Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
It's a bird! It's a plane! It's...popdemonium!
Fall Emoji Return!
The New Releases 💿
JAEBAES RISE!!!!!!!!! JAE STEPHENS DEBUT ALBUM 'AUDACITY' OUT NOW - LISTEN & DISCUSS NOW

Bigger hits: Selena vs Miley

unclefloprry
in Base

. 73 members have voted

  1. 1. Bigger Hits

    • Selena Gomez
      26%
      19
    • Miley Cyrus
      73%
      54

  2. 2. Better hits

    • Selena Gomez
      30%
      22
    • Miley Cyrus
      69%
      51

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

and your personal choice (of their most streamed songs on Spotify) :giraffe:

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

Extra (not related to their most streamed songs) :giraffe:
11. Naturally- 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

Edited by unclefloprry

  • Replies 37
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Miley has the biggest hit of the two with PITUSA, Selena has more “big hits” throughout her career, both have impeccable hits :clap3: My personal picks:

 

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel
11. Naturally - 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

 

8-5, both slayed

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel
11. Naturally - 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Can't Be Tamed

 

Miley's music is just better :giraffe:

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

Gomez doesn’t even have a hit as big as “The Climb”, and that’s Cyrus’ fourth biggest hit after “PITUSA, WB & WCS”.
 

Miley Cyrus wins, by eons.

 

:rip:

Edited by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

3 minutes ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

Gomez doesn’t even have a hit as big as “The Climb”, and that’s Cyrus’ fourth biggest hit after “PITUSA, WB & WCS”.
 

Miley Cyrus wins, by eons.

 

:rip:

i agree that miley has bigger hits but this is not true at all :skull: 

 

OT: Miley has bigger hits but Selena has more hits WW tbh.

Miley has the peak hits, Selena has the stability hits

 

both are well known along their audience but lemme do this

 

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel (both trash)

11. Naturally- 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter (their peak)
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

 

so many classiqués from both sides, I love stanning successful and talented woman.

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

Miley has bigger hits. She also has better hits overall. Selena's single picks were always a bit questionable personally. Wolves, Back To You and Lose You To Love Me are aging like fine wine though. 

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball :jonny:
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

Extra (not related to their most streamed songs) :giraffe:
11. Naturally- 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

 

 

Sel: 7

Miley: 6

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

Extra (not related to their most streamed songs) 
11. Naturally- 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

 

 

Miley wins!! As easy as Selena dont have a Wrecking Ball or Party In The Usa 

 

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop (TIE)
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

 

Sel: 7

Miley: 4

 

Edited by Seldoja

Miley has the bigger hits


1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel

11. Naturally- 7 Things
12. Fetish - Mothers Daughter
13. Come and Get It - Cant' Be Tamed

 

Both have so many bops tho :clap3:

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Adore You (combined versions :eli:)

 

Miley has bigger and better hits, by far. :heart2:

  • Author
23 minutes ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

Gomez doesn’t even have a hit as big as “The Climb”, and that’s Cyrus’ fourth biggest hit after “PITUSA, WB & WCS”.
 

Miley Cyrus wins, by eons.

 

:rip:

I disagree, The Climb is local. Even Love You Like a Love Song feels bigger than that song :biblio:

Miley has the bigger and much better hits.

 

Midnight Sky alone feels bigger than any solo Selena song sans LYTLM

1. We Don't Talk Anymore - Party in the USA
2. It Ain't Me - We Can't Stop
3. Wolves - Nothing Breaks Like a Heart
4. Lose You To Love Me - Malibu
5. Back To You - Wrecking Ball
6. Good For You - Prisoner
7. Hands To Myself - Midnight Sky
8. Love You Like a Love Song - The Climb
9. Same Old Love - When I Look At You
10. Kill 'Em With Kindness - Don’t Call Me Angel (neither)

 

Miley’s music is better, more full of substance, and talent-driven. All of her songs are bigger and more memorable, too.

Is this a joke… ? Miley has at least 5-6 songs that are bigger than Selena’s biggest song (I’m talking about her own music not the songs on which she is featured)

23 minutes ago, unclefloprry said:

I disagree, The Climb is local. Even Love You Like a Love Song feels bigger than that song :biblio:

Feels bigger? The Climb sold more than the double of that other one, please. :toofunny3:

 

LYLALS is a bop, though!

What is this site’s obsession with overestimating Selena Gomez’s success

If we exclude the US, I'd argue Calm Down is bigger than any Miley hit but overall, Wrecking Ball and Party in the USA were mega hits while Selenas were cute 

Miley for both. I mean PITUSA is diamond and she has others that are closing in too. 

 

  • Author
35 minutes ago, Blue Monday said:

What is this site’s obsession with overestimating Selena Gomez’s success

She's a hitmaker :cm:

Go to topic listing

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications
Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.