Agree about it being Britney and Janet 

My first thought was the Dixie Chicks.  

2 hours ago, cyberraga said:

The way y'all stay trying to shoehorn Katy into this. Her "hate train" is child's play. Getting laughed at for flopping and releasing parody-esque music isn't even close to being in the same realm as the abuse people like Britney, Janet, The Dixie Chicks etc got 

ok. But isn't it a hate train that you and your base have said she deserved. The same one you participated in  just because it made you feel.better about yourself, doesn't mean it isnt a hate train. 

 

During Witness and 143, Katy went through hate trains, sucks that you don't see it that way. Also there is a difference between being black balled and being in a hate train.

 

Also why are you so bothered I chose to say my faves name instead of yours, lets unpack that.

 

 

 

Edited October 1, 20241 yr by Phaunzie

Def Britney!

Jennifer Lopez in 2024?

Britney 2007

Mariah 2001

Janet 2004

 

those were nonstop mainstream news

Yeah Janet and Britney seems valid 

 

About online hate, i get the Taylor 2016 and Selena 2018 answers, for example Selena got tweets with like 300-500k likes mocking her kidney transplant, it was insane. BUT even with its massive numbers it was still way more "stan world" focused. Selena reached #1 on Monthly Listeners on Spotify in 2018.. not only female, overall 

So the GP clearly did not care

Taylor had a massive era and 1m debut right after it 

 

Even Jlo and Katy in 2024 seems like a better answer than them....

But still it doesn't come anyyyyy close to Britney 

 

Katy released AI songs produced by a rapist so.. yeah, she will be dragged. but she's on her peak as a performer and can somewhat do a tour apparently after Rock in Rio and Australia dates 

and i don't think the online generation cares enough about Jlo to the impact on her public perception be THAT huge. 

 

16 hours ago, Phaunzie said:

ok. But isn't it a hate train that you and your base have said she deserved. The same one you participated in  just because it made you feel.better about yourself, doesn't mean it isnt a hate train. 

 

During Witness and 143, Katy went through hate trains, sucks that you don't see it that way. Also there is a difference between being black balled and being in a hate train.

 

Also why are you so bothered I chose to say my faves name instead of yours, lets unpack that.

 

 

 

Except I didn't mention my fave bc I'm not delusional enough to think getting laughed at for flopping is a "hate train".

 

Katy is not going through a "hate train", let alone "the worst hate train" which is what the OP is about. She is being rightfully dragged for working with Luke in 2024 and being laughed at for flopping. This is not the same thing as being sent death threats and getting *actually* blacklisted like Madonna did after American Life, or Janet did after the Super Bowl or The Dixie Chucks did after their criticism of the Iraq War or the media scrutiny Britney got during/before/after her mental health struggles. 

Britney easily. 

 

Not only was her 2007 meltdown played for laughs on TV but Dr. Phil tried to exploit her in the process for ratings at her lowest point and even some kid's shows like iCarly parodied her downfall. 

 

There's a reason why "Leave Britney alone!" was one of the first viral memes from Youtube. 

Edited October 2, 20241 yr by Storm653

Have any of them really been spared intense media scrutiny? 

 

You can say Britney, Madonna, Janet, Mariah got it the worst..even Katy and JLO but like, the same shhh is still happening to the new artists like Chappell. Her interviews going viral are setting her up for the same stuff.