The result. Thought this place was full of Swift fans 

 

12 minutes ago, Shelter said:

The result. Thought this place was full of Swift fans 

 

They probably aren't tagging their entire base in their fanbase thread like a certain stanbase on here

3 hours ago, Allday said:

Honestly both the same level for me. I use 4 tracks on each album.  Both a mid 6/10

Both are overrated by their fans. I voted Midnight

16 minutes ago, Armani? said:

They probably aren't tagging their entire base in their fanbase thread like a certain stanbase on here

And still lost 

 

Midnights was a reverse Renaissance experience tbh

 

I loved Ren for a few days and I've literally not listened to it since. It grew OFF of me so hard, but the opposite happened with midnights. Hated the album at first but it's grown on me a lot even if I don't think it's anywhere near her best work

Ren sweetie

Renaissance by extremely far.

Midnights is all hype and mediocre in comparison

The landslide faith in humanity restored

 

Midnights, and it isn’t even remotely close. 

Both are amazing albums from two LEGENDS

My ratings for Renaissance was around 9.5 and for Midnights it was around 8.5 so I'd vote for Ren. 

It's way too soon to tell. Right now, Renaissance. Midnights is excellent. It's just a question of if it will endure.

I enjoy Midnights more

I like both albums, but found them both disappointing in comparison to folklore, evermore, Self Titled and Lemonade, which were all extremely excellent.

 

I prefer MIDnights right now, but that could change

 

Renaissance no contest.

 

Virgo's Groove alone is better than anything Taylor swift is likely to come out with in this lifetime. 

Renaissance deserves its 90s score, Midnights…. Um ? 

Both are great Albums from legendary musicians. 

Renaissance by far

Obviously Renaissance  It's a masterpiece while Midnights is mediocre even by Taylor's standards 

Please

 

 

Renaissance.

37 minutes ago, Triton said:

Renaissance deserves its 90s score, Midnights…. Um ? 

Midnights doesn't have the 90 or above metacritic score.

Edited October 24, 20223 yr by Jude

1 minute ago, Jude said:

Midnights doesn't have the 90 or above metacritic score.

I know, should have clarified…the latter doesn’t deserve its current score, especially it being high 80s 

Please, Renaissance is def miles and miles better. What is this thread. 

I have to very strongly vote for Renaissance here. I believe it's truly Bey's best album. For me, Folklore is Taylor's best. She hit the nail on the head with that one. 

1 hour ago, Bimbo said:

Please

 

 

Renaissance.

Jfjcjgjv

 

But yea Ren. Easily.