Replay alone >>>>>>

The one that has the actual Babylon and not 16 of its wannabes

Why am i not surprised it's a bored Britney stan opening this thread and gaslighting the Hive VS Monsters  dumb feud?

Yall will never humble Beyonce Giselle Knowles Carter.  The lead of one of the most successful girl groups of all time.  Billboards female artist of the 00s.  She has had massive commercial, critical and touring success.  Future HOFer.  This is just the victory lap of her career.  Its so funny bc yall be so serious and this is Bey just in her art bag, enjoying the spoils of her hard work.

43 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Which both are ****. 

 

Break My Soul alone DEVOURS that crap of an album. 

 Nah, came on sis. I really liked the album but BMS is pure sh*t. 

6 minutes ago, Mystic Boy said:

Why am i not surprised it's a bored Britney stan opening this thread and gaslighting the Hive VS Monsters  dumb feud?

The tantrum over an internet poll

14 minutes ago, Blumoon said:

This is where yall are hurt.  Wanting to humble Bey and her fans.  Release the anger!

Beyonce IS a very humble person, though

2 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

Beyonce IS a very humble person, though

She is, which is why the obsession w “humbling” her is stupid.  What they really mean is they want to see her fail.

Edited July 28, 20224 yr by Blumoon

Chromatica

 

I don't remember a single chorus/sound from Renaissance after first listen, Maybe something will stick after multiple listens. 

 

53 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Which both are ****. 

 

Break My Soul alone DEVOURS that crap of an album. 

Release the angerrrr!!!

10 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

 Nah, came on sis. I really liked the album but BMS is pure sh*t. 

I disagree.

 

It was instant love for me, and this comes from someone who doesn't blindly stan anything that she puts out. 

They're very different albums that occasionally touch similar sounds/themes, but include a lot of what makes each artist unique. 

 

I prefer Renaissance because I'm a Beyoncé fan and it also has r&b/disco elements which I love. I also think RENAISSANCE was more out of bey's comfort zone and ambitious sonically, whereas chromatica was more in gaga's wheelhouse and a return to sounds she's explored before

Edited July 28, 20224 yr by PrettyHurts

Chromatica, sweetie...  

I haven't heard Renaissance yet but I stan both Gaga and Bey so I'm not gonna participate in the poll. Chromatica has aged well though imo I think I like it more now than on release. 

Renaissance for me. Virgo's Groove alone >>>

Bey by far lol. 

The other album isn't out yet. 

After the first listen: Chromatica, more catchy and memorable hooks 

 

idk Bey’s album might grow on me but so far I only use BMS, I think I’m not getting the album or whatever it’s just not clicking 

 

Both are very different album you dumb fuks

I haven’t even listened to renaissance yet but I know it wins by a landslide 

1 hour ago, Hivy said:

The one thats not pots and pans aka Renaissance. 

 

Rain On Me os great though ( TY Ariana)

you've clearly not listened to either fully   Renaissance is more complex in it's production and leans to 'pots and pans' at time

not a big fan of either but i prefer chromatica 

I’ve only listened to three tracks on Renaissance so far and already >>>>

I'm not a stan of neither of them but I appreciate their work equally and I'm always checking out what they put out because they're amazing artists.

 

That being said, I think Chromatica is too safe. It's not a bad album but it doesn't go as far as it should, maybe if Gaga kept some of the original concepts with the SOPHIE productions the album would be more interesting. Dawn of Chromatica is better in my opinion because it does go to that experimental route and takes those safe melodies and twist them to something beyond. 

 

Renaissance is better overall because is a more fully realised project. You can tell there are inspirations there from the late 70's and 80's and the production doesn't just pay homage to them but also plays with them and experiments with the sound, creating something very fresh and bold and STILL keeping the Beyoncé signature. It's hard for an artist to take inspiration from others, experiment and still mantain your own style, and I think Bey did that. 

 

So, in my opinion: Renaissance > Dawn of Chromatica > Chromatica

 

The albums have a similar source of inspiration but couldn’t be more different… and both are great albums on their own. I know this thread will be filled of stan wars but thankfully I’m able to appreciate both.

 

Gaga and Bey are such talented ladies and we are lucky to witness their releases.