not the Sunmi panning even in the K-TRL thread title... is it that bad? 

5 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

The way You always spread these lies, everyone would have dragged them HARD, they were dragged during RBB/ZZB/UU and then again when Monster and even Queendom got released, same as Birthday lol.

like even within the luvies here on ktrl those were and continue to be divisive releases 

 

just because some of us praise some of those songs doesn’t mean everyone will defend everything

44 minutes ago, Veiko said:

How can it be rushed if it’s planned before they even debuted ? 
 

First comeback is with a guitar and this one is with a saxophone imagine if all their comebacks will be tied to a different instrument 

i know it was planned before debut

just sayings that it feels rushed since they just had their debut last month

 

just curious as to why SM planned another comeback so soon

Edited October 17, 20232 yr by hallucinate

5 minutes ago, cloudbusting said:

like even within the luvies here on ktrl those were and continue to be divisive releases 

 

just because some of us praise some of those songs doesn’t mean everyone will defend everything

Yes, like RV discography is possibly the most polarizing one out of their peers, even, successful tracks like Rookie or RR are hated by some stans, in my case I don't care for Psycho lol. It's onces and Blinks who praise to the high heavens how perfect their faves discographies are

1 hour ago, Adama said:

Hope the Netflix docu will show us the mess behind the stage 

Seated This is going to top Destiny’s Child, Pussycat Dolls or Fifth Harmony dramas 

1 hour ago, hallucinate said:

not a whole notebook

leeseo kind and humble angel

Whoever is talking in the video sounds like they're mocking her 

Idk if it’s the songs/dances but IVE seems so much less charismatic than when they debuted 

4 minutes ago, Rhyme said:

Whoever is talking in the video sounds like they're mocking her 

and they apparently woke her up from a nap to sign the notebook 

she’s probably confused and can’t even say no to avoid being called rude

Edited October 17, 20232 yr by hallucinate

3 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

Yes, like RV discography is possibly the most polarizing one out of their peers, even, successful tracks like Rookie or RR are hated by some stans, in my case I don't care for Psycho lol. It's onces and Blinks who praise to the high heavens how perfect their faves discographies are

we definitely have onces who can critique when things don’t hit (like Shart Shaker and Scientist don’t get a ton of defense in here, and rightfully so) and tbh as annoying as it is I kinda get blinks blindly defending it because there’s not much music there to begin with

 

its just annoying to see the usual “sheep!!!!” narrative pop up unprovoked (or see it quoted, in this case lmao) 

Well... Sunmi isn't quite giving what I hoped for. The teasers, visuals and title were giving me TAIL 2.0 but this song is kind of janky. Maybe it will grow on me over time. The choreography looks nice.

 

 

It's giving Xtina Accelerate 2.0 instead of TAIL 2.0

 

 

 

Edited October 17, 20232 yr by Reginald

 

Wait MOTHERS  

Yeeun and the pink-haired girly  

 

20 minutes ago, Antisocialites said:

not the Sunmi panning even in the K-TRL thread title... is it that bad? 

its diabolical, probably the worse song of her whole career including bisides so yes I think a deserved thread title

I think Stranger needed actual transitions between the parts - the start and stop is too abrupt every time

9 minutes ago, Gaia said:

Idk if it’s the songs/dances but IVE seems so much less charismatic than when they debuted 

They have bops but their only good choreo is Eleven 

5 minutes ago, hallucinate said:

and they apparently woke her up from a nap to sign the notebook 

she’s probably confused and can’t even say no to avoid being called rude

I remember there was that article awhile ago about how Leeseo was signing autographs all the time but a whole notebook is actual bullying. Tons of respect for her to not snap after all these months.

IVE and aespa needs to hire new choreographers because the HYBE girls Lesserafim and Newjeans are miles ahead there 

 

the only good choreo of aespa is also their debut one which is black mamba 

Stranger was interesting. Let me just listen Siren instead

 

my god...  I mean I appreciate her trying something different, but it did not pay off that well  the chorus is NOT it

Listened to SNSD's Japanese discography from front to back tonight and **** me it still holds up so well, unlike most K-pop from 2011-2013 

 

You-aholic, Bad Girl, Beautiful Stranger, The Great Escape, Animal, Flower Power, Reflection, Paparazzi, Galaxy Supernova, Lips, Gossip Girls, Karma Butterfly and more.... The endless 10/10 bops. The cohesive pop electro, atmospheric sound.

 

I fear that no other K-pop girl group has something that compares to this album trinity

56 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

The way You always spread these lies, everyone would have dragged them HARD, they were dragged during RBB/ZZB/UU and then again when Monster and even Queendom got released, same as Birthday lol.

Girl bye, there are tons of Birthday sympathizers in here 

 

40 minutes ago, MusicFan98 said:

Yes, like RV discography is possibly the most polarizing one out of their peers, even, successful tracks like Rookie or RR are hated by some stans, in my case I don't care for Psycho lol. It's onces and Blinks who praise to the high heavens how perfect their faves discographies are

It’s cause it’s true 
 

Btw, Onces and Blinks in here are definitely less biased compared to Reveluv/Sheep, don’t even go there. 
 

I as a Twice stan drag S*gnal monthly in here for example 

Edited October 17, 20232 yr by Pluto2022

And speaking of that song:

 

Who thought this was a good idea???

 

Edited October 17, 20232 yr by Pluto2022

One thing about onces is if a song sucks we aren’t gonna stream (see Scientist and set me free) 

5 minutes ago, Harrier said:

Listened to SNSD's Japanese discography from front to back tonight and **** me it still holds up so well, unlike most K-pop from 2011-2013 

 

You-aholic, Bad Girl, Beautiful Stranger, The Great Escape, Animal, Flower Power, Reflection, Paparazzi, Galaxy Supernova, Lips, Gossip Girls, Karma Butterfly and more.... The endless 10/10 bops. The cohesive pop electro, atmospheric sound.

 

I fear that no other K-pop girl group has something that compares to this album trinity

What is SNSD? I’ve heard that name a lot here maybe I know them as other name?

Just now, Veiko said:

What is SNSD? I’ve heard that name a lot here maybe I know them as other name?

Girl's Generation  SNSD stands for the initials of their korean name

Just now, Dialamba said:

One thing about onces is if a song sucks we aren’t gonna stream (see Scientist and set me free) 

Lies 

 

I can’t stop me is a major bop and their digitals were poor to say at least