1 minute ago, lgaga1fan said:

The main vocal had literally passed away and they still sung live + ran circles around their peers lets not

ahh I can't wait for these legends to come back soon and save the BG industry once again 

I didn't know they're charting on MelOn now. 

I do not need HYBE Hogs coming around and calling SHINee overrated when every male group that horrid company has produced has been directly influenced by them. Just because they arent the most popular bg ever doesn't mean they aren't impactful. 
 

 

8 minutes ago, smates said:

Can you name them? I can think of great rappers and dancers (like his bandmate J-Hope for example) and great singers like Chen and D.O. but I just genuinely cannot think of someone who can do all of that without relying on backtrack during intense routines and also look good while doing it. Maybe I need to check more boy groups.

I can help that (at least for 4th gen bgs members) 

 

 

people love to shade minho because he's the weakest singer in the group

but he still sings better than most male idols nowadays and has a very nice low voice 

 

this song  

 

Edited April 9, 20233 yr by ItsJustMe.

You're all so messy. Can't we just go back to praising lessakurafim trailer. 

 

2 minutes ago, karlo_98 said:

I didn't know they're charting on MelOn now. 

Yes Korea is waking up. Their Rollin' is coming  

On 3/27/2023 at 11:14 AM, Adama said:

Just 100K uls left before they enter the top 10 of Melon !  

sis, your prophetic words   
 

 

number of ULs flies when you're the most talented group ever!

 

Whats up with all the crusty 3rd gen BG stans randomly coming at SHINee lately? It's not Key's fault that he has more vocal and dancing talent alone than your favorite group's entire lineup combined. I feel like I'm seeing anti-shawol clowns here daily recently. 

1 minute ago, discreetinside said:

I can help that (at least for 4th gen bgs members) 

 

 

to be honest Han is the first male idol from the 4th gen that comes to my mind when I think about a skilled all rounder 

 

JYP has some serious gems 

1 minute ago, Hazy said:

and you would put those capable idols you mentioned together with Jungkook? he’s able to carry a note while dancing (which should be bare minimum) but so are Blackpink even though they are no Mariahs too and they are dragged in here on a daily   

 

I won’t lie, I’m not that into boy groups so I won’t make any **** up, I had Stray Kids phase and they have more capable members than BTS so I’m not impressed by Jungkook or any BTS member like I was when I was first introduced to kpop 

 

but maybe boy group stans can educate us and give examples! 

 

also, when it comes to people like Jungkook, it just comes down to the star factor, not some outstanding skills 

 

and I won’t even start it with female idols and female western artists because it would be embarassing for him, but like I said, the standard is different for the male stars and it’s sad 

Yes? Outside Kei, Baekhyun and Taeyang, JK is obviously a better singer than GD and BI. And among all of them he’s by far the best dancer like, let’s be real ? 

 

Sadly singing and performing live is not the bare minimum in Kpop anymore. 

None of the Stray kids guy can outsing him live JK, did you saw their performances ? Who’s out singing him? Chanbin? And they aren’t touching BTS rap line or BTS dance line especially when they have Hyunjin as a main dancer Lmfao. 
 

And we all know here that I’m a blink and I love their performances, but I’m not delusional to say that they are on par with him. He can outperforms them with ease. Especially if you compare what type of performance he’s doing compared to BP. And Rose and him are on par in term of live singing (not the best among their peers). + He performed harder dance choreographies than Lisa.

 

 

SHINee is lowkey the only bg that matters.

 

literal excellence on all fronts (and backs ).

 

4 minutes ago, Century said:

Even their version of a useless visual outdances and outsings 5/7 BTS members. Be serious troll. They're directly the reason for boy groups having more intricate and technical choreo. Even your fav's fav talks about how every other active idol RUNS to watch SHINee rehearse.

Minho most definitely does not outdance Jimin, J-Hope, JK, or V Even Suga has a B-Boy background  Their choreo might have been intricate and technical for 2nd gen, but it's definitely not comparable to the complexity of choreo from 3rd gen on. 

 

I knew I would burst some blood vessels with this opinion  I'm not denying Shinee's legacy, I just fear times have changed and I feel like people look at their abilities through rose-colored lenses

1 minute ago, armink said:

Minho most definitely does not outdance Jimin, J-Hope, JK, or V Even Suga has a B-Boy background  Their choreo might have been intricate and technical for 2nd gen, but it's definitely not comparable to the complexity of choreo from 3rd gen on. 

 

I knew I would burst some blood vessels with this opinion  I'm not denying Shinee's legacy, I just fear times have changed and I feel like people look at their abilities through rose-colored lenses

No people look at their abilities from recent performances and weigh them against lip sync autotune twinks with two left feet. You're apparently blind and deaf though so I don't blame you for thinking that.

13 minutes ago, worldwide angel said:

so bc they don’t have a number one they don’t have western appeal despite racking up a plentiful of top 40 hits? 

 

they may not be #1 smashes but at least they can chart for more than 3 weeks 

Girl, the prediction says Jisoo is out of the chart. OUT. I am not asking for a #1, that's ridiculous.. did you all even read the first post I quoted?

 

I am literally wondering why she can't chart at #80-70 like her bandmates? And some blinks are mentioning remixes or VPN as if the other members didn't chart at some point.

The song is just flopping in the West, can blinks take the L without bending backwards to deviate attention?

Taemin is botched, I dont see the appeal at all

 

 

We need a live perfomance ASAP.

 

 

Feeling kind of wonderful, feeling kind of wonderful.

 

 

 

 

 

8 minutes ago, ItsJustMe. said:

people love to shade minho because he's the weakest singer in the group

but he still sings better than most male idols and has a very nice low voice 

 

this song  

 

ppl clown on him because next to SHINee he looks unimpressive but if you dropped him into any other boy group lineup, he'd be a universally acclaimed ace 

Edited April 9, 20233 yr by Century

5 minutes ago, Hazy said:

to be honest Han is the first male idol from the 4th gen that comes to my mind when I think about a skilled all rounder 

 

JYP has some serious gems 

Yes they did

 

1 minute ago, Century said:

No people look at their abilities from recent performances and weigh them against lip sync autotune twinks with two left feet. You're apparently blind and deaf though so I don't blame you for thinking that.

And where are these recent performances that show he is a better dancer than those members? He has NEVER attempted choreo as complex so the material is just not there for comparison. Just accept you are a bitter hag who cannot even accept the most minor losses for your faves  

I will never forget this SHINee performance where the backtrack wasn't playing for any of the artists during the performances and every single group got read for filth by netizens EXCEPT SHINee because they just sang completely over the backtrack while dancing  @ 21:40

 

Also peep Taemin's pants ripping straight down the crotch at the end.

 

 

16 minutes ago, Hazy said:

I had Stray Kids phase

 

Now hold on!! Since when? Spill the tea!! 

 

15 minutes ago, armink said:

Shinee has to be the most overrated group by kpop fans as a whole, and especially by sheep. Only Taemin is an ace like JK. All the other members are a tier below in dancing, especially considering Shinee's choreo has never been as intense as BTS.

 

And before the sheep lose their mind, yes Shinee can sing and yes Shinee has plenty of good music. 

Key is more well rounded than any BTS member

11 minutes ago, karlo_98 said:

I didn't know they're charting on MelOn now. 

Media are picking up their global achievements and records so Koreans have no other choices than check the song 

 

7 minutes ago, jqnetto said:

sis, your prophetic words   
 

 

number of ULs flies when you're the most talented group ever!

 

It was bound to happen after their good encore 

Truly in their Fearless era! 

I'm not familiar enough with Shinee to make comparisons but the given examples are not giving, I'm sorry  I know they are all better vocalists (Onew and Jonghyun in particular are phenomenal) but I meant performers and I just know any random person on the street would rather watch JK.

 

 

 

Also, Jisung is absolutely the most talented SKZ member but if y'all think he is a better performer than Jungkook, I'm leaving 

imagine how crazy of a group we woulda got if yves was also part of this new jaden group 

22 minutes ago, worldwide angel said:

so bc they don’t have a number one they don’t have western appeal despite racking up a plentiful of top 40 hits? 

 

they may not be #1 smashes but at least they can chart for more than 3 weeks 

Jisoo did not chart on the Hot 100. Like, at all.

 

thoughts and prayers tho