rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[djcalpal]

8 hours ago, 1989 said:

Change is a fan favorite? 
 

I agree about Exile tbh, she's a cute girl but Evermore >>>
 

Jail if you actually gave New Romantics a low score though 

 

As you should! 

I've been to 5 of her tours over the last 13 years and back in the day at least, people LOVED Change haha.

 

New Romantics is fine, I've just never seen it as a standout. Not a skip, but kind of gives Disney to me (please don't imprison me). 

[Brooklyn Baby]

5 hours ago, djcalpal said:

I've been to 5 of her tours over the last 13 years and back in the day at least, people LOVED Change haha.

 

New Romantics is fine, I've just never seen it as a standout. Not a skip, but kind of gives Disney to me (please don't imprison me). 

On another note - FIVE of her tours? You're so blessed. I've only been to rep and Eras 

[djcalpal]

38 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

On another note - FIVE of her tours? You're so blessed. I've only been to rep and Eras 

Yes I'm that old (I'm the same age as Taylor - it's been a wild ride growing up with her)! 

 

Speak Now tour was a life highlight haha. 

[1989]

1 hour ago, djcalpal said:

Speak Now tour was a life highlight haha. 

I am so jealous 

 

I've been to three - 1989, Rep, and Eras 

[swifthino]

trying to do this and it's way harder than i thought 

[Brooklyn Baby]

My true averages (without 11s or 0s)

 

Taylor Swift - 7.250

Fearless (OG) - 8.377

Fearless (TV) - 7.764

Speak Now (OG) - 8.529

Speak Now (TV) - 8.452

Red (OG) - 7.521

Red (TV) - 7.567

1989 (OG) - 8.531

1989 (TV) - 7.895

reputation - 6.633

Lover - 5.668

folklore - 9.170

evermore - 9.056

Midnights - 6.895

TTPD - 6.945

 

[Mezik]

On 8/17/2024 at 8:35 AM, Forever Winter said:

Submitted Ballots (74):

  Hide contents

1. @terrorblade

2. @tb6591

3. @SylMacPer

4. @PaloSanto

5. @greento

6. @NordicGuy

7. @Forever Winter

8. @The Music Industry

9. @Solaria

10. @pinkbowvintage

11. @1989

12. @Peroxide

13. @DevilsRollTheDice

14. @NEX

15. @Live To Tell

16. @Teen Spirit

17. @sanzo

18. @MidnightsAtPeace

19. @Avrileon

20. @CamiloPg_

21. @4Real

22. @KillingYourCareer

23. @a_d_22

24. @Namigo

25. @llikeh

26. @305

27. @Arrows

28. @skizzo

29. @Soobin

30. @Tusk

31. @Riverbank

32. @Theluckyone

33. @LastKiss

34. @itsjem

35. @Hurem

36. @Life Savers

37. @folkloreking

38. @gagacasanova

39. @Vespertine

40. @freakum.

41. @chosensparkles

42. @reputation1989

43. @D-@-N

44. @badidearight

45. @Velvet Night

46. @Enrique523

47. @Mr. Duff

48. @AshleyLovescats887

49. @ChapelHooker

50. @Gorjesspazze9

51. @halcyonday

52. @iamanearthling

53. @AbeHicks

54. @Axolotl

55. @jacobhalkohit

56. @PerfectSacrifice

57. @frankvert

58. @Venice B

59. @vinicius

60. @Fitzswiftie

61. @Yog

62. @Ampersand13

63. @Feanor

64. @wastedpotential

65. @Prismee

66. @idkwiam

67. @Schami66

68. @Støned

69. @G.U.Y_Del_Rey

70. @djcalpal

71. @Great Username

72. @Tedwards

73. @tjspy

74. @Mezik

You have two weeks (until August 31) to edit your ballots by going into the Google Form.

https://forms.gle/bNn6wDEC2wz4mkPc7

Please take advantage of this if you feel like some scores need to be edited and add COMMENTS on songs you love or hate!

 

Also, if you have consistent 1-2s across albums (example: 8-20 1s or 2s for TTPD or Lover), those scores will not count. Please double-check if your ballot qualifies and read the rules in the OP carefully.

Can you clarify with me if you need me to redo certain ones? I may have rated the Misc. ones low but that's because I genuinely hate them all..

[Brooklyn Baby]

2 minutes ago, Mezik said:

Can you clarify with me if you need me to redo certain ones? I may have rated the Misc. ones low but that's because I genuinely hate them all..

 I don't see anything wrong with them! You're fine.

Btw you can go back anytime and edit if you feel like you want to change scores, click "Edit your responses" and resubmit at the bottom. You can also use decimal points (ex: 7.5, 9.1, etc.) and add comments next to your scores.

[Mezik]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

 I don't see anything wrong with them! You're fine.

Btw you can go back anytime and edit if you feel like you want to change scores, click "Edit your responses" and resubmit at the bottom. You can also use decimal points (ex: 7.5, 9.1, etc.) and add comments next to your scores.

It would take me SO LONG to add comments/decimals.

 

The truth was, I find 90% of her discography fantastic ... so I did my ratings based off how much I like the songs compared to my 11s..  

 

May have been bias to my surprise songs too.  

[wastedpotential]

47 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

My averages:

 

Taylor Swift - 7.250

Fearless (OG) - 8.377

Fearless (TV) - 7.764

Speak Now (OG) - 8.529

Speak Now (TV) - 8.452

Red (OG) - 7.521

Red (TV) - 7.567

1989 (OG) - 8.531

1989 (TV) - 7.895

reputation - 6.633

Lover - 5.668

folklore - 9.170

evermore - 9.056

Midnights - 6.900

TTPD - 6.725

 

Wait our scores are remarkably similar

 

except I was kinder to Red and Rep and Lover and Midnights and TTPD 

[Brooklyn Baby]

9 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

except I was kinder to Red and Rep and Lover and Midnights and TTPD 

The thing is Red is my #3 album but it has slightly more clunkers than Speak Now which is consistent all throughout 

 

As for the other three, well 

[Bussea]

oh everbore stans im so sorry…

[Bussea]

1 hour ago, Forever Winter said:

My averages:

 

Taylor Swift - 7.250

Fearless (OG) - 8.377

Fearless (TV) - 7.764

Speak Now (OG) - 8.529

Speak Now (TV) - 8.452

Red (OG) - 7.521

Red (TV) - 7.567

1989 (OG) - 8.531

1989 (TV) - 7.895

reputation - 6.633

Lover - 5.668

folklore - 9.170

evermore - 9.056

Midnights - 6.900

TTPD - 6.725

 

The way this rate would've been a gag if we rated the OG & TV versions separately 

[Brooklyn Baby]

3 minutes ago, Bussea said:

oh everbore stans im so sorry…

 

Ur sick

[Bussea]

2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

Ur sick

This album gave me covid 

 

[wastedpotential]

7 hours ago, Bussea said:

oh everbore stans im so sorry…

Oh sissy, don't say that 

 

Please take that one back 

[Brooklyn Baby]

MIDnights songs placed way too high on the last rate. We have to change that 

[Bussea]

1 hour ago, wastedpotential said:

Oh sissy, don't say that 

 

Please take that one back 

you are gay 

[Bussea]

oh you gay too @Forever Winter

 

nevermore stans are LGBT!!!

Edited August 21 by Bussea

[wastedpotential]

6 hours ago, Bussea said:

you are gay 

And you're exhibiting a sense of poor taste that makes me sad bc I love you so much and want you to be better 

[Bussea]

3 hours ago, wastedpotential said:

And you're exhibiting a sense of poor taste that makes me sad bc I love you so much and want you to be better 

my bad i tried to listen to nevermore and fell asleep what were you saying 

[Brooklyn Baby]

19 minutes ago, Bussea said:

my bad i tried to listen to nevermore and fell asleep what were you saying 

Deleting your ballot asap

 

[Bussea]

31 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Deleting your ballot asap

 

Delete the album too

 

[wastedpotential]

11 minutes ago, Bussea said:

Delete the album too

 

Oh I reallY want tO say delete... something bUt I feaR I'd get Sent to pErmabanLand For that 

 

 

Stream Christ Loves Me and repent 

[Brooklyn Baby]

23 hours ago, Forever Winter said:

My true averages (without 11s or 0s)

 

Taylor Swift - 7.250

Fearless (OG) - 8.377

Fearless (TV) - 7.764

Speak Now (OG) - 8.529

Speak Now (TV) - 8.452

Red (OG) - 7.521

Red (TV) - 7.567

1989 (OG) - 8.531

1989 (TV) - 7.895

reputation - 6.633

Lover - 5.668

folklore - 9.170

evermore - 9.056

Midnights - 6.895

TTPD - 6.945

 

I forgot to mention these are my normal scores without 0 sabotages