- Huge signature hits/ classics. ( bigger hits than lady gaga who’s supposed to be a living legend according to some Atrlers)

- Huge cultural / Iconic pop moments

- Ageless discography.

 

IMO she is discuss and keep it cute.

 

Icon? Yes.

 

Legend? No, and never will be.

Edited December 6, 20223 yr by ATWK

$25M yearly Idol paycheque with a 10+ year album that makes year-end Billboard 200 for 2022?

 

I think so

Every legend has at least one critically acclaimed album to their credit so no.

The pettiness of this thread 

 

My Stanning TRINITY : Rihanna, Britney and Lady gaga

 

1 minute ago, Klein said:

The pettiness of this thread 

 

My Stanning TRINITY : Rihanna, Britney and Lady gaga

 

LOL! Stanning Gaga doesn’t mean i can’t claim someone else is a legend.

No. 

the set up

Absolutely not

What else?
U dont really think big hits and iconic moments are a sign that u are a Legend, right?

 

influences?

tributes?

still talking about your decade-old projects? (and no, I dont mean only streaming)

 

 

+it's kind of early to give her a status of legend

it was a bit early for MJ and Madonna, yet they are the biggest ones

other huge artists had talks about if they are legends..but Katy? she is successful..but Britney,Beyonce,Gaga were bashed when the topic came up

imagine what will happen with K

if Taylor and Rihanna are the more Katy is, more famous hits, image etc

The legend lane like Paula Abdul

 

Not a legend lane like Madonna

Not everyone with 2 consecutive hit albums in a 3 year span is a legend. 

Edited December 6, 20223 yr by vale9001

not at all 

 

her career is literally just hit songs from 2008-2014 

Be serious

An icon - yes. A legend...no. 

A fad maybe

She tainted her legacy with performing next to a sh.t. Mind you, I saw it live

Yes

No. But she is an icon like her peer Gaga.

No.

Teenage Dream (song) alone will make her a legend!

She's as legendary as Paula Abdul.

32 minutes ago, popjunkie said:

No. But she is an icon like her peer Gaga.