She only has 1.

Can Christina get a hit?

9 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

She only has 1.

dont set xtina up ...

6 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

She only has 1.

She has 4 or even 5.

Charting on national charts in several countries:
AIWFCIY
C(BPCH)
Oh Santa Remix
O Holy Night
Santa Claus Is Coming To Town

Right now, she has 3 Xmas songs in the Holiday 100 in the USA: AIWFCIY, CBPCH and Oh Santa Remix

In 2024: CBPCH charted in 9 countries, OHN (in 1, France), OSR in 2.
In 2023: CBPCH (in 8), OHN in 2, FILAC in 1, OSR in 2
In 2022: CBPCH (in 5), OSR in 4, OHN in 2, Santa Claus in 1, Silent Night in 1.
...

As you can see.. several of her tracks chart in individual territories. CBPCH in particular is by far her 2nd most successful Christmas song... unfortunately, it also has to crack the US Top 50 to chart. It would normally rank inside the Hot 100 Top 75 each season... but it can't bc it is from 1994 and even tho it never entered the Hot 100, it has to chart inside the top 50.

Yesterday, the song was #57 on US Spotify and #50 in the world.

Mariah has also amassed over 467 million holiday streams this year so far (and Xmas Day is still coming out tomorrow). The music is in high demand every single season. In 2024 she did 560 million Holiday streams on the platform. I would project sth like 515-525 million for 2025.

Edited December 26, 2025Dec 26 by stevyy

Your tone is as pointed as the northern most star leading those shepherd sisters to Jesus' manager

With a Legend X Collab, maybe

maybe a collab with another artist.

Oh Santa is a hit.

The house is made of glass

5 minutes ago, spree said:

Oh Santa is a hit.

Clock THAT tea!

That would be detrimental to her legacy, considering even now she's already known as "the Christmas lady" by the younger generations, and a big part of her discography didn't transition that well into the streaming era or is just plain forgotten.

Yes, all she has to do is make the November 1st video transition into a new song instead of AIWFCIY, which would of course go viral and possibly stick.

She has 6 (5 and a remix) songs pulling 1m+ streams, to put some things in perspective:

All I Want for Christmas Is You 23,401,518

Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) 4,236,778

Christina Aguilera's entire discography 4,204,156

All I Want For Christmas Is You (SuperFestive!) 1,975,867

Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town 1,616,821

Oh Santa! (feat. Ariana Grande & Jennifer Hudson) 1,390,590

O Holy Night 1,330,447

Oh Santa! 732,382

My Kind of Christmas (Album, by Christina) 616,275

Silent Night 580,019

This Christmas (by Christina) 318,586

Gurl, just say you're a lamb with this level of obsession, it's not that hard.

Mariah's last non Xmas "hit" was Obsessed. Xtina's last one was in 2006. lol

10 minutes ago, Elusive Chanteuse said:

Mariah's last non Xmas "hit" was Obsessed. Xtina's last one was in 2006. lol

#Beautiful definitely was a hit

20 minutes ago, Night Howler said:

That would be detrimental to her legacy, considering even now she's already known as "the Christmas lady" by the younger generations, and a big part of her discography didn't transition that well into the streaming era or is just plain forgotten.

nearing 2,1 billion streams of her entire catalogue with 490m coming from Xmas music in 2025.

Christmas EVE: pre 1996 girls on Spotify (and some extras)

42,35m - Mariah Carey (#8 overall)
24,65m - Brenda Lee
14,72m - Ella Fitzgerald
13,89m - Shakira
13,04m - Darlene Love
12,03m - Britney Spears
7,52m - Gwen Stefani
7,13m - Céline Dion
4,99m - Madonna
4,95m - Alicia Keys
4,85m - Sade
4,55m - Whitney Houston
4,53m - Kylie Minogue
4,20m - Christina Aguilera
3,82m - P!nk
3,71m - Nelly Furtado
3,58m - Dolly Parton
3,32m - Cher
3,05m - Enya
2,91m - Eartha Kitt
2,89m - Shania Twain
2,47m - Kate Bush
2,47m - Cyndi Lauper
2,06m - Mary J. Blige
1,96m - Lauren Hill
1,61m - Ashanti
1,57m - Tracy Chapman
1,52m - Diana Ross
1,42m - Annie Lennox

--
1,41m - Faith Hill
1,31m - Ciara
1,30m - Björk
1,18m - Aretha Franklin
1,13m - Bonnie Tyler
0,96m - Alanis Morissette
0,92m - Brandy
0,92m - Erykah Badu
0,91m - Toni Braxton
0,82m - Sarah McLachlan
0,73m - Janet Jackson
0,70m - Celia Cruz
0,68m - Lil' Kim
0,66m - Sheryl Crow
0,66m - Laura Branigan
0,64m - Joni Mitchell
0,59m - Donna Summer
0,54m - Gloria Gaynor
0,53m - Chaka Khan
0,51m - Dusty Springfield
0,51m - Fiona Apple
0,48m - Leann Rimes
0,48m - Monica
0,46m - Reba Mcentire
0,44m - Irene Cara
0,42m - Sinead O Connor
0,39m - Roberta Flack
0,36m - Carole King
0,35m - Belinda Carlile
0,34m - Linda Ronstadt
0,32m - Gladys Knight
0,24m - Jewel
0,22m - Bonnie Raitt
0,20m - Kim Wilde
0,18m - Taylor Dayne
0,18m - Anita Baker
0,15m - Tori Amos
0,12m - Patti Labelle
0,11m - Paula Abdul

and so on. The real question is who did transition well into the streaming age from the pre internet girls?

15 minutes ago, Elusive Chanteuse said:

Mariah's last non Xmas "hit" was Obsessed. Xtina's last one was in 2006. lol

I would even extend that to the 2xP selling #Beautiful.

I also want to emphasis that in flopping hard, the HFIA era brought forward 2 Adult R&B Airplay #1's. Still charting on R&B sub-charts is def. also an achievement within itself. Mariah even had 2 R&B Song entries in 2025 with Type Dangerous and In Your Feelings.

Sure, the HFIA era - as I was saying, flopped into oblivion... but several magazines rank it as one of the best albums / R&B albums of 2025. I am so proud of MIMI.

"Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)" deserves

Don't she have like have 4 already (DFAU 2006, OSD 1995, Hero 1993)?

Also her version of "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" is chef's f*cking KISS

20 minutes ago, stevyy said:

The real question is who did transition well into the streaming age from the pre internet girls?

Besides Shakira and Beyonce, almost nobody did. But at least legends like Whitney and Celine didnt get their legacies tarnished to become "the xmas lady".

1 hour ago, stevyy said:

3nearing 2,1 billion streams of her entire catalogue with 490m coming from Xmas music in 2025.

Christmas EVE: pre 1996 girls on Spotify (and some extras)

42,35m - Mariah Carey (#8 overall)
24,65m - Brenda Lee
14,72m - Ella Fitzgerald
13,89m - Shakira
13,04m - Darlene Love
12,03m - Britney Spears
7,52m - Gwen Stefani
7,13m - Céline Dion
4,99m - Madonna
4,95m - Alicia Keys
4,85m - Sade
4,55m - Whitney Houston
4,53m - Kylie Minogue
4,20m - Christina Aguilera
3,82m - P!nk
3,71m - Nelly Furtado
3,58m - Dolly Parton
3,32m - Cher
3,05m - Enya
2,91m - Eartha Kitt
2,89m - Shania Twain
2,47m - Kate Bush
2,47m - Cyndi Lauper
2,06m - Mary J. Blige
1,96m - Lauren Hill
1,61m - Ashanti
1,57m - Tracy Chapman
1,52m - Diana Ross
1,42m - Annie Lennox

--
1,41m - Faith Hill
1,31m - Ciara
1,30m - Björk
1,18m - Aretha Franklin
1,13m - Bonnie Tyler
0,96m - Alanis Morissette
0,92m - Brandy
0,92m - Erykah Badu
0,91m - Toni Braxton
0,82m - Sarah McLachlan
0,73m - Janet Jackson
0,70m - Celia Cruz
0,68m - Lil' Kim
0,66m - Sheryl Crow
0,66m - Laura Branigan
0,64m - Joni Mitchell
0,59m - Donna Summer
0,54m - Gloria Gaynor
0,53m - Chaka Khan
0,51m - Dusty Springfield
0,51m - Fiona Apple
0,48m - Leann Rimes
0,48m - Monica
0,46m - Reba Mcentire
0,44m - Irene Cara
0,42m - Sinead O Connor
0,39m - Roberta Flack
0,36m - Carole King
0,35m - Belinda Carlile
0,34m - Linda Ronstadt
0,32m - Gladys Knight
0,24m - Jewel
0,22m - Bonnie Raitt
0,20m - Kim Wilde
0,18m - Taylor Dayne
0,18m - Anita Baker
0,15m - Tori Amos
0,12m - Patti Labelle
0,11m - Paula Abdul

and so on. The real question is who did transition well into the streaming age from the pre internet girls?

The way Kelly is #2 with 29.36 million streams and was left out, yet a lot of these girls debuted around the same time as her, I-

8 hours ago, stevyy said:

She has 4 or even 5.

Charting on national charts in several countries:
AIWFCIY
C(BPCH)
Oh Santa Remix
O Holy Night
Santa Claus Is Coming To Town

Right now, she has 3 Xmas songs in the Holiday 100 in the USA: AIWFCIY, CBPCH and Oh Santa Remix

In 2024: CBPCH charted in 9 countries, OHN (in 1, France), OSR in 2.
In 2023: CBPCH (in 8), OHN in 2, FILAC in 1, OSR in 2
In 2022: CBPCH (in 5), OSR in 4, OHN in 2, Santa Claus in 1, Silent Night in 1.
...

As you can see.. several of her tracks chart in individual territories. CBPCH in particular is by far her 2nd most successful Christmas song... unfortunately, it also has to crack the US Top 50 to chart. It would normally rank inside the Hot 100 Top 75 each season... but it can't bc it is from 1994 and even tho it never entered the Hot 100, it has to chart inside the top 50.

Yesterday, the song was #57 on US Spotify and #50 in the world.

Mariah has also amassed over 467 million holiday streams this year so far (and Xmas Day is still coming out tomorrow). The music is in high demand every single season. In 2024 she did 560 million Holiday streams on the platform. I would project sth like 515-525 million for 2025.

What is CBPCH