Which two power ballads are stronger?

 

  

Mariah sweep! 

 

i love gaga but those songs are trash, mariah wins by a landslide

Arutw>Shallow=Without you >nFU

Without You ALONE and the fact that it's a COVER... 

 

 

Shallow was a moment tho so it was kinda close cause I don't really care for My All when it comes to Mimi's ballads but still...

Mariah, sweetie. Those classics 

When I saw you + without you outsold every combo here 

My All alone clears any Gaga ballad, no shade. 

I love gaga and those ballads, but I grew up with those mariah classics so >>>

Always Remember Us This Way being an option makes it automatically the winner

 

Although I love the Mariah songs too. This American Idol audition of "Without You" still makes me howl

 

 

ARUTW>Without You>Shallow>My All

 

Overall, all amazing songs but I prefer Gaga's two. Without You is a masterpiece too though

Shallow conquered the globe. Anyone who knows those Mariah songs definitely knows Shallow too. it's difficult to answer since Mariah's hits have faded a bit with time and Gaga's could too, but i think Shallow is the biggest song here. Mariah for quality.

Mariah has the better songs, but Gaga's were bigger together.

ASIB songs were obviously bigger

Miss Keri baby for all 3

 

3 hours ago, Rocket said:

Mariah has the better songs, but Gaga's were bigger together.

incomparable... bc of how far removed they are from one another. 

 

I believe Without You would be at 2-3 billion streams if it showed the same commercial appeal in the streaming age as it did in the physical age. WY was like the 2nd or 3rd best selling song of 1994 in Europe. (and due to singles being singles, u know promoting albums, made Music Box the top selling album of the continent in 1994). It sold like 800k in 1993, 6,5 million in 1994 and the remaining 800k between 1995-today. 

3 hours ago, Démodé said:

ASIB songs were obviously bigger

My All's physical sales alone generated as much revenue as a song with 3,1 billion streams. 

Without You sold even more. 

Always Remember Us This Way = My All > Without You > Shallow

 

Mariah wins.

45 minutes ago, stevyy said:

incomparable... bc of how far removed they are from one another. 

 

I believe Without You would be at 2-3 billion streams if it showed the same commercial appeal in the streaming age as it did in the physical age. WY was like the 2nd or 3rd best selling song of 1994 in Europe. (and due to singles being singles, u know promoting albums, made Music Box the top selling album of the continent in 1994). It sold like 800k in 1993, 6,5 million in 1994 and the remaining 800k between 1995-today. 

Gaga's were still globally bigger. My All wasn't that big. All of it's success came from the US.

 

My All is one of the greatest songs ever recorded >>> the rest 

Mariah.

 

 

 

 

Without You catapaulted her career in Europe - it's crazy what that song did for Music Box 

 

My All and Without You are definitely better 

 

They seem neck and neck with how big they are

Mariah for all options