The white washing....  The end pose is probably the best girl group end pose of all time though

Edited December 2, 20232 yr by bunnyeyes

9 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Album Sales

2021: 574,445

2022: 1,984,556

2023: 3,369,049

 

Spotify: 

2020: 25M

2021: 275M

2022: 550M

2023: 700M+

 

Domestic Digitals:

2022 > 2021 > 2023 > 2020

 

YouTube: 

2022 > 2023 > 2021 > 2020

 

Album Equivalents:

2020 - 100k

2021 - 750k

2022 - 2.5M

2023 - 4M

 

2023 is the only year with a tour. Explain to me how 2021 was their peak  

 

i wish bulk sales mattered. but if so then birthday would be RV's peak

we need to stop pretending that girls/spicy/betterthings/drama are anywhere near next level /savage

 

 

They are all so gorgeous what! @Mel.

I'd think in terms of buzz aespa definitely peaked around 2021-early 2022, they were undoubtedly top 3 GGs (if not #1) during that period with all the success, the viral Winter GOT The Beat fancam, and the interest in them extending to the success of a random SM Station song (DCT) + Step Back

They have remained consistent over the years however (much to some users' dismay), and have even topped their personal records through album sales & now international streams with Drama. So while they'll probably never be the talk of the town like they were during NL-Savage I'd rather be consistent success-wise than peak and then serve a steep decline practically everywhere like some certain other girl groups

Edited December 2, 20232 yr by Billionaire

Also NewJennies making their way in to the top50 of AOTY year-end aggregate  Get Up is like at #44 right now, it's so deserved. Real TABS 

2 minutes ago, Billionaire said:

I'd think in terms of buzz aespa definitely peaked around 2021-early 2022, they were undoubtedly top 3 GGs (if not #1) during that period with all the success, the viral Winter GOT The Beat fancam, and the interest in them extending to the success of a random SM Station song (DCT) + Step Back

They have remained consistent over the years however (much to some users' dismay), and have even topped their personal records through album sales & now international streams with Drama. So while they'll probably never be the talk of the town like they were during NL-Savage I'd rather be consistent than peak and then serve a steep decline practically everywhere like some certain other girl groups

one of the more reasonable takes ive read. the buzz around them savage/dct/step back was insane. winter had viral fancams every other performance.

this is a big 4 flagship girl group though and id argue that you can be complacent with a steady string of local hits or start expecting more organic international slayage from them. they couldnt even outsell an arena in Los Angeles this year.

i still feel like drama is frontloaded, but well see when it outstreams Illusion

5 minutes ago, Billionaire said:

Also NewJennies making their way in to the top50 of AOTY year-end aggregate  Get Up is like at #44 right now, it's so deserved. Real TABS 

the fact that its :36 and is allowed to count as a stream to boost the overall count is

 

-

can we talk about how newjeans has a music video for literally every song they've dropped? visual artists  

Edited December 2, 20232 yr by Asscatchem

aespa needs an english album to promote in the hyper pop circuit first and then go mainstream or at least popular in western gay circles

13 minutes ago, Asscatchem said:

one of the more reasonable takes ive read. the buzz around them savage/dct/step back was insane. winter had viral fancams every other performance.

this is a big 4 flagship girl group though and id argue that you can be complacent with a steady string of local hits or start expecting more organic international slayage from them. they couldnt even outsell an arena in Los Angeles this year.

i still feel like drama is frontloaded, but well see when it outstreams Illusion

I know you have this weird vendetta against aespa and constantly try to relive 2021 but you need to stop lying. Your personal opinion isn't a fact and you need to give it a rest. Seriously it's every week with you. I will never understand why you need to act like aespa should just retire. 

 

SM needs to hire me for the setlist and Production design for the tour

 

6 minutes ago, Rhyme said:

I know you have this weird vendetta against aespa and constantly try to relive 2021 but you need to stop lying. Your personal opinion isn't a fact and you need to give it a rest. Seriously it's every week with you. I will never understand why you need to act like aespa should just retire. 

 

idg why people are so triggered by the notion that next level is still their biggest hit by far and theyve yet to surpass themselves.

did i say i want them to retire?  i just want them to push the bar. if i didnt care about aespa i wouldnt comment on them.

it was definitely not sold out.

Just now, Asscatchem said:

idg why people are so triggered by the notion that next level is still their biggest hit by far and theyve yet to surpass themselves.

did i say i want them to retire?  i just want them to push the bar. if i didnt care about aespa i wouldnt comment on them.

it was definitely not sold out.

No one's triggered. It's just kinda super annoying to watch you repeat something untrue over and over to the point even users who just joined call it an obsession. Push the bar? Next Level is great and a smash but it's a Fast & The Furious song revamped. Truly pushing the boundaries of experimental sound. Drama and Spicy could never. 

 

If you want them to be on the absolute top so you can brag about them

just say that. Otherwise forget about them and go stan Newjeans full time. Try not to turn on them too 

1 minute ago, Rhyme said:

No one's triggered. It's just kinda super annoying to watch you repeat something untrue over and over to the point even users who just joined call it an obsession. Push the bar? Next Level is great and a smash but it's a Fast & The Furious song revamped. Truly pushing the boundaries of experimental sound. Drama and Spicy could never. 

 

If you want them to be on the absolute top so you can brag about them

just say that. Otherwise forget about them and go stan Newjeans full time. Try not to turn on them too 

it's not untrue that next level is their peak. if you're annoyed then just block me, i couldnt care less because im not trying to be biased 

 

if i was a pure success stan id stan newjeans like Mel but i guess that accusation doesnt fit the bill

i still stand by my belief that aespa has potential to really shift the industry but theyre just cashing out on the regular sm idol playbook and not pushing anything atp

1 minute ago, Asscatchem said:

it's not untrue that next level is their peak. if you're annoyed then just block me, i couldnt care less because im not trying to be biased 

 

if i was a pure success stan id stan newjeans like Mel but i guess that accusation doesnt fit the bill

i still stand by my belief that aespa has potential to really shift the industry but theyre just cashing out on the regular sm idol playbook and not pushing anything atp

You're not trying to be biased yet you're actually denying them selling out US venues because you want it to be true they're not doing as well as others saying even though I linked you proof so....okay die on that hill. Drama > Next level btw  

 

8 minutes ago, Rhyme said:

You're not trying to be biased yet you're actually denying them selling out US venues because you want it to be true they're not doing as well as others saying even though I linked you proof so....okay die on that hill. Drama > Next level btw  

 

ehh are you from los angeles?

4 minutes ago, Asscatchem said:

ehh are you from los angeles?

No, I went to the other sold out Dallas show. 

On 8/10/2023 at 10:57 PM, Asscatchem said:

 

 

well...

@Rhyme btw heres how it looked like straight from ticketmaster the weekend of the concert after being on sale for months and stubhub was even more flooded so

4 minutes ago, Asscatchem said:

@Rhyme btw heres how it looked like straight from ticketmaster the weekend of the concert after being on sale for months and stubhub was even more flooded so

 

Sorry Asscatchem but touringdata > you anyday

1 minute ago, Rhyme said:

 

Sorry Asscatchem but touringdata > you anyday

more like ticketmaster > touringdata (bc obviously tour data has never been manipulated/misrepresented before)

 

 

53 minutes ago, Asscatchem said:

more like ticketmaster > touringdata (bc obviously tour data has never been manipulated/misrepresented before)

even if that map were the final sale count (which according to the timestamp it isn’t), why are we pretending that it isnt still obviously successful? people buy last minute tickets all the time, and that is a perfectly believable amount left for those kinds of attendees. 
 

acting like they’re pushing loossemble numbers bffr 

 

 

WONBIN GUITAR SOLO

 

Just now, cloudbusting said:

even if that map were the final sale count (which according to the timestamp it isn’t), why are we pretending that it isnt still obviously successful? people buy last minute tickets all the time, and that is a perfectly believable amount left for those kinds of attendees. 
 

acting like they’re pushing loossemble numbers bffr 

by the way crypto arena concert capacity is 14,000+. 9,500 doesnt seem like 100%

not them paying their best song "Memories" dust