when they came out,I was mesmerized by these 2 videos (and songs)

 

 

 

Which video do you prefer?
Which is more artistic/impressive?

 

 

 

Fighter easily/obviously. E.T. is try hard. 

E.T. is a visual EXPERIENCE 

fighter

ET has better story telling. Katy actually went to space too for the video! She got a noble prize for exploring another planet for the sake of extending TD’s hit streak! 

Fighter's vid was done better by Madonna.

E.T. >>>

Fighter, E.T. has very awkward green screen parts and the storytelling was subtle but effective.

Fighter because it was about her now dead ex manager Steve Kurtz. 

Same director for both. Floria Also did Hurt and The One that Got Away for Xtina and Katy.

 

ima gonna go with Fighter tho.

The Fighter video had nothing to do with the song at all. The Stripped videos were a string of Madonna cosplays. Fighter visuals were her rendition of Madonna's Bedtime story, Nothing really matters, Frozen.

14 minutes ago, banterfly said:

The Fighter video had nothing to do with the song at all

Yes it does . Just because YOU don’t get it doesn’t mean it doesn’t match the video. 

1 hour ago, K@rm@ said:

Same director for both. Floria Also did Hurt and The One that Got Away for Xtina and Katy.

 

ima gonna go with Fighter tho.

Some of their very best videos on that list! The one I actually don't really like all that much is "E.T." out of these 4, so the answer is obviously "Fighter" by default.

 

Fighter

i dont like any of them

12 hours ago, banterfly said:

The Fighter video had nothing to do with the song at all. The Stripped videos were a string of Madonna cosplays. Fighter visuals were her rendition of Madonna's Bedtime story, Nothing really matters, Frozen.

Yes it does. U obviously didn't get it and aren't paying attention to the video. Their is a lot of symbolism, the song originally was about her ex-manager Steve Kurtz who stole money from her and over worked her. 

 

Fighter for both.

The E.T. video was absolutely mesmerizing to me when it came out, to the point it got me back into pop music. The storyline is so good. Fighter video is also stunning with amazing set pieces. Floria Sigismondi >>>

Xtina for both 

for the ones who don't get fighter mv it's all about a transformation from a larva/pupa to a moth from dark to light to become who she is representing all she's faced in her personal/profissional life to get where she was in Stripped, when she could take control of her life. I remember reading about floria saying she was scared of moths and she's faced her fear to film it.

 

xtina for both. personally I think it's her best video.

Edited March 14, 20233 yr by theweekend

Fighter is the better song, E.T. Better video

9 minutes ago, theweekend said:

for the ones who don't get fighter mv it's all about a transformation from a larva/pupa to a moth from dark to light to become who she is representing all she's faced in her personal/profissional life to get where she was in Stripped, when she could take control of her life. I remember reading about floria saying she was scared of moths and she's faced her fear to film it.

 

xtina for both. personally I think it's her best video.

I second every word you said.

To those who claimed not to understand the concept behind the Fighter video I suggest you to watch the MTV Making the Video where she and Floria Sigismondi discusss it in more details.

 

 

Katy sweetie 

On 3/13/2023 at 10:43 PM, K@rm@ said:

Same director for both. Floria Also did Hurt and The One that Got Away for Xtina and Katy.

 

ima gonna go with Fighter tho.

 

On 3/14/2023 at 12:51 PM, Dark Miracles said:

The E.T. video was absolutely mesmerizing to me when it came out, to the point it got me back into pop music. The storyline is so good. Fighter video is also stunning with amazing set pieces. Floria Sigismondi >>>

Wait, I didn't know

she should work with more people, her work is Amazing!

I can just imagine the concept her and say Gaga or the Weeknd may do

honestly, she can be used for revitalizing a solid act's career, giving it a new perspective and such (at least visually)

 

Hopefully she gets a resurgence..

 

 

 

On 3/14/2023 at 2:58 PM, theweekend said:

for the ones who don't get fighter mv it's all about a transformation from a larva/pupa to a moth from dark to light to become who she is representing all she's faced in her personal/profissional life to get where she was in Stripped, when she could take control of her life. I remember reading about floria saying she was scared of moths and she's faced her fear to film it.

 

xtina for both. personally I think it's her best video.

Teaa

she has always done videos like this (so I wasnt surprised by her Liberation work)

but this video is the Real highlight of her videography

sad that people don't pay as much attention to the lesser hits of an artist's career. Deffo underrated imo