Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
Fall Emoji Return!

Lady Gaga

This is part 1 of the Lady Gaga discussion.

Featured Replies

4 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

If Gaga’s acting is undeniable, she can win BA even with 2 BOS wins. 
Look at Frances McDormand. She is a 4 time Academy Award winner and won 3 of them between 2018-2021.


The BOS category has evolved. If today’s standards were used in the past, Madonna would be a two time BOS winner for You Must Love Me (1996) and Sooner or Later (1990). Woman were never properly credited as song writers back then. Now in 2022, artists like Beyoncé get nominated as a song writer and in 2015 Gaga got nominated with only 10% writing credits. 
 

Hold My Hand is an undeniable front runner for BOS. Based on three factors. 1. Lack of meaningful competition. 2. The academy loves to award giant ballads 3. The song is attached to a hugely successful movie that will have multiple nominations at the ceremony. 
She could definitely lose to a niche song from a Best Picture nominated movie. Like how How Far Will I Go and Can’t Stop the Feeling lost to City of Stars. But as of right now, Hold My Hand is the song to beat. We still have 6 months to go and most Best Picture nominated movies will come out in the Fall and Winter 

Frances McDormand is between the rarities I mentioned before, she's a veteran actress, deeply respected by her peers, probably the most respected actress right now, even more than Streep and she has 40 years of honorable career in that field, you can't really make a comparison with Gaga.

 

 

  • Replies 457.3k
  • Views 18.6m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Topics in this Discussion

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

FYI: The final round of BOS is a pure favourite vote. You only check one box in the ballot. So we should use a different “stats” from the complex ass ranking scores in acting categories. :giraffe:
 

 

.

Edited by Canonical Ensembl

16 minutes ago, Konril said:

Ugh... this Oscar talk... I hope EEAAO snatches.

 

If Gar gets nominated, good... If she gets snub, not a total loss.

Now that you mention it, EEAAO song also slé. Gar should be shook. :siptea:
 

 

Quote

 

There are different voting branches for each category at the Academy Awards, where members vote in their own fields.

For example, the Actors branch votes to nominate in all four acting awards, the directors vote for Best Director nominees, and so on. How many votes you need to secure a nomination depends on the size of the voting branch.

According to The Wrap, the only category in which you need more than 100 votes to secure a nomination are Best Picture and the four acting categories, which are voted for by the largest number of people. Everyone has a say on Best Picture.

This collegiate voting partially explains the discrepancies that often happen between categories, for example when a Best Film nominee doesn't get a Best Director nod, or vice versa.

 

So basically what this means is that it's much easier for Gaga to get a Best Original Song nomination than a Best Actress nomination because she's much closer to the type of people who vote for Best Original Song. Where Gaga has the advantage when it comes to BOS is when the voting for the actual award comes in. Since everyone can vote for the winner, unlike voting for the nominees, popular artists like Gaga have the upper-hand since non-musical voters will most likely vote for either the only name they know or the biggest song in contention (see James Bond themes always winning).

 

Using BOS win(s) to discredit her chances at BA doesn't make sense since different branches vote for those awards. 

Edited by Bang Up

Pop back to stanning again, we love to see it.

 

ufyo2o9.gif

 

1 hour ago, Canonical Ensembl said:

Rooting for a rebound on weekdays. :dancehall:

If it continues to follow the past trend, it should rise back up on Monday and maybe even touch the 1.2M mark again. Sunday is also the lowest streams day of the week anyway.

 

ufyo2o9.gif

16 minutes ago, Katniss said:

Nah different situation i think, she only needs the movie to be good (Best picture nominated at least) and she'll have a shot imo.

Arrival is good, Little Woman is good and even Nightmare Alley was kinda bearable but they all got snubbed in acting category (especially Amy Adams for Arrival). To get a nomination even a win requires good narrative, goodwill among acting branch and most importantly effective campaign strategy (HoG suffered from poor/ messy campaigns while Eyes of Tammy Faye benefits from those Academy Museum screenings and FYC parties).

What I am trying to say is, we should lower our expectation on J:FAD as it could be easily snubbed by academy.

7 minutes ago, paperfectdelusion said:

Arrival is good, Little Woman is good and even Nightmare Alley was kinda bearable but they all got snubbed in acting category (especially Amy Adams for Arrival). To get a nomination even a win requires good narrative, goodwill among acting branch and most importantly effective campaign strategy (HoG suffered from poor/ messy campaigns while Eyes of Tammy Faye benefits from those Academy Museum screenings and FYC parties).

What I am trying to say is, we should lower our expectation on J:FAD as it could be easily snubbed by academy.

I meant that the movie has to be a Best picture nominee, for Gaga to have a shot.

2 minutes ago, Katniss said:

I meant that the movie has to be a Best picture nominee, for Gaga to have a shot.

Arrival was nominated for every possible Oscar except for best actress so yeah things like that can happen so be prepared!

 

As for Best Original Song idk, like she already nominated twice and got one it kinda makes no sense to campaign for another one? Unless she wants to show off in front diane warren, which I approve!:WAP:

9 minutes ago, paperfectdelusion said:

 

What I am trying to say is, we should lower our expectation on J:FAD as it could be easily snubbed by academy.

This point was brought up last year, but women rarely win Best Actress for controversial villain roles. If she has amazing chemistry with Joaquin and the movie is nominated for best picture, she can maybe get nominated. 

Gaga would have a better chance winning BA with a remake of Cabaret. 

46 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

Hold My Hand is an undeniable front runner for BOS. Based on three factors. 1. Lack of meaningful competition. 2. The academy loves to award giant ballads 3. The song is attached to a hugely successful movie that will have multiple nominations at the ceremony. 
She could definitely lose to a niche song from a Best Picture nominated movie. Like how How Far Will I Go and Can’t Stop the Feeling lost to City of Stars. But as of right now, Hold My Hand is the song to beat. We still have 6 months to go and most Best Picture nominated movies will come out in the Fall and Winter 

La La Land was undeniable that year, the only way it’d have lost is vote splitting (Audition was also nominated), if Top Gun manages to squeeze in a BP nom, i fear BOS is hers to lose. Also the ballot only displays the song & movie title, not the songwriters, which gives the most popular acclaimed movie in the category the best advantage (i reckon its one of the reasons TIHTY lost & Diane Warren still hasn’t won yet)

3 minutes ago, paperfectdelusion said:

Arrival was nominated for every possible Oscar except for best actress so yeah things like that can happen so be prepared!

 

As for Best Original Song idk, like she already nominated twice and got one it kinda makes no sense to campaign for another one? Unless she wants to show off in front diane warren, which I approve!:WAP:

Arrival best movie ever btw omg 

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

7 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

This point was brought up last year, but women rarely win Best Actress for controversial villain roles. If she has amazing chemistry with Joaquin and the movie is nominated for best picture, she can maybe get nominated. 

Gaga would have a better chance winning BA with a remake of Cabaret. 

Yeah she should keep getting enrolled in good projects and bring box office smash (her selling point compared other BA candidates) and building good will inside academy, I'm sure she will get it in two or three more try.

7 minutes ago, WildAmerican said:

Arrival best movie ever btw omg 

It is very good I never understand why they snubbed her that year, the way some Academy members are NOT seeing heaven!:angelo:

5 hours ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

GettyImages-176918306-aeb934697c0a4498aa034.jpg

image.png

 

 

 

Kinda want her to bring this KarenGa serve back briefly for a single cycle at least, if not an entire era.

 

YZzWPef.gif

That iconic soccer mom wig suits her facial features so much. I’d love to see it again especially with this dirty blonde/light brown shade. 

3 hours ago, Papa said:

 

ufyo2o9.gif

One of her best fame era looks simply because she wasn’t overly tan like other times in that era. 

Could you pull me out of this alive?

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

 

Where's my body? I'm stuck in my mind

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

HMH entered Top 50 HK (101k) for the first time :clap:

 

It's now in 4 (+1) Top 50 playlists after Taiwan (#6), Singapore(#31) and New Zealand (#45)

 

Bubbling Under

57. Switzerland (118k)

58. Belgium (263k)

59. Malaysia (197k)

 

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

1 minute ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

HMH entered Top 50 HK (101k) for the first time :clap:

 

It's now in 4 (+1) Top 50 playlists after Taiwan (#6), Singapore(#31) and New Zealand (#45)

 

Bubbling Under

57. Switzerland (118k)

58. Belgium (263k)

59. Malaysia (197k)

 

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

It was bumped out by Drake bomb in Switzerland though. :rip: 

 

But now it’s raining Drake so

 

tinashe-all-hands-on-deck.gif

Just now, Canonical Ensembl said:

It was bumped out by Drake

We need Godga to jump on the Massive remix

 

@Universo @State of Grace.

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

8 minutes ago, The Witch said:

We need Godga to jump on the Massive remix

 

@Universo @State of Grace.

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

Not that tank album...Why are you being an OGH now?

 

El Apagon remix or keep it

 

ezgif-6-5ed2a6b2c1.png

10 minutes ago, The Witch said:

We need Godga to jump on the Massive remix

 

@Universo @State of Grace.

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

I just know Massive and Overdrive were stolen from Chromatica. We need Interscope to open an investigation on Bloodpop over demo smuggling. 
 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

Just now, State of Grace. said:

Not that tank album...Why are you being an OGH now?

 

El Apagon remix or keep it

 

ezgif-6-5ed2a6b2c1.png

Ga Ga is latinophobic

 

She only does collabs with USA fads!

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

Just now, Canonical Ensembl said:

I just know Massive and Overdrive were stolen from Chromatica. We need Interscope to open an investigation on Bloodpop over demo smuggling. 
 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

Bloodpoop wishes he could serve House excellence

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

1 hour ago, Vroom Vroom said:

This point was brought up last year, but women rarely win Best Actress for controversial villain roles. If she has amazing chemistry with Joaquin and the movie is nominated for best picture, she can maybe get nominated. 

Gaga would have a better chance winning BA with a remake of Cabaret. 

I think this too! Gaga is simply undeniable when music and acting is involved. I know people don't want her to "pigeonhole" herself into a specific type of role, but I don't see why that's a bad thing. So many actresses stick to what they're good at and just do that over and over again. It's smart. Joker: The ReUp can serve as continued proof she's a versatile actress and then Cabaret can be her pièce de résistance.

 

6 hours ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

GettyImages-176918306-aeb934697c0a4498aa034.jpg

image.png

 

 

 

Kinda want her to bring this KarenGa serve back briefly for a single cycle at least, if not an entire era.

 

YZzWPef.gif

Do y'all remember that 5-day span in 2013 when she banged out look after look after look? They were all pretty "tame" looks but had a feeling of sophistication and elegance? So good. 

 

3d564c57d61892bab17259732a4496db.jpg

 

04315396493cfaba9d57b39e518c9026.jpg

 

180373d2873013eca7e01b.jpg

 

11 minutes ago, The Witch said:

Ga Ga is latinophobic

 

She only does collabs with USA fads!

 

504zfn.thumb.gif.a43ee4ce14e420f8b9c1ff5

Chromatica's production was better than Flake's album

 

ezgif-6-5ed2a6b2c1.png

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.