Again said:

Well Stevvy told me Mariah is the 38th most succesful female touring artist born in 1969 who debuted in 1990 so it must be her!

This being less of a Mariah setup and more of a stevyy setup is wild 

12 minutes ago, spree said:

you're missing Remixed and Revisited and Celebration.

 

answer is Madonna, of course.  Confessions alone >>>

Ehh I didn't forget them but I didn't see the point of adding Remixed and Revisited, and Mariah only had three studio albums in her third decade while Madonna released consistently, so I had to give Mariah a fair chance.

11 minutes ago, nostalgic said:

Next poll: Bigger childhood, Madonna (60s) or Mariah (70s)?

 no it'll be bigger first decade, which will probably be a disaster. 

 

1 minute ago, wastedpotential said:

 

 

This being less of a Mariah setup and more of a stevyy setup is wild 

His random spreadsheets he inserts in every thread, even when they don't concern Mariah, are always hilarious. 

Madonna doesn't have a xmas jingle that goes number one once a year because Billboard keeps constantly changing the rules therefore making their charts utterly useless by making seasonal songs chart together with album tracks that are allowed to chart but before that rule change that did not happen so now it is unfair to compare charts from others decades to the current ones so Mariah

3 minutes ago, UseYourIllusion2002 said:

Ehh I didn't forget them but I didn't see the point of adding Remixed and Revisited, and Mariah only had three studio albums in her third decade while Madonna released consistently, so I had to give Mariah a fair chance.

but if you're going to have a Mariah greatest hits, you should include Madonna's too....all of them.  But I get it.  It would be cool to see all the pictures tho.

Madonna. 

Tiring and boring.

Stop comparing.

It's not a justice for Madonna.

Her Reinvention tour outgrossed all of Mariahs tour during that decade.

Could she even sell out?

She bargained her tickets for giveaways and cheap sales because her tour was flopping so hard that decade.

There were news reports. 

She's no competition.

So stop it already.

 

 

Edited January 3, 20242 yr by readytowind

The set up is real 

Chile 

 

This actually just highlights how disappointingly sparse Mariah’s output has been since 2010 

Mariah didn't release much. 

 

The 2010s and 2000s are not at all the same. 

 

However, unlike Madonna, Mariah was a H100 staple in the 2010s.

 

Anyway... isn't this what Madonna's decades look like?

 

1983 - 1992 - first

1993 - 2002 - 2nd

2003 - 2012 - 3rd

2013 - 2022 - 4th

2023 - 2032 - 5th

 

 

this set up 

9 minutes ago, stevyy said:

However, unlike Madonna, Mariah was a H100 staple in the 2010s.

How so?

12 minutes ago, stevyy said:

Mariah didn't release much. 

 

The 2010s and 2000s are not at all the same. 

 

However, unlike Madonna, Mariah was a H100 staple in the 2010s.

 

Anyway... isn't this what Madonna's decades look like?

 

1983 - 1992 - first

1993 - 2002 - 2nd

2003 - 2012 - 3rd

2013 - 2022 - 4th

2023 - 2032 - 5th

 

 

I mean, even if we agree on that, Hard Grammy alone is bigger than Mimi’s ‘10s studio albums combined (without accounting for COADF or the other two).

3 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

How so?

Fr, Madonna had American Pie, Music, Don't Tell Me, What if Feels Like For a Girl, Die Another Day, Hung Up, Sorry, and 4 Minutes in her third decade. While Mariah had #Beautiful I guess? 

Just now, Badgalbriel said:

How so?

she charted in every single year.

 

2010: #100 - Up Out My Face

2011: #100 - Oh Santa

2011: #86 - All I want for Christmas is You (Super Festive)

2012: #21 - AIWFCIY

2013: #15 - #Beautiful

2013: #26 - AIWFCIY

2014: #88 - You're Mine Eternal

2014: #35 - AIWFCIY

2015: #82 - Infinity

2015: #11 - AIWFCIY

2016: #16 - AIWFCIY

2017: #89 - I Don't

2017: #9 - AIWFCIY

2018: #3 - AIWFCIY

2019: #1 - AIWFCIY

 

<3