13 minutes ago, Aden said:

Between Shallow's Oscar win, #1 peak, 2 billion+streams, being Gaga's second-highest Hot 100 hit, 1 billion+ viewed music video, performance that will eventually hit 1 billion views, near-Diamond status, cultural impact, and general longevity that has it still charting 5 years after... is it safe to call it her biggest hit? 

 

Nostalgia would have us still say Poker Face or Bad Romance, but what do we think? 

 

Shallow's absolutely a classic. It has the potential to overcome PF/BR long-term given how ageless it is by design and how perfect it is for easy listening. 

 

When talking about Gaga's legacy and contribution to culture though, it's absolutely Bad Romance. It's one of the most definitive pop hits of all-time. BR will forever be her most impactful song and signature hit. 

 

13 minutes ago, JohnWayneHolland said:

It's definitely a classic and one of her biggest hits, but it still has to surpass Bad Romance and Poker Face in total units for it to be her biggest hit, PF has 13M units and BR almost 12M units.

 

 

Uhhh pretty sure BR and PF has surpassed 15M or more tbh. 

i'm just glad that her biggest hits aren't all from the first two years of her career

 

3 minutes ago, Phoenixstar said:

Uhhh pretty sure BR and PF has surpassed 15M or more tbh. 

This is just in the US, WW they definitely have way more units

 

 

47 minutes ago, Ratviolo said:

GagaDaily has consistently been doing such an amazing job over the past few years

what does Kirill have against you

34 minutes ago, JohnWayneHolland said:

It's definitely a classic and one of her biggest hits, but it still has to surpass Bad Romance and Poker Face in total units for it to be her biggest hit, PF has 13M units and BR almost 12M units.

 

 

I fear Shallord will surpass them given its recurrent streams.

 

42 minutes ago, Aden said:

Between Shallow's Oscar win, #1 peak, 2 billion+streams, being Gaga's second-highest Hot 100 hit, 1 billion+ viewed music video, performance that will eventually hit 1 billion views, near-Diamond status, cultural impact, and general longevity that has it still charting 5 years after... is it safe to call it her biggest hit? 

 

Nostalgia would have us still say Poker Face or Bad Romance, but what do we think? 

 

It's part of the Big 4, it'll soon be diamond eligible.

 

But Bad Romance will forever be her signature song. The song, the video, the impact, the vibes. 

 

 

20 minutes ago, JohnWayneHolland said:

This is just in the US, WW they definitely have way more units

 

 

Oops didn’t know we were talking about US. Sounds about right tbh

6 minutes ago, Aden said:

I fear Shallord will surpass them given its recurrent streams.

 

When Shallah becomes the first female song to get the 2x Diamond certification

 

 

4 minutes ago, Phoenixstar said:

Oops didn’t know we were talking about US. Sounds about right tbh

Yeah, she'll soon have 4 Diamond singles in the US with Shallah and Just Dance, legend

 

Biggest Classic: Bad Romance

Biggest GeePee Hit: Shallow

Biggest DarkBawp Hit: Bloody Mary

 

I'm kinda rooting for Gar doing some fighting sequences or chasing scenes in JFAD.

 

Act. Sing. Stunt. Triple threat.  

1 hour ago, sunbathinganimal said:

how is Bloody Mary of all things a bigger radio hit than an Ariana Grande collab

I don't think it will reach 75m AI like Rain On Me tho. 

 

 

Oh 

#Leave 

1 hour ago, Aden said:

Between Shallow's Oscar win, #1 peak, 2 billion+streams, being Gaga's second-highest Hot 100 hit, 1 billion+ viewed music video, performance that will eventually hit 1 billion views, near-Diamond status, cultural impact, and general longevity that has it still charting 5 years after... is it safe to call it her biggest hit? 

 

Nostalgia would have us still say Poker Face or Bad Romance, but what do we think? 

 

Poker Face and Bad Romance are definitely bigger. Bad Romance was literally the most viewed video on YouTube for a minute there, and is the most certified single ever I think. 

1 hour ago, Miracle said:

I think I would rule it out for now. I think Gaga wants to get involved in artsier movies (although she was gonna be on Birds of Prey but that was basically a long cameo). Even Cate Blanchett is doing MCU now, but Gaga is still nowhere in that level of I don't give a **** what role I have I just want the money and I have 2 acting Oscars that Oscar Blanchett has.

 

Especially since Gaga would make the same with a 3 movie MCU deal than with just 20 dates of performing. Makes no sense for her career rn

Gaga is in such a great/unique spot right now in her career.

By having two sources of revenue (three if you count Haus Labs). She can do whatever project she wants. She doesn’t have to worry about doing side projects to pay bills. 
 

1 hour ago, sunbathinganimal said:

GaGa was incredible in HOG but kinda bad in ASIB

Her singing and chemistry with Bradley really make the performance. But yes, I would agree that she is better in HOG 

 

HOG > ASIB > AHS: Hotel
 

 

16 minutes ago, Aden said:

Biggest Classic: Bad Romance

Biggest GeePee Hit: Shallow

Biggest DarkBawp Hit: Bloody Mary

 

New Year’s Classic: Just Dance

Valentine’s Day Classic: ARUTW

Halloween Classic: Bloody Mary

Classic Classic: Bad Romance

Soundtrack Classic: Shallow

00’s Classic: Poker Face 

 

14 minutes ago, xo_hours said:

The #Leave is SENDING ME

21 minutes ago, xo_hours said:

Yeah. We were wondering about it the other day. Thanks for the answer.  

 

The beak

3 minutes ago, Aden said:

 

The beak

THE WAY I SCREAMED WITH YOUR BEAK COMMENT

 

I- 

4 hours ago, JohnWayneHolland said:

 

 

 

so after spending MONTHS claiming BM will never be a radio hit and how radio is about to drop it any minute, that member  is now claiming in the Airplay thread that Interscope payola'd it

1 hour ago, Sombre said:

what does Kirill have against you

Smfjskfjd stop