The lyrics, melody, structure, instrumental, production. 

Not even top 3 on the album tbh but gays just love an upbeat song I guess

No because Jade Green is

that and Heaven Is 

Well The Architect is much better, so no. 

Yes, but not Kacey's

 

 

Jade Green and Dinner With Friends too.

8 minutes ago, Pendulum said:

Yes, but not Kacey's

 

 

Taste, their album is kinda AOTY tbh

Ruthless snatched it 

I fear Sway outsold but the album is QUALITY 

It's perfect 

1 hour ago, shookspeare said:

Not even top 3 on the album tbh but gays just love an upbeat song I guess

Sis the instrumental is very 70s inspired, the melody is catchy and the lyrical storytelling is dark and mystic. It’s very Stevie Nicks. I wouldn’t call it that upbeat tbh. So no, that’s not why it’s song of the year. 

Well yes but also Ruthless

Well no but Giver/Taker, Sway, The Architect, Heaven Is, & Nothing To Be Scared Of are!

Giver/Taker is  

blair witch project sounding bop 

 

Dinner With Friends and Too Good To Be True too

No, Sway is

what a weird way to spell

 

A-N-I-M-E    E-Y-E-S

It’s on the overrated track tier

The Architect outdid in every imaginable way possible

cardigan yes 

 

never heard cardinal 

So far, yes! I thought the lyrics were corny / cringy at first but I can't get it out of my head now.