It could be discussed 10 years ago. Nowdays It's obviously Ariana. 

4 hours ago, Caesar said:

miley hasn’t been able to sell a full body of work since bangerz no shade

Plastic Heartz had longevity and a total of 3.2B, it's daily streams are still excellent.

5 hours ago, Blue Monday said:

We’re actually just trying to get y’all to join us on Earth 1 and end this silly debate once and for all, but if you want to keep living in a fantasy world that’s your decision 

Not sure members getting their kiis from a troll claiming that Miley only has two hits () are the ones to talk about "Earth 1" or someone else living in a "fantasy world". Might as well hold your hands to that Miley Cyrus member spamming every Ariana Grande thread saying that all of Ariana hits are front-loaded. 

Edited March 10, 20242 yr by Scars

1 hour ago, Jude said:

 

 

 

 

Ariana is bigger at the moment musically and most of her career but Miley still has a huge career herself. Even though Younger Now was not huge, Malibu managed a top 10 hit and Plastic Hearts did very well and has had very good streaming numbers post Flowers. Her career may not be as big as her Bangerz days but she is still an it factor.

 

Many pop girls wish for either one of their careers

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by Into The Void

Why do you guys keep doing this to Miley. She’s nowhere close Taylor or Ariana. Will never be close to them even if she gets one mega hit once in a while. 

I was just telling someone yesterday that Arianators are not as charts obsessed as Swifties but it seems I was wrong.   

Miley overall. Ariana is just pretty girl singing about *** and sexual attraction, when Miley has done much more, more than a decade from now. She has grown and now is the real legend that Ariana cannot be with her music. I don’t even want to mention Hannah Montana, which was a cultural phenomenon. It’s funny how you think Ariana has done something, when actually it’s Miley who literally changed pop culture and will be remembered for many years ahead. Not to mention her songs like climb, wrecking ball, party in the USA that will last decades if not longer. No one will remember song called side to side or thank u, next cause they are just popular for few years and that’s over for them basically. Climb and party in the USA are always popular. The only one thing in which Ariana is bigger is the chart numbers, but it is because of young generation who likes listening to songs about riding a ****  

 

so after all, Miley 

Edited March 11, 20242 yr by Daglazzo

I love Miley but anyone saying Miley is delusional, considering her career had flop after flop from the end of 2013 literally until flowers smashed in Jan 2023. Flowers was also a fluke, look at how everything else from that album performed. She does not perform commercially well outside of gimmicks and stirring up controversy. Meanwhile, between Bangerz and ESV, Ariana had an entire career of smashery (ME until ES), numerous hits, and has been a fixture in pop culture since her debut. She is a huge celebrity outside of her music as well. It's unequivocally Ariana